Economy & Policy

California's Incoming Insurance Chief Kim to Review Lara's Reforms

Jane Kim won 54.2% of the vote to become California insurance commissioner and plans to review Lara's Sustainable Insurance Strategy and a public wildfire plan.

By Daniel Okafor

5 min read

Incoming California Commissioner Kim to Review Lara’s Insurance Reforms
Incoming California Commissioner Kim to Review Lara’s Insurance Reforms12019 / pixabay

What's News

  • Jane Kim won 54.2% of the vote, leading Ben Allen by more than 900,000 votes.
  • Kim proposes a mandatory public wildfire insurance program for existing California homes.
  • The P/C industry posted a $170 billion net income jump after its first full-year underwriting gain in four years.
  • California's homeowners market averaged a 109.7% combined ratio from 2014 to 2023.
  • Farmers, Travelers and Mercury expanded or committed to California homeowners business under Lara's strategy.

Jane Kim won California's insurance commissioner race with 54.2% of the vote and a lead of more than 900,000 votes over fellow Democrat Ben Allen — and she intends to put the state's insurer-friendly reforms under review. Kim, an attorney and consumer advocate who served on San Francisco's Board of Supervisors from 2011 to 2019, claimed victory less than a week after the Nov. 3 election. She replaces Ricardo Lara, who is term limited. Her endorsements came from U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), for whom she worked as California political director, plus the California Teachers Association and the Working Families Party. Her campaign platform promised natural disaster insurance for everyone, premiums that go to paying claims, greater insurer transparency, and investment in safer homes and communities.

What does Kim want to change first?

Her signature proposal is a public program covering wildfire risk for existing California homes. In an October outline, Kim said participation would be mandatory. Premiums would be based partly on each home's wildfire risk and partly on rebuilding costs to fund catastrophic losses. Private insurers would keep selling other homeowners coverages, and the public program would invest its reserves in wildfire mitigation. The plan needs backing from state lawmakers and the governor. Affordability anchored her campaign message. "We've been traveling up and down the state all year and I just believe that our message centered around affordability and fighting to make sure that insurance is there for 40 million Americans in California resonated," Kim said. She added that voters have demanded affordability "over the last decade, but I think that has become particularly untenable the last few years under the Trump Administration." Kim is assembling a transition committee of policy experts in insurance, climate and technology leaders from across the state to shape her first 100 days and first-year agenda. "Our mandate is to make insurance affordable, available and fair, and that is what I will be fighting to do every single day that I'm in office," Kim said.

Why does the Sustainable Insurance Strategy face scrutiny?

Outgoing Commissioner Ricardo Lara built the strategy to bring insurers back to California's homeowners market. It expedites rate reviews and lets carriers use catastrophe models and reinsurance costs in ratemaking, tied to commitments to expand coverage in wildfire-distressed areas. Kim calls it a tradeoff that favors insurers. "The Sustainable Insurance Strategy was one that was put forward as a way to appease insurers who continue to threaten to leave the state in order to raise premiums on hard working families here in California, and we're going to be examining this program and making sure that we're also figuring out how to make insurance more affordable and more available," Kim said. She plans to review Lara's record with a focus on making rate filings and approvals more transparent and ensuring insurers pay claims promptly. Insurers that pulled back from California cited wildfire risk, catastrophe losses and difficulty winning rate approvals. The strategy has produced results. Farmers removed its policy cap last November. The Travelers Companies said in April it intends to expand homeowners offerings across California. Mercury committed to write 38,000 new policies over a multiyear period. Carriers including CSAA and Mercury secured 6.9% rate increases under the framework.

Is the industry actually struggling?

Kim argues no. She cited a report showing the property/casualty industry posted its first full-year underwriting gain in four years, pushing net income to $170 billion. "We know they were profitable; those are the facts," Kim said. "The data is out. They've been making more money than they ever have in their history the last three years. We know that they've been doing well." The industry counters with California-specific numbers. An Insurance Information Institute analysis of Best's Market Share Reports found California's homeowners market ran a 10-year average combined ratio of 109.7% from 2014 to 2023 — an overall underwriting loss across the period.

How is the industry responding?

Laura Curtis, vice president for state government affairs at the American Property Casualty Insurance Association, urged continuity. "Protecting the recent progress in the market is critical. While significant challenges remain, recent reforms have begun laying the foundation for a more stable and sustainable market," Curtis said. "Costly new mandates or regulatory actions that drive up costs or limit coverage options risk reversing this progress and worsening the crisis." Rex Frazier, president of the Personal Insurance Federation of California, warned against prejudging rate cases. "There are clear state rules for rate review, and it is inappropriate for any state official to pre-judge an individual insurer rate filing," Frazier said. "Arbitrary rate suppression is not only illegal, it reduces the ability of insurers to serve all communities and hurts consumers by drying up the insurance market." On priorities by line of business, Kim pointed to home and auto. "The ones that we hear the most about on the campaign trail are home and auto, because this is what impacts the everyday lives of Californians," Kim said. Small businesses raised liability insurance concerns with her during the campaign, but her stated focus stays on consumers. "I will be an independent watchdog for working families and everyday Californians, not a lap dog for billion-dollar corporations," Kim said. "We believe the mandate of this office is to protect the 40 million Americans that live in the great state of California." The fight over Lara's framework — and Kim's public wildfire plan, which requires legislative approval — will define California's insurance market for years.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,189 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »