Burned-Out VP Quit at 63 After 24 Years, Went Consulting
At 63, Ava Brenengen left a 24-year VP role at a healthcare trade association, citing burnout. Her consulting income bridges COBRA until Medicare and defers Social Security to 65.
By Olivia Hart
3 min read

What's News
- Ava Brenengen quit her VP role at 63 after 24 years at a national healthcare trade association
- A financial advisor structured consulting income to cover COBRA until Medicare and defer Social Security to 65
- She registered an LLC and launched a low-budget website after a few months of rest
- Her exit decision followed paying the final tuition installment for her daughter's last college semester
Ava Brenengen walked away from a 24-year run as vice president of communications and public relations at a national healthcare trade association at 63, because chronic stress had made the chime of a Teams message trigger, in her words, "a jolt of panic."
Her exit plan was hatched in a January snowstorm, while digging her car out of an icy airport hotel parking lot before a flight to a New Orleans retreat. She made it to the retreat. The only idea that consumed her there was stepping down.
She was not, however, ready for full retirement. She calls what came next a "soft retirement" — a consulting practice built around the tasks she enjoyed and stripped of the rest.
What did burnout actually look like?
The mental machinery of work that was once second nature — deadlines, project management, back-to-back Zoom meetings — became draining, Brenengen writes in a first-person account for Business Insider. Business travel degraded. She once shampooed her hair with body lotion because the bottle labels' print was too small to read.
Her feet ached from heels. To counter ageism, she spent a fortune each month coloring the gray out of her hair. Burnout, she concedes, was a convenient term; she also sensed something deeper.
The takeaway: the symptoms ran from the physical to the psychological, and the label understated the problem.
How did she structure the exit?
Brenengen had stumbled through prior career transitions — news producer, Capitol Hill aide, C-suite nonprofit executive — on what she calls blind faith. Ending full-time work demanded more than winging it. She examined her timetable and finances and prioritized health and personal growth.
A financial advisor told her a consulting business could generate enough monthly income to cover COBRA health-insurance payments until Medicare kicked in, and to defer Social Security until age 65. The sequencing mattered: healthcare coverage and benefit timing, not salary replacement, anchored the plan.
The trigger was family, not finance. After her daughter began her final semester in college, Brenengen paid the last tuition installment and told her employer she was ready to hand over her role.
The takeaway: the exit rested on a benefits bridge, not on a large consulting income.
Why was execution harder than planning?
After a few months of rest, she registered as an LLC and launched a low-budget website. Planning was easy, she writes; execution was complicated. She found steady, gratifying work for an organization led by a CEO whose leadership and advocacy she admired. But she needed more clients to boost income, and her motivation to drum up new business was low.
Naming and promoting her value as a consultant was hard — even to colleagues who knew her track record. Operating solo, without an executive title and a large organization behind her, has been humbling. Reporters who once sought her out as a source now receive pitches from a personal email address. "I've lost the 'street cred,'" she writes.
Imposter syndrome, she says, does not quite capture the unmoored feeling; she was fiercely protective of a newer, excavated self she had just unearthed.
The takeaway: the credential premium she spent decades building did not transfer to sole-operator consulting.
What has soft retirement given back?
Soft retirement granted time to reckon with traumas that festered on the edge of awareness while she buried herself in work. She now leaves her smartphone in another room each morning and journals. She recently wrote, for the first time with courage she says, about surviving a brutal divorce after 20 years of marriage that forced her and her daughter to move from their family horse farm to a small apartment over a barn.
She frames that emotional work through what New York Times columnist David Brooks calls "re-storying" — taking a "fragmented life and slowly cohering it into a new narrative."
She may not be drawing a big paycheck, Brenengen writes, but she no longer needs to be tethered to a title to understand who she is becoming. For executives weighing a similar step, the case is candid about the trade: income and status fall; recovery and autonomy rise.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,535 articles