Economy & Policy

18 Democrats Demand Oz Explain Nine-Day Delay in $50B Rural Health Fund

Congressional Democrats gave CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz until Nov. 25 to answer questions on delayed $10 billion rural health awards, warning the money may flow to consultants instead of rural hospitals.

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

Democrats Demand Answers From Oz After Delay in $50B Rural Health Awards
Democrats Demand Answers From Oz After Delay in $50B Rural Health AwardsSchwoaze / pixabay

What's News

  • 18 members of Congress sent a letter to CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz on Nov. 19 demanding answers on a nine-day delay in the $50 billion Rural Health Transformation Program awards.
  • Second-year awards of $10 billion were announced Nov. 9 instead of the statutory Oct. 31 deadline; CMS cited an 'additional administrative process requirement.'
  • Illinois saw its allocation cut $3 million, about 1.5% from its $193.4 million first-year award; Alabama lost $4.1 million and Colorado nearly $3 million.
  • Five rural hospitals have closed or been downgraded since the fund was created, per UNC's Sheps Center.
  • The rural fund offsets an estimated $137 billion in Medicaid cuts for rural America over 10 years under Trump's budget law.

Eighteen members of Congress gave Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Administrator Mehmet Oz until Nov. 25 to explain a nine-day delay in annual awards from a $50 billion fund meant to shore up healthcare for rural Americans. The lawmakers, all Democrats, sent their letter late Thursday, calling rural care "in an acute state of crisis" and citing what they described as "an alarming lack of public transparency." The stakes are real: the fund pays out $10 billion a year over five years, and states plan budgets around it.

What went wrong with the second-year awards?

CMS was supposed to announce second-year funding by Oct. 31. Instead, an Oct. 30 agency letter said officials "discovered an additional administrative process requirement," and the awards were announced Nov. 9, according to the announcement first reported by KFF Health News. Nine days may sound minor. For state budgeteers it is not.

Illinois Rep. Nikki Budzinski said her state "got no explanation from CMS as to why" it received $3 million less in its second-year Rural Health Transformation Program allocation — a roughly 1.5% cut from its $193.4 million first-year award. State leaders have received no information about an appeals process, she said. Any delay or reduction matters, she argued, because states must plan for an "acute impact" from the loss of other federal funding.

"Those kind of delays prevent a state to fully prepare for what's to come," Budzinski said.

Who is losing money?

In year one, all 50 states competed for the initial tranche, with awards ranging from $147 million to $281 million determined by a federal scoring process. Most states saw funding change by less than 2% in year two. North Dakota and Iowa gained the most; New Jersey, Florida and Vermont saw the biggest reductions.

Most signatories of the letter come from states that lost funding. Rep. Terri Sewell of Alabama — down $4.1 million — and Sen. Michael Bennet of Colorado, which saw a nearly $3 million drop, spearheaded the letter with Budzinski. The letter warned the fund "lacks sufficient guardrails to protect rural hospitals at greatest risk of closure."

The reduction numbers are small in percentage terms. The absence of an explanation and an appeals process is the larger issue.

Where is the money actually going?

The lawmakers' sharpest concern is leakage. Budzinski said she wants to make "sure that the money isn't going to consultants, that it's actually getting to the rural providers that it is supposed to be getting to." The letter states that too much of the fund "could flow to large consulting and technology firms rather than supporting providers and communities on the ground."

Alan Morgan, CEO of the National Rural Health Association, sent his own letter to federal officials on Nov. 9. His association's analysis found state leaders are directing the money to local hospitals and clinics, he said, because communities are "relying on rural hospitals to be there to deliver care." But he conceded it is unclear how much of the overall fund local hospitals receive versus consultants. Federal data maps and press announcements are not enough, he said: the way states win money needs "to be articulated in a way that success can be replicated by all states going forward."

The letter asks whether CMS will build a searchable database tracking spending, and how officials will evaluate state performance and set future allocations. CMS did not respond to questions before deadline.

What is the fund compensating for?

Republicans passed the Rural Health Transformation Program last summer as a last-minute sweetener to offset effects of President Donald Trump's signature budget law, including an estimated $137 billion in Medicaid spending cuts for rural America over 10 years — roughly $13.7 billion a year against the fund's $10 billion in annual inflows.

Cara James, president and CEO of Grantmakers in Health, called the rural money "retail therapy for Congress" at a Milken Institute event this month. Because the same tax law cut Medicaid, supplemental food assistance and other grants that rural communities disproportionately use, she said, the short-term money would not "help sustain people" — and she posed a persistent fear: "If it's even getting to the communities."

The closures continue regardless. Five rural hospitals have closed or been converted into lower-level facilities since the fund was created, according to the Cecil G. Sheps Center for Health Services Research at the University of North Carolina, including one in Michigan that shuttered beds and now provides only emergency services to survive.

Is anyone getting answers?

This is the fourth congressional letter on the program. Democrats wrote to Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. in August 2025 about the rollout; Budzinski contacted Oz on Illinois' behalf last November; Bennet, Republican Sen. Susan Collins of Maine and others asked in June that funds be targeted to rescue rural hospitals and clinics.

"We haven't gotten full responses to any of these inquiries," Budzinski said. She will chair the New Democrat Coalition, the House's largest Democratic caucus, as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress — which means Oz's Nov. 25 deadline is unlikely to be the last word.

By Olivia Hart for Business Bearings

Source: gilmermirror.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,535 articles

Related articles

« Previous article