Money & Markets

AM Best Cuts JM Family's Courtesy Insurance Outlook to Negative

AM Best moved Courtesy Insurance Co.'s long-term credit outlook to negative from stable after three years of underwriting losses, while the auto warranty provider kept its A (Excellent) financial strength rating.

By Daniel Okafor

3 min read

AM Best Downgrades Credit Outlook for Courtesy Insurance, part of JM Family
AM Best Downgrades Credit Outlook for Courtesy Insurance, part of JM FamilyMustafa Sheikhmouss / unsplash

What's News

  • AM Best downgraded Courtesy Insurance Co.'s long-term credit outlook to negative from stable.
  • Courtesy reported underwriting losses over the last three years, AM Best said.
  • Courtesy keeps an A (Excellent) financial strength rating, and AM Best called its balance sheet strong.
  • Courtesy launched in the 1980s and supplies auto warranties and insurance for car dealers' parts warranty programs.
  • JM Enterprises founder Jim Moran died in 2007; Forbes magazine estimated his fortune at $2.4 billion.

AM Best cut the long-term credit outlook on Courtesy Insurance Co. to negative from stable, the rating firm said, citing underwriting losses the auto warranty provider reported over the last three years. Courtesy Insurance operates within JM Family Enterprises, the group based in Deerfield Beach, Florida.

Courtesy issues auto warranties and insurance for car dealers' parts warranty programs. The company launched in the 1980s and still holds a financial strength rating of A (Excellent). AM Best also said the balance sheet remains strong. The rating survived the review. The trajectory did not.

What did AM Best change?

  • Long-term credit outlook: downgraded from stable to negative.
  • Trigger: underwriting losses over the last three years.
  • Financial strength rating: unchanged at A (Excellent).

AM Best analysts attributed the losses in part to economic factors larger than the company's own operations: supply chain disruptions, inflation and labor costs. The bulletin names those three drivers and stops there, giving no dollar amount for the losses and no breakdown of claims, repair costs or policy volume.

That omission shapes how a reader should weigh the verdict, which rests on a directional signal across a three-year window rather than on any single disclosed number, and on a relative comparison with peers the agency says share the same strong assessment.

What did AM Best say about the numbers?

"The group has reported underwriting metrics that compare unfavorably to similarly assessed peers at the strong assessment level," the rating firm noted.

The test inside that sentence is relative rather than absolute. Courtesy is not being pushed into a lower tier or marked as weak. It is being flagged because its underwriting metrics now compare unfavorably with companies held at the same strong assessment.

Management has responded, AM Best said, and the agency's expectation is explicit: "Management has implemented mitigation initiatives that are expected to improve results over the medium-to-long term."

Why keep the A (Excellent) rating?

An assessment and an outlook answer different questions. The assessment measures current financial strength, and here AM Best found the balance sheet strong. The outlook projects where those metrics are heading, which is what changed.

The two signals resemble a credit card statement and a forecast of next month's spending: the first records what already happened, the second signals what management expects to come.

In Courtesy's case the signals point in opposite directions. The company keeps an A (Excellent) rating with a balance sheet AM Best calls strong, while the agency no longer accepts the stability of the trajectory that produced those numbers.

Where does Courtesy sit inside JM Family?

JM Enterprises was founded by car dealer Jim Moran, who died in 2007. He led a number of Toyota dealerships along with Southeast Toyota Distributors, and Forbes magazine reported that he amassed a fortune estimated at $2.4 billion.

The group grew out of dealership operations. Courtesy extends it into a product line that serves dealers directly: auto warranties and insurance for car dealers' parts warranty programs.

That business earns money while the cost of covering repairs stays below what policies charge, and loses money when it does not. Three years of underwriting losses tell readers the second condition has weighed on results.

What has to change for AM Best?

The agency's own bar for improvement is the mitigation work management has already put in place, which AM Best expects to lift results over the medium-to-long term. The bulletin leaves the three named economic drivers outside the company's direct control, which puts the weight of the recovery on those initiatives.

Until the underwriting metrics stop comparing unfavorably with peers, AM Best's negative outlook keeps attention on Courtesy's next set of results rather than on the financial strength rating that has so far held steady.

For JM Family, the open variable is whether that work shows up in the underwriting numbers before the rating itself comes under pressure. AM Best has flagged the direction of travel without changing the grade.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,538 articles

Related articles

« Previous article