Amazon warns NYC shoppers of up to $5 delivery surcharge
Amazon warns New York City shoppers that the proposed Delivery Protection Act could add up to $5 per order and force the company to consider moving delivery operations out of the city.
By Nathan Brooks
3 min read

What's News
- Amazon's Thursday customer notices warn of up to $5 more per order if the Delivery Protection Act becomes law.
- The proposal would require last-mile delivery providers to hire delivery workers as employees.
- Amazon said it could consider moving its operations outside New York City if the legislation passes.
- Mayor Zohran Mamdani defended the proposal in August.
- DoorDash agreed in September to pay $131.5 million to end New York City's pay-practices investigation.
Amazon is telling some New York City shoppers that a proposed city law could add up to $5 to each order. Notices appeared Thursday in Amazon's app and on its website, warning that the extra charge could apply if the proposal became law. Amazon paired that customer warning with a threat to move delivery infrastructure out of New York City.
The New York City Council is considering the Delivery Protection Act. It would require last-mile delivery providers to hire their delivery workers as employees. Mayor Zohran Mamdani backs the proposal, which he defended in August, giving the measure the support of the city's mayor.
How Amazon's delivery model would change
Amazon currently uses a network of delivery service providers, or DSPs. These DSPs are independent businesses that Amazon contracts with to deliver orders. That contracted structure sits directly against the act's employee requirement.
The act would require covered providers to use employees for those deliveries. For Amazon, that places its DSP model at the center of the Council debate. It also shifts the structure from subcontracting to direct employment, a model Amazon says it cannot support on the proposed terms.
Mamdani framed the proposal as an economic policy choice. "It's time to end the subcontracting model that puts profits over people and build an economy that works for working New Yorkers," Mamdani said. His support gives the proposal backing from City Hall while the Council considers whether it becomes law.
What does the proposal change for New York shoppers?
The immediate customer effect is an increase of up to $5 per order if the proposal becomes law. Amazon's notices warn of as much as $5 for each order, rather than a flat $5 surcharge. For a household placing two affected orders, the maximum added cost would be $10.
Amazon put the infrastructure risk in its Thursday statement. "If this legislation passes, we'd no longer be able to work with them, and we'd be forced to consider moving our operations outside of the city," Amazon said. The company thus presents the measure as a choice between higher order prices and the prospect of a reduced presence in New York City, rather than a decision that leaves its current delivery setup untouched.
For workers, the change would be more basic. The act would end the subcontracting model for covered last-mile providers by requiring direct employment. Shoppers would absorb any announced fee, while Amazon would decide whether to alter its local network. That makes the proposal unusually direct: a shopper-facing surcharge, a change in employment status and the prospect of a city pullback all hang on the Council's decision.
New York has already settled with DoorDash
Under Mamdani, New York City has moved against other delivery operators over worker pay practices. In September, DoorDash agreed to pay $131.5 million to end the city's investigation into the company's pay practices. DoorDash had previously opposed a separate city law requiring food-delivery apps to offer customers the option to tip drivers when they paid for their order, rather than after delivery.
That history gives Amazon's warning a local precedent. It does not guarantee the Council will pass the Delivery Protection Act, and Amazon's statement says it would have to consider moving operations, not that it had decided to leave. It shows that New York City is willing to extract financial concessions from major delivery platforms when policymakers push them on worker treatment.
The next decision belongs to the Council. If the act becomes law, Amazon has already told customers to expect a possible $5-per-order increase and has warned of a pullback from New York City. If the Council does not advance the act, the immediate surcharge threat recedes. Either way, Amazon has brought the labor dispute into the checkout flow, where the potential cost of the city's proposal becomes visible to consumers before the Council decides.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,492 articles