Innovation & Tech

AI Will Never Master Persuasion — Here's Why That Matters for Business

An Entrepreneur analysis argues AI will never persuade on its own: ChatGPT and Gemini out-research McKinsey analysts but can't replicate emotional intelligence, tone-reading or charisma in deals.

By Amara Osei

3 min read

The 1 Skill AI Will Never Master — No Matter How Advanced It Gets
The 1 Skill AI Will Never Master — No Matter How Advanced It GetsOleksandrPidvalnyi / pixabay

What's News

  • The author argues AI will never persuade on its own because persuasion is 'shared action' requiring a human touch.
  • AI research capability now exceeds entry-level consultants and mid-level knowledge workers, driving automation at firms including McKinsey.
  • Asked about zoning reform, ChatGPT identified seven issues across progressive and conservative audiences and generated ten advocacy stories.
  • Gemini stated it faces limits 'whenever success relies entirely on deeply human emotional intelligence, physical presence or lived experience.'

AI can research, analyze, build arguments and tailor messages to any audience — but it will never persuade on its own, because persuasion, understood as "shared action," requires a uniquely human touch. That's the core argument of an Entrepreneur contributor analysis examining where automation hits a hard wall in marketing, sales and communications.

The timing matters. AI is producing full-length movies and solving previously unsolvable math problems, which makes automating marketing, sales and communications seem all but certain. Yet the author argues that understanding AI's persuasive limits will help professionals excel whenever they need to engage others — whether making the sale to a potential client or to a spouse.

Where AI already beats knowledge workers

AI assistants like ChatGPT and Google's Gemini have enormous strengths in persuasive communication. Their ability to capture, analyze and synthesize massive amounts of information is unparalleled, the author writes. AI can sort through data, spot trends and identify differences among viewpoints.

Its research capability now exceeds the skills of interns, entry-level Research Assistants, consultants and even mid-level knowledge workers — even entire teams of them. That's why many of these positions are being partially or entirely automated across sectors, including at McKinsey.

AI doesn't stop at collecting information. It structures arguments logically, supports them with facts and identifies counterarguments. The author tested whether AI would argue against itself: asked if AI should be eliminated, ChatGPT answered, "Probably not," followed by many paragraphs of nuance. Gemini responded, "Eliminating artificial intelligence entirely would mean losing transformative advancements."

The author, whose expertise includes housing policy, asked ChatGPT to frame zoning reform advocacy for progressives and conservatives. It identified seven issues, including equity and property rights, and suggested ways to navigate them with both groups. Asked for compelling stories to advance housing reform, it offered ten. The first: "The young couple who can afford the mortgage — but can't afford the house." A good place to start, the author concedes.

What does AI still get wrong about persuasion?

Three limitations persist. First, AI can't adopt what the author calls "the persuader's mindset": it's about them, not you. Counterparts become eager to work with you repeatedly only when you understand them, put their needs front and center, and show how you can meet them while meeting your own. AI can offer general audience understandings, but it cannot relate interpersonally — it's not a person. Humans can poke, probe, dig and explore with emotional intelligence in ways AI can't.

Second, AI's approach is logic-first, which clashes with how brains actually work. All the neuroscience and all the psychology show that humans are wired to feel first, then reason. Persuasion has to start with feelings before turning to logic. The models admit this. When asked where it would struggle, Gemini replied: "Gemini faces distinct limitations in persuasion whenever success relies entirely on deeply human emotional intelligence, physical presence or lived experience." ChatGPT emphasized that it cannot experience any of the emotions it would be responding to.

Third, AI can't bring the human elements to interaction. Humans listen to how something is said — excited or anxious — and watch for body language. The author's example: she grimaced when I said that — uh oh, maybe I shouldn't have said it. People can be charismatic, warm and exciting in sharing ideas. AI, the author writes, not so much.

The bottom line for leaders

The verdict is a division of labor, not a replacement. AI will only ever be a supplemental tool for persuasive endeavors, especially in business and leadership. The recommended playbook: lean on AI's strengths in research, data, logic and arguments, then build a human-centered, emotionally intelligent edifice on top of it.

Original: simonandschuster.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,136 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »