Britain's Rejoin Hopes Pushed to 2029 as Burnham Stays Inside Red Lines
Burnham's first big Europe speech keeps Starmer's red lines, defers any rejoin decision past 2029, and has already spawned two anti-rejoin groups claiming £750m a week in costs.
By Daniel Okafor
4 min read

What's News
- Burnham's speech rules out customs union, single market or freedom of movement moves before the next parliament — no rejoin decision before 2029.
- Friday's UK-EU summit covers food and agricultural access, linked carbon markets and a youth mobility scheme.
- Two anti-rejoin groups, Stay Out and Enough Official, claim rejoining would cost Britain £750m a week.
- Burnham, 56, has said only that he hopes Britain rejoins the EU in his lifetime — possibly around 2060.
- Roughly half of Burnham's MPs represent constituencies that voted Leave in 2016.
Britain will not move toward rejoining the EU before 2029 at the earliest, if Andy Burnham's first major speech on Europe is the guide. Burnham, who became British prime minister this summer, delivered the address on Monday evening at London's Guildhall. Timothy Garton Ash, the historian and Guardian columnist who analyzed the speech, judged it "a disappointment" — both cautious and "curiously old-fashioned".
The numbers behind the caution are political, not economic. Roughly half of Burnham's cabinet does not want even to mention Brexit, according to Garton Ash. Roughly half of his MPs sit in constituencies that voted Leave in 2016. The public thinks Brexit was a mistake but dreads reopening the argument, and doubts it would vote to rejoin without the old opt-outs from the euro and the Schengen free travel area.
What did the speech actually promise?
Burnham said: "we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years". He followed it with "the hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain". Garton Ash reads the pairing as hedged: it implies a soft Brexit might be acceptable.
The concrete commitments arrive at Friday's UK-EU summit:
- easier access for food and agricultural products
- linking the UK and EU carbon emissions markets
- a youth mobility scheme
Everything else in this parliament stays within Keir Starmer's old "red lines": no customs union, no single market, no freedom of movement. Burnham will explore "options for our long-term relationship" with the EU, "to inform decisions in the next parliament". Unless an early election intervenes, that means nothing before 2029.
Burnham himself has only said in interviews that he hopes Britain rejoins the EU in his lifetime. He is 56. Garton Ash notes that could mean waiting until roughly 2060.
Why did the speech feel dated?
Garton Ash counted nine references to Britain "leading". He also flagged the speech's central device: the "Makerfield test", named for Burnham's constituency, which voted Leave in 2016. The test asks only what delivers economic benefits to hard-pressed voters there. Defence and Ukraine support sat entirely apart from the wider European security picture, which Garton Ash argues self-evidently involves the EU.
Oddest of all, he writes, was Burnham's reach back to Winston Churchill's 1948 speech about Britain at the intersection of three majestic circles. Burnham skipped past the first circle, "the British Commonwealth and Empire", and — for obvious reasons, Garton Ash says, referring to not offending "the egomaniac in the White House" — the second, "the English-speaking world" anchored by the US. Churchill's third circle, "United Europe", received visionary treatment long before the EU existed.
At Guildhall, the most European elements on display were the Polish vodka served by the lord mayor, Bronek Masojada, and a few Dutch words he addressed to the prime minister's wife, Marie-France van Heel. Burnham spoke of a reset "with Europe", as though Britain were not itself part of Europe.
Who is already mobilizing against rejoining?
Two anti-rejoin pressure groups have launched in response to Burnham's tentative reopening of the issue: one called Stay Out, the other Enough Official. Backed by surviving Brexit veterans, they claim rejoining would cost Britain £750m a week. Garton Ash sketches the nightmare scenario: Boris Johnson, Michael Gove, Jacob Rees-Mogg and Liz Truss emerging "like a gaggle of the undead" from a red battlebus promising the EU would "steal £750m a week from the NHS".
Gove, whom Garton Ash calls "the Iago of Brexit", warns any move toward rejoining would "commit the country to another decade of fractious negotiations". Garton Ash's rebuttal: that decade is coming regardless, because both Britain and the EU keep changing, and the relationship with Britain's largest trading partner will need constant negotiation no matter what.
What is the realistic case for rejoining?
Rationally, Garton Ash has "no doubt" full membership would benefit both sides. Britain holds assets Europe needs: most of its best universities, leading AI startups, financial services, the creative industries and, he adds, "supposedly super spooks". But politics on both sides of the Channel make that outcome very difficult.
He also counsels patience toward Burnham's slow exploration of options, and not only for tactical reasons. After Europe's megacycle of elections in 2026 and 2027, an EU with a President Marine Le Pen in France, a centre-right and far-right coalition in Spain, hard-right governments in Poland and Italy, and the AfD setting the pace in Germany "may be a very different proposition". Waiting may not be a failure of nerve. It may be a bet on who governs Europe next.
Source: theguardian.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,226 articles