At Least Two Refiners Declare Force Majeure; Enbridge Pipeline Slows
At least two Midwest refiners declared force majeure after tainted Bakken slowed Enbridge's pipeline. Trucks are filling Dakota Access Pipeline tanks, raising the risk of Bakken shut-ins.
By Amara Osei
3 min read

What's News
- At least two Midwest refiners declared force majeure, temporarily suspending Bakken crude deliveries.
- The North Dakota Pipeline has operated at lower rates since last week after tainted-crude reports triggered testing for organic chlorides.
- Enbridge said on Thursday it was still working to restore normal operations, with no restart timeline.
- Insufficient trucks and filling storage tanks could force Bakken production shut-ins, Jeremy Irwin said.
- The disruption could accelerate drawdowns at the Cushing, Oklahoma, storage hub.
By Amara Osei
At least two Midwest refiners have declared force majeure, temporarily suspending acceptance of Bakken crude deliveries because of contamination, Jeremy Irwin, global crude lead for Energy Aspects Ltd, said. The move comes as North Dakota producers move oil by truck to avoid shutting in production.
North Dakota oil producers are moving Bakken crude by truck as a prolonged outage on the Enbridge Inc.-operated North Dakota Pipeline forces them to seek alternatives to shutting in production. Some producers and marketers are hauling output to Dakota Access Pipeline delivery points.
“Some producers and marketers are trucking out production to delivery points on the Dakota Access Pipeline,” Jeremy Irwin, global crude lead for Energy Aspects Ltd, said in an interview. “Their tanks are filling up and they can’t get enough trucks to evacuate the Bakken crude they have, which could potentially lead to production shut-ins,” he said.
What slowed the North Dakota Pipeline?
The North Dakota Pipeline has operated at lower rates since last week. A surge in reports of tainted crude forced operator Enbridge to implement testing for organic chlorides, slowing the system.
Organic chlorides can corrode equipment and potentially force refiners to shut down operations. That risk helps explain why at least two Midwest refiners temporarily stopped accepting Bakken crude deliveries, Irwin said. Their force majeure declarations apply to deliveries affected by contamination, he said.
The refinery response and producer response run in opposite directions. Producers are moving oil toward storage despite a truck shortage, while refiners have temporarily stopped taking affected crude.
Enbridge did not immediately respond to a message seeking comment. On Thursday, the company said it was still working to return the system to normal operations as quickly as possible. The company provided no timeline for a restart.
Can trucking prevent Bakken shut-ins?
Trucking gives producers a route around the constrained pipeline, but the workaround depends on vehicle supply and storage capacity. Irwin said tanks on the Dakota Access Pipeline are filling, while marketers cannot secure enough trucks to evacuate their Bakken crude. If that imbalance persists, the result could be production shut-ins, he said.
Road hauling can reduce the risk of shut-ins only for the volume trucks can collect, Irwin said. Producers need enough vehicles to evacuate the barrels now filling storage, he said.
Trucking does not restore the Enbridge system to full rates. It shifts the immediate constraint to truck availability and storage at Dakota Access Pipeline delivery points. Producers must keep moving enough barrels by road while they wait for normal pipeline operations.
Where refiners can find replacement barrels
The Dakota Access Pipeline hauls Bakken oil to refiners in the United States and Canada. The disrupted North Dakota Pipeline normally carries Bakken crude toward those markets, but lower rates and testing have reduced its flow.
The disruption could accelerate drawdowns at the storage hub in Cushing, Oklahoma, the pricing center for benchmark West Texas Intermediate crude futures. As Midwest refiners tap inventories of light sweet oil, such as WTI or domestic sweet, the Enbridge system remains constrained.
That response would not resolve the contamination problem affecting Bakken cargoes. It would shift some refinery demand toward stored light sweet barrels while producers rely on road transport from the Bakken.
The outcome now rests on Enbridge’s testing progress, any restart timeline, truck availability and storage space at Dakota Access Pipeline delivery points. Without enough trucks or relief from the pipeline slowdown, Irwin warned, the disruption could lead to shut-ins of Bakken production.
Source: insurancejournal.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,503 articles