Money & Markets

Anthropic staff face up to 37.1% tax as IPO windfalls arrive

Anthropic employees facing "$100 to $200 million outcomes" confront up to 37.1% California taxes. Four advisors detail the strategies, from simple to esoteric.

By Olivia Hart

5 min read

Anthropic employees could soon be a lot richer. 4 financial advisors share how they can manage the tax bill.
Anthropic employees could soon be a lot richer. 4 financial advisors share how they can manage the tax bill.12019 / pixabay

What's News

  • Anthropic employees are looking at "$100 to $200 million outcomes," Prospero Wealth cofounder Eric Franklin said.
  • California taxes stock sale gains at up to 37.1%.
  • A client pledged $8 million in shares via a variable pre-paid forward for liquidity of up to 90% of value.
  • Business losses can offset up to $512,000 in income, the current IRS limit for married couples.
  • Exchange funds require a seven-year lockup; one advisor has never had a client use one.

Some Anthropic employees are sitting on "$100 to $200 million outcomes," according to Eric Franklin, a former Amazon employee who co-founded Prospero Wealth, a wealth advisory firm focused on tech workers. His firm has spoken with several of them ahead of an IPO that could break the record SpaceX set earlier this year as the largest ever.

The windfall comes with a catch. Selling employer shares to diversify can trigger capital gains of up to 37.1% in California, where stock profits are taxed like regular income, according to Business Insider's reporting. Early employees who received shares at a fraction of their current value face the biggest bills.

The typical position is dangerously concentrated. Thomas Kopelman, cofounder of AllStreet Wealth, who has managed roughly 10 SpaceX employees' wealth, said: "If you think about the average Anthropic person or SpaceX person, their balance is their 401(k), maybe they've been doing their backdoor Roth IRA, and then they own Anthropic or SpaceX."

Business Insider spoke with four financial advisors about how tech workers can diversify while minimizing taxes. Their tools ranged from psychological tricks to buying car washes. All agreed employees should first calculate how much money they actually need.

"You've won the game; you have all the wealth that you possibly could need," Kopelman said. "What do you want your lifestyle to look like and how much should we lock in day one?"

Timing constrains everything. Insiders are usually restricted from selling right when a company goes public. And no single product solves the problem. "It's almost never: 'Oh, well, let's use this one single product and boom, you're done," Franklin said.

What does simple look like?

The simplest move is mental. Alex Shahidi, co-CIO of Evoke Advisors, a $28 billion AUM firm, said the core error is treating the statement value as spendable money. "In reality, there's a tax liability that's not written on your statement," he said. Complex deferral strategies, he warned, "oftentimes creates unpleasant surprises in the future."

His simpler alternatives:

  • Sell in tranches across multiple tax years.
  • Build a diversified portfolio with gold, commodities, or other equities to cut dependence on employer stock.
  • Wait until the stock appreciates enough to cover the expected tax bill, then sell. "Then the market paid the tax for you," Shahidi said. "It actually works."

Why is tax-loss harvesting the default?

The first tool for most tax-aware investors is direct indexing: buying individual stocks that mirror an index, such as the S&P 500, then harvesting losses to offset gains while keeping index-like returns.

"That's a place where they can feel like they're getting something beyond what they would generally do themselves," Franklin said. "It's something that's easy to explain."

For wealthier clients, Franklin described direct indexing "on steroids" — long-short indexing, which adds leverage and short selling to generate larger tax losses or attempt to beat the index. The tradeoffs are higher fees and higher risk. "The bigger the portfolio, the more long-short makes sense," Kopelman said.

Can borrowing beat selling?

Loans against shares offer liquidity without an immediate sale. Franklin cited a client at a recently IPO'd tech company who pledged a third of their position — $8 million — to a bank in exchange for instant liquidity of up to 90% of the shares' value.

"You get the cash immediately, and then you can immediately diversify that and start doing tax-loss harvesting," Franklin said. That generates larger tax losses than investing on-hand cash alone.

The instrument was a variable pre-paid forward, a contract delaying the sale for 3 to 5 years while paying out now. The risk: if the stock falls over that period, the client loses money repaying it. Direct loans carry variable rates and their own risks, advisors noted.

What about exchange funds?

The classic diversification route is an exchange fund: pooling appreciated shares with other investors for diversified exposure without immediately triggering capital gains. The catches are a seven-year lockup, fees, and sometimes a waitlist.

"You almost never can get into them by the position size that you want," Kopelman said. "It's an option, but it's one that I've never had a client do." Franklin disagreed in part, calling exchange funds a good tool for money certain to stay untouched for seven years.

How exotic can it get?

Gabriel Shahin, founder of Falcon Wealth Advisors, a $1.8 billion firm, pointed to opportunity zone funds, which defer tax by investing in low-income areas. "The problem is you're not going to get the same juice for investing in an op zone as you are in a tech company, let alone a private tech company," he said.

Another route: buy a business and use paper losses to offset up to $512,000 in income — the current IRS limit on excess business losses for a married couple. Bonus depreciation rules, allowing deduction of up to 100% of certain property's value, amplify the paper losses.

The fine print is demanding:

  • Roughly 500 hours a year of participation to pass IRS rules.
  • A separate LLC with its own tax filings.

Shahin said investors here typically buy shipping container businesses, car washes, or convenience stores; solar businesses, which add solar tax credits, are the most popular.

"You can't afford to be cheap," Shahin said. "You think it's expensive to hire a professional? Try doing it yourself as an amateur."

If Anthropic's listing breaks SpaceX's record, the demand for exactly that kind of professional help — and the fees that come with it — will scale with the IPO's size.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,205 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »