Innovation & Tech

AI Branding Tools Can Cut Trust by Half, Branding Founder Warns

Trust in content drops by nearly half when audiences spot AI's tell-tale look, warns Treebird Branding founder Jaci Lund — and color drives 80% of brand recall.

By Amara Osei

3 min read

AI Can Save Time on Branding. It Could Also Erase What Makes You Different
AI Can Save Time on Branding. It Could Also Erase What Makes You Differentmsandersmusic / pixabay

What's News

  • Potential customers judge a website in 50 milliseconds; up to 94% of that impression is based on branding design.
  • Trust in content drops by nearly half when people recognize it as AI-generated, per research cited by Jaci Lund.
  • Color carries roughly 80% of brand recognition and recall.
  • AI-generated logos cannot be trademarked or copyrighted, according to Lund.
  • Lund is founder of Atlanta-based Treebird Branding and an EO Accelerator.

Potential customers form a first impression of a company's website in 50 milliseconds, and up to 94 percent of that judgment rests on branding design. Jaci Lund, founder of Atlanta-based Treebird Branding and an Entrepreneurs' Organization (EO) Accelerator, argues that AI-generated branding is quietly destroying the credibility those split-second judgments depend on.

Lund, writing in an expert opinion column for Entrepreneurs' Organization, lays out the case in hard numbers. Research shows that when people recognize content as AI-generated, their trust in it drops by nearly half. Humans have an innate ability to spot what Lund calls the recognizable AI look and tone.

The mechanism behind that trust collapse, she explains, is a cognitive bias called the effort heuristic. People assign higher value to things they believe took more effort to create. Hard work reads as quality in the human mind. When consumers can see genuine labor behind a brand identity, that brand starts with a head start. AI-generated branding, Lund writes, "short-circuits that entire equation."

What does AI do to brand recognition?

The damage goes beyond vague impressions. Lund points to AI tools such as Claude, which she says often bleed their own brand colors into user output. Color carries roughly 80 percent of brand recognition and recall, so companies using these tools are, in her words, "literally training your audience to forget you."

The economics cut against AI shortcuts. Entrepreneurs turn to AI for creative work to save time and money. But Lund argues they end up erasing the differentiation that made them worth choosing in the first place. Rebuilding lost trust and recognition costs far more, in both time and money, than getting branding right the first time.

Where does AI belong in branding?

Lund doesn't rule out AI entirely. Her advice is to deploy it where it excels and keep it away from core creative decisions.

Recommended uses, drawn from her own practice:

  • Analyze data, identify trends, and handle repetitive administrative work, such as tracking engagement across campaigns or organizing brand asset libraries.
  • Feed AI human-written copy to train it on the brand's voice, then use it for drafts of emails and internal documents. Have it study rhythm, vocabulary and tone before it writes anything independently. Output still needs a human pass, but it beats a blank page.
  • Audit brand consistency by uploading a brand guide and checking visual presence across channels — comparing website copy, social captions and email templates against the guide to catch mismatches.

What should founders never automate?

Lund's list of prohibitions is just as specific:

  • Do not generate logos, visual identity or core creative assets with AI. The output can't be trademarked or copyrighted, and it likely won't be distinct. Her test: ask an AI tool to recreate your logo twice in a row, and you'll likely get two very different results.
  • Don't let AI write your positioning statement or value proposition. It can only echo patterns from every other business it was trained on, not originate what makes a company different. "That answer must come from you," Lund writes.
  • Don't ignore the tell-tale AI look — the color palettes, tones and layouts that audiences register, even subconsciously, as generic.

The through-line of her argument: design is the door opener that decides whether people stick around long enough to evaluate the business. The whole goal of branding is to create a distinct memory in someone's brain, and AI-generated branding increasingly paints that memory in a negative light.

Lund closes with a direct challenge to founders using AI in their branding today: is it helping you stay consistent, or just making you invisible? Companies that answer honestly, and rebalance their AI use before recognition erodes, will spend far less than those forced to rebuild trust after the fact.

Source: inc.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,136 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »