Deals & IPOs

Anthropic's IPO Puts Its 'Humanity First' Pledge to the Profit Test

Anthropic heads into this month's IPO with a trustee-controlled board, a 5% stock pledge and founders donating 80% of their wealth — but experts say the 'public benefit' math is wide open.

By Grace Kim

4 min read

Ahead of its IPO filing, Anthropic pledges to prioritize humanity’s benefit. Here’s how
Ahead of its IPO filing, Anthropic pledges to prioritize humanity’s benefit. Here’s howAI-generated

What's News

  • Anthropic plans its IPO this month and has pledged at least 5% of its stock to a public benefit fund.
  • Anthropic's founders have committed to donate 80% of their wealth and hold a 50.1% voting majority.
  • Five trustees of a Long-Term Benefit Trust vote through a single Class T share with no economic rights.
  • Only a handful of public benefit corporations trade publicly: Warby Parker, Lemonade and Veeva Systems, which converted in 2021.
  • Google put 'Don't Be Evil' in its 2004 IPO prospectus with no legal binding force.

By Grace Kim

Anthropic has pledged at least 5% of its stock to a "public benefit" fund, and its founders have committed to donate 80% of their wealth — commitments now heading into the sharpest test they've ever faced: Wall Street.

The San Francisco startup plans its initial public offering this month, and the pressure to deliver profits will collide with a promise made at its founding: to prioritize humanity's benefit as it develops AI. In its regulatory filings, Anthropic pledges to pursue the long-term benefits of humanity through responsible development of advanced AI. "We strive to help bring humanity safely into an era where transformative AI exerts tremendous and potentially decisive influence over a broad range of human undertakings," the company said.

But the governance structure Anthropic sketches out gives the company wide leeway to decide how it measures whether it's benefiting society, experts say. Like its rival OpenAI, Anthropic is a public benefit corporation — a legal designation for companies that pledge to balance shareholder interests with the public good. How that plays out for companies potentially worth trillions of dollars is uncharted territory.

"I think then the real test emerges if and when the question of public benefit becomes costly," said Sarah Kreps, professor and director of Cornell University's Tech Policy Institute — meaning when public benefit comes into direct conflict with profit.

What does the corporate structure actually change?

Precedents are mixed. Google famously put "Don't Be Evil" in its 2004 investor prospectus, but the words carried no legal force, and critics say the company left them behind.

Stavros Gadinis, a law professor at UC Berkeley School of Law, points to Elon Musk's 2021 takeover of Twitter as the kind of conflict a public benefit charter is built to avoid. "Let's say that Twitter's directors felt that Elon was the wrong guy to police the public square... But he made them an offer that was so high compared to what their advisors told them the company was really worth that it would be against their fiduciary duties to not sell to Elon," Gadinis said. "This is the situation that the public benefit charter is trying to avoid."

Publicly traded public benefit corporations are rare, and all are far smaller than Anthropic or OpenAI:

  • Warby Parker, the eyewear company
  • Lemonade, the insurance company
  • Veeva Systems, the software developer that converted to a public benefit corporation in 2021 after a conventional 2013 IPO

The structure also tends to deter shareholders because it hands more power to the board than to investors. And measuring "public benefit" is far harder than measuring profit — especially when AI leaders tout their technology as a cure for everything from cancer to economic stagnation.

"There are these echo chambers, the Silicon Valley bubble where they really think that what they're doing is for the good of humanity," Kreps said. Someone immersed in that environment might not even ask the right questions about how public benefit should be measured, she added.

Competitive pressure adds another fault line. Anthropic and OpenAI models have grown more circumspect, but open-source Chinese models "likely will tell you whatever you want," Kreps said. Her question: "will they start to rethink some of those guardrails? And what happens then?"

Can the Long-Term Benefit Trust hold the line?

Anthropic's accountability mechanism is a Long-Term Benefit Trust: an independent body of trustees with expertise in AI safety, national security, public policy, and social enterprise.

The mechanics, per the IPO filing, are unusual:

  • A single share of Class T common stock lets five trustees vote as a unit to elect and remove Class T directors, who will hold a majority of board seats
  • That share carries no economic rights — trustees vote but see no financial gain or loss, and can't sell
  • Three directors are elected by the trust; three by other shareholders, including founders holding a 50.1% voting majority
  • A seventh, potentially tie-breaking director is nominated by the trust but can't be appointed or removed without consent from the board's nominating committee, expected to be founder-controlled

"The LTBT's arrangements are designed to minimize the LTBT's and the Trustees' exposure to our financial performance and grant the Trustees sufficient independence to ensure we are striking this balance appropriately," the filing said.

Even so, the trust's reach has limits, Gadinis said. It "cannot determine the everyday decisions of these directors or the management of the company," he noted. "If they disagree, they will have to go through the effort of removing directors, and they may not be able to remove a majority."

Public listing brings its own discipline. Anthropic must report finances and operate with more transparency than a private company, and Gadinis argues that incentive may prove as powerful as any structural safeguard. "I do think that by being public, we are going to get a lot more information, because a lot of people are going to be asking questions, and companies will be responding to these questions, not only because they're required by security laws, but also because they want to build this kind of trust with the investing community," he said.

The first quarterly report after listing will show whether transparency and trustees can hold the line that a motto alone never could.

Source: Fast Company

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,178 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »