AI Job Apocalypse? Layoffs at NAB, Qantas, Canva Suggest Otherwise
NAB denies AI caused its sackings and Qantas's 850 outsourced jobs look like plain offshoring, argues economist John Quiggin on the layoff wave.
By Amara Osei
3 min read
What's News
- Qantas is outsourcing 850 jobs to India while claiming AI will eventually replace them.
- NAB has announced mass sackings in most years since 2010 while total employment stayed unchanged.
- ChatGPT launched four years ago, yet productivity growth remains minimal, Quiggin writes.
- Solow's 1987 quip: 'You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics.'
- Open-weight rivals DeepSeek (China) and Mistral (France) trail AI leaders by roughly a year at a fraction of the cost.
Four years after ChatGPT's launch, Australia's headline layoffs at NAB, Qantas, Canva and Atlassian show plenty of AI blame-shifting and almost no AI-driven job apocalypse. That's the argument from John Quiggin, professor at the University of Queensland's school of economics, who says the evidence points to old-fashioned cost-cutting dressed in new technology.
The historical parallel is blunt. In 1987, Nobel laureate Robert Solow remarked: "You can see the computer age everywhere but in the productivity statistics." Computers had existed for 40 years at that point. Real productivity gains only arrived in the 1990s with the internet, and they were short-lived, Quiggin notes.
Is the pattern repeating with AI?
Quiggin thinks so. Today's main economic impacts mirror the 1990s dotcom era: a stock market boom and massive infrastructure investment. Back then it was fibre optics; now it's datacentres. Both bet on future demand that has yet to emerge, he writes.
The recent layoff announcements, some explicitly blamed on AI, raise the question of whether the job apocalypse has finally arrived. Quiggin's verdict: the evidence suggests otherwise.
What's actually behind the NAB and Qantas cuts?
NAB has specifically denied AI played any role in its decision, and Quiggin sees no reason to disbelieve the bank. The sackings look like business as usual. Since 2010, NAB has announced a mass sacking in most years, sometimes more than one, yet its total employment numbers have remained unchanged even as many employees quit or retired.
"NAB's business model, like that of other banks and big employers, is to hire employees when it needs them and sack them whenever it is profitable to do so," Quiggin writes. "That's capitalism after all." He contrasts this with an era when big employers like banks gave and expected loyalty from their workers.
Qantas has invoked AI, but Quiggin argues the airline did so only to muddy the waters. The decision to outsource 850 jobs to India fits the carrier's longstanding strategy of doing over Australian workers while claiming preferential treatment as a national flag carrier, he says. The claim that AI will eventually replace those jobs actually weakens Qantas's case: if automation is coming anyway, why sack existing staff early and build a new operation overseas? Quiggin adds a jab at Australian politicians enjoying the hospitality of the Chairman's Lounge, hoping they give this some thought.
Which companies face real AI risk?
Canva looks more vulnerable, in Quiggin's assessment. The company runs a software-as-a-service model, charging monthly and annual subscriptions for easily usable graphics design software. That model worked well for users who don't want to wrestle with more powerful but complex packages. Now anyone who wants a poster for an event can produce one in seconds, specifying style and colour scheme. The result may be recognisable as "AI slop," Quiggin concedes, but many people will settle for that.
Atlassian's business model is also under challenge, though its software will be harder to replicate. Its applications focus on project management and organisation-wide data. Piecemeal AI use by individual workers is unlikely to replace those functions, Quiggin writes. AI might eventually enable the reverse engineering of software packages, but that remains to be seen.
Could the real apocalypse hit the AI giants?
The AI hyperscalers themselves aren't safe, Quiggin warns. Firms such as OpenAI and Anthropic, along with Meta (Facebook/Instagram) and Alphabet (Google), face cheap "open-weight" rivals like DeepSeek of China and Mistral of France. These models run only about a year behind the leaders while investing a small fraction of the money.
It's entirely possible, Quiggin writes, that large language models become like email: essential to daily life for many people, but not a source of profit. If that happens, the apocalypse will show up in the stock market rather than the jobs market — a prospect with direct consequences for investors still pricing in AI-driven growth.
Source: The Guardian Business
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,136 articles