Alabama maternity closures amid a $50 million malpractice verdict
A $50 million Mobile County verdict against a cardiologist was cut to $6 million as Alabama debates liability, physician retention and maternity-care closures.
By Olivia Hart
4 min read

What's News
- Johnson said a Mobile County jury returned a $50 million verdict against a cardiologist and his practice; a judge cut it to $6 million.
- Monroe County Hospital closed its labor and delivery unit in 2023, Johnson said.
- Hospitals in Grove Hill, Shelby County and Mobile have closed labor and delivery units in recent years, Johnson said.
- Johnson said the Mobile cardiology practice also treats rural Washington County, a medically underserved area with limited specialist access.
- Texas adopted medical-liability reforms in 2003 and later recorded substantial physician-workforce growth, Johnson said.
By Olivia Hart
A Mobile County jury returned a $50 million verdict against a cardiologist and his medical practice earlier this year, according to Dr. Nina Ford Johnson. A judge later reduced it to $6 million.
Johnson, a Mobile pediatrician and president of the Medical Association of the State of Alabama, said the case followed a patient’s death. In the opinion, she argues that Alabama’s liability climate could push physicians toward states with more predictable rules and make hospital access harder.
What happened to Alabama’s maternity care?
Monroe County Hospital closed its labor and delivery unit in 2023 after decades of delivering babies, Johnson said. Families who once planned to give birth there faced travel of dozens of miles to another hospital.
Labor and delivery closures have occurred in recent years at hospitals in Grove Hill, Shelby County and Mobile, Johnson said. She cited financial pressure and staffing challenges as reasons. Her broader claim is that access to care is becoming harder across Alabama.
Takeaway: Johnson’s account shows Alabama’s maternity-care footprint is already contracting in several communities.
What did the $50 million verdict put at risk?
Johnson said the Mobile cardiology practice also treats rural Washington County, a medically underserved area with limited specialist access. According to information presented in the case, the financial exposure threatened the practice’s future. Physicians considered leaving or retiring, while investments in medical equipment were put on hold and continued care in rural communities was at risk.
The judge found credible evidence that the practice could lose several physicians, Johnson said. He warned that such a development “would have critical consequences for the provision of healthcare in Mobile and the surrounding region.” The judge also weighed the impact on what he called innocent third parties—the patients.
Johnson framed the patient stakes in practical terms: chest pain with the nearest cardiologist unavailable, and elderly patients facing hours of travel for appointments that once required a short drive. She also warned that a community may struggle to recruit replacements after losing physicians. The opinion did not name the cardiologist or patient, or provide staffing and financial data for the practice.
Takeaway: In Johnson’s account, one verdict can affect physician retention and rural specialist access far beyond the courtroom.
Why might a doctor choose another state?
Johnson said no single factor explains Alabama’s healthcare-access problems. Reimbursement rates are often inadequate, administrative requirements consume time that should be spent with patients, and insurance-related obstacles make running a practice harder. She described medical-liability exposure as another reason physicians may practice elsewhere.
Johnson said Alabama asks young physicians to build careers and experienced physicians to remain where services are needed. The stakes are sharp for physicians finishing residency, she said.
A new doctor may have spent more than a decade preparing for practice and accumulated substantial educational debt before choosing where to establish a practice, raise a family and build a career. Alabama competes against states she describes as offering a more predictable environment.
Johnson said patients and families who suffer harm deserve accountability, and liability reform should not diminish patient safety or physicians’ responsibility. Her point was that the legal environment also affects doctors and patients uninvolved in a particular case. That includes rural communities where specialist access is already limited.
Takeaway: Johnson treats liability reform as one part of recruitment, not a substitute for adequate reimbursement and workable operations.
What does Texas show?
Johnson cited Texas as a state that faced serious physician recruitment and retention problems before adopting medical-liability reforms in 2003. In the years afterward, she said, Texas experienced substantial physician-workforce growth, including specialists practicing in underserved communities.
The Texas comparison has clear limits. Johnson’s opinion supplied no workforce totals, pre-reform baseline or analysis isolating liability reform from other factors. It supports her call for Alabama to consider the Texas model, but does not quantify the effect or prove causation.
Takeaway: Johnson offers Texas as a precedent, but not as a measured forecast for Alabama.
What would Alabama need to change?
Johnson said Alabama invests in medical education, expands residency programs and encourages young people to pursue medicine. She said those investments will not solve access if trained physicians leave after choosing where to practice. She framed access to care as an Alabama issue rather than a Republican or Democratic one, affecting families regardless of affiliation.
Johnson did not specify a damages cap, reform model or legislative timetable for Alabama. She instead called on state leaders to address the liability climate as part of the broader effort to retain doctors. The test she set was whether reform protects access without reducing accountability.
Johnson put her conclusion plainly. “Legal reform is not about protecting doctors from accountability. It is about protecting patients’ access to doctors.”
Takeaway: Until state leaders address liability rules, Johnson said, Alabama will keep giving physicians reasons to practice elsewhere.
Source: birminghamtimes.com
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,404 articles