Innovation & Tech

AI Agents Are Shopping This Black Friday — Just Barely

AI agents drive under 1% of retail web traffic this holiday season, Bain finds, as retailers split between welcoming bots and blocking them.

By Grace Kim

5 min read

The first agentic AI Black Friday is off to a rocky start
The first agentic AI Black Friday is off to a rocky startPreis_King / pixabay

What's News

  • AI assistants account for less than 1% of retailers' web traffic, per a Bain & Co. analysis of Similarweb data.
  • Only about 500 of 320 million Uber transactions in the final week of October came from AI agents.
  • Meta launched its Muse personal AI agent in September.
  • Walmart is welcoming agentic shopping; Amazon is blocking third-party bots in favor of Alexa.
  • Bain found AI search converts to a sale almost twice as effectively as traditional web search.

Only about one in a hundred online shoppers are using AI agents to buy things, according to a Bain & Co. analysis of Similarweb data published this week — and that number frames the first holiday shopping season in which consumer AI agents have genuinely been available to the public.

The headline figure: AI assistants represent less than 1% of retailers' web traffic. Ride-hailing and delivery platforms show the same pattern. DoorDash and Uber both recently said very few of their customers are using agents. Of roughly 320 million Uber transactions in the final week of October, only about 500 came from AI agents.

Adoption is climbing fast, though. The Bain report also found that AI search is almost twice as effective as traditional web search at converting into an actual sale.

What happened when a real shopper let an AI pick gifts?

Dean Mandelos, a 29-year-old therapist in New York City, asked Muse — the personal AI agent Meta launched in September — to find a holiday gift for his sister, who loves to cook. The bot recommended a set of knives.

"I think that it was giving some good ideas. I just think that the thing that AI consistently misses is, like, the social aspect," Mandelos said. "My first thought would have been that it would suggest a cookbook or something. But instead, it went right towards actual tools and equipment."

Muse had already proven useful to him. It listed and sold items on his behalf on eBay and gathered bids from multiple contractors for a door replacement job. But the shopping run hit snags: expired and sold-out listings, plus outright blocks from major e-commerce sites including Amazon and eBay.

"I would like to let it do its own thing," Mandelos said. "I need to have a reason to trust it more."

Who is actually using agents to shop?

Zappi, a consumer insights platform, surveyed shoppers and found 1% of respondents mentioned — unprompted — that they use AI to shop. Steve Phillips, Zappi's founder and chief innovation officer, said these users skew younger, wealthier, and more tech-savvy.

"That's not unusual for any sort of tech. They would be the first people buying Apple phones," he said.

Phillips likened the current moment to the early dot-com era, when travelers searched the web for hotel rooms and then phoned in the reservation.

"No one was booking online, but people were using the web, and I think we're in the same stage now," he said. "There is a massive trust factor there."

Amrita Bhasin, co-founder and CEO of sustainable supply chain startup Sotira, uses OpenAI's ChatGPT and Google's Gemini to find apparel and beauty products from unfamiliar brands. She still completes the purchases herself.

"I think the process of actually buying is not super complicated," she said. "Figuring out what to buy is where I face severe decision fatigue."

The takeaway: agents are winning the search phase, not the checkout.

How are retailers responding?

Abhishek Bora, head of growth at streetwear retailer All Star Elite, said agentic traffic — mostly from Meta's Muse — accounts for about 1% of his website traffic. It's unclear whether those agents complete purchases or just surface items for customers to click "buy" on.

"Once a week or twice a week we get a Muse purchase," he said. "It's small, but we have been optimizing for it."

That optimization means adding machine-readable data layers to All Star Elite's site so bots can better parse products and promotions.

Walmart and Amazon have taken opposing positions. Walmart is rolling out a suite of tools to make agentic shopping easier; Amazon is blocking third-party bots and steering shoppers to Alexa. Others haven't picked a side. Target CEO Michael Fiddelke and Home Depot's head of online experiences each told Business Insider their companies are focusing their AI strategies on the customer experience.

"It's the first Black Friday that AI can really play a meaningful role for sure, but it's not fully autonomous yet," said Gina Logan, a retail analyst at Kantar. "Two-thirds of shoppers are using AI for shopping at least sometimes, but over half still prefer to control their own shopping decisions."

Logan cautioned that a bad agentic experience could undermine a retailer's years or decades of investment in customer trust. Xavier Starkloff, co-founder and CEO of AI shopping platform Joko, argued that improving product discovery matters more right now than closing transactions.

"Agentic is definitely a game changer at a time like Black Friday because it's all about finding the right deals," Starkloff said.

Is trust the real bottleneck?

Logan compares the hesitancy around AI agents to shoppers' original reluctance toward the shopping cart. Stores once had to hire people to push carts around just to normalize them.

"And I think that just tells you exactly how it has to be with agentic," she said.

The emotional math matters too. Holiday shopping is a weeks-long event, not a pantry restock, and a gift for a loved one carries different weight than a trendy present for a co-worker. Bhasin plans to use her agents this season to find items at specific retailers, online and in-store, where she can knock out several gifts at once. Mandelos is testing the tech on friends with detailed prompts and a strict budget.

For his sister's gift, he's shopping the traditional way.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,592 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »