70% Get Corporate Gifts They Don't Want. AI Prediction Isn't the Fix
Gifts for Good CEO Laura Hertz says 70% of people get unwanted corporate gifts. Her fix: let people choose — 81% prefer picking their own gift.
By Daniel Okafor
3 min read

What's News
- 70% of people have received a corporate gift they did not want, per gifting survey data.
- 81% of people prefer choosing their own gift, per Gifts for Good research.
- In one campaign, roughly half of participants chose a charitable gift over a physical item.
- An employee given a gift choice directed funds to pay for cancer patients' rides to treatment.
Seventy percent of people have received a corporate gift they did not want, according to survey data on corporate gifting trends. That figure sits at the center of an argument made by Laura Hertz, CEO of Gifts for Good, who says companies are confusing algorithmic prediction with actually knowing people.
Hertz opens her essay with a case from her own experience. A young employee, offered a choice of gifts by her employer, skipped the candle, the journal and the spa day. She directed the funds to pay for cancer patients' rides to their treatment centers. Her mother was undergoing cancer treatment at the time, and the employee knew how hard simple logistics become during illness.
An algorithm would not have predicted that choice or its emotional weight, Hertz writes.
What does AI personalization actually deliver?
Artificial intelligence can predict preferences, personalize communication and automate interactions at a scale businesses could not reach before. Hertz concedes this is often useful. The risk, she argues, is different: as companies get better at anticipating what people might want, they confuse prediction with knowing someone.
Her prescription is narrow and concrete. Companies should give as much thought to the moments where human choice and attention still matter as they give to automation.
The corporate gifting market shows the problem clearly. Companies have long relied on standardization to create consistency at scale — identical gifts for every customer who signs a renewal, uniform rewards for employees and partners. Scaling appreciation this way can backfire, Hertz writes, because not every person feels seen or valued in the same way. The company may believe it is delighting customers. The gift may not land that way at all.
Sometimes the more personal move is simply to ask, she says.
Why does participation beat prediction?
Prediction fails for a structural reason, in Hertz's telling. Algorithms work from past purchases and stated preferences. But personalization has a second component the machines skip: participation, meaning giving people a say in the experience itself.
That can take several forms, according to Hertz:
- Asking an employee what kind of recognition matters to them
- Letting a customer choose how they engage with a company
- Offering options for how someone would like to be appreciated
The employee whose mother had cancer illustrates the point. Her company did not need to know the personal detail of her mother's illness to give a meaningful gift. It needed only to give her a choice. By letting her pick something she would enjoy or direct the money to a cause she cared about, the company created room for her to bring her own meaning to the gesture.
What do the numbers show?
The data Hertz cites from her company's research points one direction. Eighty-one percent of people prefer choosing their own gift. In one campaign, roughly half of participants chose a charitable gift rather than a physical item.
The outcomes vary widely. Someone chooses a traditional gift. Someone else picks an experience. A third turns the gift into support for a cause. None of those choices is more correct than another, Hertz writes, and that is the point. A business does not always need to know enough about a person to predict the perfect gesture. Sometimes it needs to create enough flexibility for that person to make the gesture meaningful on their own.
Should efficiency be the only metric?
AI will keep making business faster, easier and more personalized, Hertz writes. She draws the line at measurement. Efficiency should not become the only standard for a good interaction.
A personal conversation or thoughtful recognition — asking someone what they want and what they care about — takes more effort than an automated exchange. That extra effort is sometimes the cost of paying attention to another human being, she argues.
Her closing claim frames the competitive stakes: even with more technology for predicting what people might want, the companies that make people feel most valued may be the ones that also know when not to guess.
Original: giftafeeling.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,538 articles