Money & Markets

ACE Seeks Ruling That eBay's $55.7 Million Settlement Is Uninsured

ACE Property & Casualty says eBay's $55.7 million harassment settlement falls outside a policy with $50 million limits, citing expected losses, contract breaches and California law.

By Grace Kim

5 min read

Insurer Says eBay Not Covered for $55.7M Settlement for Harassing Mass. Couple
Insurer Says eBay Not Covered for $55.7M Settlement for Harassing Mass. CoupleTumisu / pixabay

What's News

  • ACE seeks a federal declaration that eBay's $55.7 million settlement falls outside insurance coverage.
  • The excess policy carries $50 million per occurrence and $50 million in general aggregate limits.
  • The Steiners sued in July 2021 and settled the civil suit in June 2026.
  • Seven members of eBay's security team pleaded guilty to federal crimes related to the harassment.
  • The settlement includes $48.7 million in compensation, $6 million in eBay donations and $1 million from Wenig.

By Grace Kim

ACE Property & Casualty Insurance Co. is asking a federal court to declare that eBay is not entitled to insurance coverage for its $55.7 million settlement of a civil suit involving Massachusetts publishers Ina and David Steiner.

What does ACE want a court to decide?

ACE filed its coverage challenge in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, where eBay is headquartered in San Jose. The insurer wants a declaration that it need not indemnify eBay or any executives or employees because covered losses, if any, were expected or intended and resulted from willful acts.

ACE alleges eBay breached the insurance contract by refusing information needed to evaluate the settlement, agreeing to a settlement without ACE's consent, and accepting terms that do not allocate among several claims or between compensatory and punitive damages. It also cites California's prohibition against insuring losses caused by deliberate misconduct.

The dispute centers on indemnity for a settlement the insurer says was deliberate and procedurally unauthorized.

What does the $50 million policy cover?

The ACE excess commercial umbrella policy provides $50,000,000 for each occurrence and $50,000,000 in general aggregate coverage. It insures eBay's executive officers, directors and employees for acts within the scope of employment or duties related to eBay's business. It also covers bodily injury or property damage caused by an “occurrence” during the policy period and personal injury.

ACE says the policy sits above underlying insurance, including a policy from Zurich American Insurance Co. Its exclusions bar bodily injury or property damage “expected or intended” from the insured's standpoint. They also bar personal injury caused with knowledge that an act would violate another's rights and inflict injury, or arising from a criminal act.

Broad categories of insured conduct do not remove ACE's conduct-based exclusions.

How did the harassment campaign begin?

According to ACE's filing, eBay security employees harassed and intimidated Ina and David Steiner in 2018 and 2019. The Steiners published EcommerceBytes, a trade publication that reported on e-commerce companies to help sellers.

The employees sent vulgar and threatening messages, delivered live spiders, a bloody pig mask and a funeral wreath to the couple's home, and physically stalked the Steiners for two weeks, ACE's filing says.

ACE's filing says then-CEO Devin Wenig criticized Ina Steiner's coverage and advocated a communications strategy to expose “errors and bias” in her reporting. He enlisted the security chief, his team and other senior executives. eBay assured the security chief it would “embrace managing any bad fall out.” Wenig maintained that he did not know the nature or details of the campaign.

ACE portrays the conduct as a senior-level operation, not an isolated security incident.

What happened after the Amazon lawsuit article?

The campaign escalated in August 2019 after Ina Steiner published an article about a lawsuit between eBay and Amazon. ACE cites one exchange in which Wenig texted the communications chief: “Ina is out with a hot piece on the litigation. If we are ever going to take her down . . . now is the time.” The communications executive replied: “On it.”

According to ACE, employees then publicized the Steiners' home address, tailed the couple in a black van and followed David Steiner when he left their residence. They also tried to install a GPS tracking device on the couple's vehicle. A police report on that attempt triggered the legal proceedings, including an FBI investigation.

The attempted tracker installation brought police and the FBI into the case.

What claims did the Steiners bring?

The Steiners sued in July 2021, alleging a coordinated effort to intimidate, threaten to kill, torture, terrorize, stalk, defame and silence them to stifle their reporting on eBay. Their claims included stalking, intentional infliction of emotional harm, civil rights violations, trespassing, vandalism, civil conspiracy and tortious interference with business relations. The parties settled in June 2026 in federal court in Massachusetts.

ACE says communications show Wenig and senior executives encouraged the campaign. It argues eBay and its leaders expected and intended agents and employees to use wrongful means to harm the Steiners. Seven members of the security team participated, and all seven eventually pleaded guilty to federal crimes related to the harassment.

ACE's lawyer described the alleged reach of the conduct: “These were not the acts of a few ‘rogue’ managers. These were the acts of the people running and controlling eBay's operations—the people ….at the top.”

On ACE's account, the campaign reached eBay's executive center.

Why does ACE call the conduct expected and intended?

eBay also entered a deferred prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney's Office. The company admitted and acknowledged “that it is responsible under United States law for the acts of its officers, directors, employees, and agents as charged” and agreed to pay a $3,000,000 criminal penalty.

The guilty pleas and deferred prosecution agreement give ACE documentary support for its coverage position.

Who funds the $55.7 million settlement?

Under the settlement, the Steiners are to receive $48.7 million in compensation. That consists of $46.15 million from eBay, $2 million from former eBay CEO Wenig and $550,000 from two other senior former eBay executives.

eBay also promised $6 million in charitable contributions to nonprofit organizations. Wenig vowed to add $1 million for a charity dedicated to protecting First Amendment rights, in Ina Steiner's name. Together, the compensation and charitable commitments equal the $55.7 million settlement figure.

The settlement assigns most of the cash burden to eBay while adding nonprofit commitments.

What happened to EcommerceBytes?

After 27 years of publishing their newsletter, the Steiners closed EcommerceBytes in September. In their closing statement, they recalled: “Many people who relied on ecommerce platforms for their livelihood requested anonymity in communicating with EcommerceBytes about problems they encountered because they feared retaliation for speaking out publicly.”

EcommerceBytes produced seller-focused reporting for 27 years before the Steiners shut it down.

A federal court's ruling will determine whether ACE must indemnify eBay for any part of the $55.7 million, subject to $50 million policy limits and ACE's claims of expected losses, contract breaches and lack of consent.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,206 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »