Economy & Policy

Business groups put $4 billion year-one price tag on trust tax

The Business Council puts a $4 billion first-year cost on Labor's 30% minimum tax on discretionary trusts, up from $920 million, as the government hunts Senate votes.

By Daniel Okafor

3 min read

Labor downplays trust changes as businesses warn of $4 billion “year one” hit
Labor downplays trust changes as businesses warn of $4 billion “year one” hitpierre9x6 / pixabay

What's News

  • Business Council of Australia puts first-year cost to businesses at about $4 billion.
  • Treasury advice during a Senate inquiry lifted the estimated annual tax hit from $920 million to $1.73 billion.
  • The proposed minimum tax rate on some discretionary trusts is 30%.
  • Penny Wong told the Senate on Monday that fewer than one in 10 small businesses use trusts.
  • The government must pass the measure in the final two sitting weeks of the year.

Australian businesses face a combined $4 billion bill in the first year of the federal government's proposed tax on discretionary trusts, according to Business Council of Australia chief executive Bran Black. The figure stacks a $1.73 billion annual tax cost on top of $2.3 billion in first-year compliance costs.

The government wants parliament to approve a minimum 30% tax rate on some discretionary trusts during the final two sitting weeks of the year. The measure is a budget item. It cannot pass without support from either the Coalition or the Greens, and both parties have voiced reservations.

What changed between May and now?

The cost estimate has nearly doubled since the policy was unveiled in May. At launch, the Business Council put the annual tax impact at $920 million. Advice from Treasury, delivered during a Senate inquiry, pushed the council's forecast to $1.73 billion a year.

Black laid out the arithmetic for reporters in Canberra on Monday: "When you combine that with the $2.3 billion that businesses will have to pay in order to comply with these changes in the first year of operation, what that means is that Australian businesses will face a total year one bill of about $4 billion."

He argued the timing makes the burden worse. "That comes at a time when businesses can least afford it," Black said. "We know inflation is up. We know that interest rates are up."

How does the government answer the criticism?

Senior ministers have rejected claims that the tax will reach most small businesses. Foreign Minister Penny Wong told the Senate on Monday that fewer than one in 10 small businesses use trusts in their operations.

She framed the reform as an economic necessity and pointed to escape routes for affected structures. "The government has made clear why it is important that we progress these tax reforms, and why it matters for the economy, and why it matters for jobs," Wong told parliament.

"There are a range of options for existing trusts which the treasurer has flagged. They include restructuring."

That restructuring option is the government's implicit answer to the compliance-cost argument: businesses that reorganise their affairs early can reduce their exposure, though the Business Council's $2.3 billion figure suggests the industry expects that adjustment itself to carry a heavy price in year one.

Why does the dispute over trusts matter?

Black said the fight turns on a false picture of how trusts work. "It goes to a fundamental misconception associated with trusts, and that is that they are used for illegitimate purposes," he said. "Trusts are used as entirely legitimate vehicles in order to manage affairs."

The Business Council's case rests on that framing: if trusts are ordinary business structures rather than avoidance devices, then a 30% minimum tax punishes legitimate arrangements and forces costly restructuring.

The government's case rests on the opposite framing, backed by Wong's one-in-10 statistic: the tax targets a minority structure whose benefits the budget can no longer carry.

Where do the Greens stand?

The government's clearest path to passage may run through the Greens. Greens leader David Shoebridge said his party remains open to the reforms, while criticising the draft legislation as internally inconsistent.

"Labor on one hand are saying they want to close some loopholes with trusts – and that's good policy – but then, in the same legislation, they introduce a whole new loophole," he told reporters.

He also signalled a negotiating stance rather than outright opposition: "If you want this legislation through this year, there's a pathway there."

What happens in the next two weeks?

The arithmetic now decides the outcome. Labor needs one of two reluctant partners before the sitting fortnight ends, and both the Coalition and the Greens have reasons to bargain — the Coalition on business-cost grounds, the Greens on the loopholes it says the bill still contains. With Treasury's revised numbers now on the public record, any deal will be priced against a $4 billion first-year bill that the Business Council will keep citing until the vote.

Source: smartcompany.com.au

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,189 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »