Strategy

89% of French Say Their Country Is on the Wrong Track. That Statistic Is a Business Problem

Ipsos finds 89% of French respondents say their country is on the wrong track. Sebastian Buck argues bleak probable futures make improbable ones a pragmatic business bet.

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

The probable future is bleak. It’s time for improbable futures
The probable future is bleak. It’s time for improbable futures19661338 / pixabay

What's News

  • Ipsos polling across 30 countries finds 62% say their country is on the wrong track, including 89% in France and 73% in the U.S.
  • Edelman's survey of 28 countries finds only 32% expect the next generation to be better off, falling to 6% in France.
  • Research published in Nature suggests AI reduces idea diversity in brainstorming, favoring incremental ideas.
  • Pierre de Coubertin proposed reviving the Olympics in 1892; the first modern Games opened in Athens in 1896, four years later.

By Olivia Hart

Eighty-nine percent of people in France believe their country is on the wrong track, according to Ipsos polling across 30 countries. In the United States the figure is 73%; the global average is 62%. Sebastian Buck, cofounder of the future design company ENSO, argues that numbers this bad put the social contract itself at risk—and that they should change how executives plan for next year.

Buck opens his essay with a historical jolt: Paris, March 1883, with hungry, jobless crowds looting shops on the Boulevard Saint-Germain, marching on the Interior Ministry, and students barricading schools until the army intervened. He draws a direct line to Paris in October 2026, when grievance over the cost of living and declining public services became a national movement. The parallels are structural, he says: then, industrial upheaval; now, technological revolution.

What do the trust numbers actually show?

The Edelman Trust Barometer, surveying 28 countries, finds only 32% of people expect the next generation to be better off. That share falls to 21% in the U.S. and to just 6% in France—roughly one person in seventeen. Buck's diagnosis is blunt: the problem is not a lack of change, but that the change underway is not the change people want.

His skepticism cuts both ways, and it lands hardest on corporate planning. This year, he writes, many companies will bake artificial intelligence into their forecasts to drive efficiency—"a future that's very much like the past, minus a bit." He then cites a claim executives should note: growing evidence, including research published in Nature, that AI may decrease idea diversity in brainstorming. It favors the incremental over the radically new, making everyone's ideas more alike. That is a caveat worth attaching to every AI productivity promise on the books.

Buck also faults the training of leaders themselves. Business schools' case study method, he argues, entrenches lessons from the past; law and finance logic does not naturally foster the empathetic creativity that designs for what people want next.

Is the probable future actually destiny?

Buck says no, and invokes the "futures cone" from strategic foresight: plausible, possible, and even "preposterous" futures are alternatives to the probable one. His example: in 1956, Britain's Astronomer Royal called space travel "utter bilge." A moon landing became possible when Yuri Gagarin orbited Earth in 1961, plausible when John F. Kennedy committed the U.S. government, and probable when Apollo 10 succeeded in May 1969. Thirteen years from "bilge" to history.

He offers three principles:

  • Respond to crisis with creativity. He quotes economist Milton Friedman: only a crisis produces real change, and "the actions that are taken depend on the ideas that are lying around." The Red Cross, the Bauhaus, and the Paralympics all emerged from war's ravages.
  • Take first steps toward a preferable future. The 1950 Schuman Declaration covered just two countries and two products—coal and steel—aiming to make war "not merely unthinkable, but materially impossible." As it stated, "Europe will not be made all at once, or according to a single plan."
  • Be willing to look ridiculous, together. Futures professor Jim Dator's second law holds that any useful idea about the future should appear ridiculous. Buck points to the 12 men who met in a London print shop in 1787 to end Britain's slave trade, armed with petitions, lecture tours, and the Wedgwood medallion: "Am I not a man and a brother?"\n What happened after the 1883 protests?

Here Buck delivers his proof case. In 1883, a 20-year-old Frenchman of no great achievements, troubled by France's defeat by Prussia, traveled to England to study its education system. He concluded sport taught respect, fair play, and collaboration within rules. Nearly a decade later, Pierre de Coubertin stood at the Sorbonne—steps from the barricaded school—and proposed reviving the Olympic Games, dormant for some 1,500 years.

The audience applauded. Almost nothing happened. So Coubertin took first steps: in 1894 he slipped the revival onto the agenda of a congress on amateur sport, convened 78 delegates, formed a 13-member International Olympic Committee, and championed the symbols of shared endeavor. The first modern Olympics opened in Athens in 1896—four years after his "preposterous" idea went public.

The takeaway for anyone drafting an annual plan: the pull toward the expected future is strong, so Buck's test is concrete. Check whether at least one preposterous idea is on the table, identify the first steps toward it, and decide who will hold the vision while it sounds absurd. Whether boards will actually budget for ridicule is, of course, the part he cannot guarantee.

Original: en.wikipedia.org

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,216 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »