Deals & IPOs

Cash-Equity Swaps Give Cash-Strapped Startups a Faster Path to Scale

A former Wall Street banker explains how startups can buy scale with equity instead of cash, pricing the deal with 3x EBITDA multiples and a 75/25 earn-out.

By Daniel Okafor

4 min read

M&A Isn’t Just for Big Companies. Here’s How Startups Can Do It With No Cash.
M&A Isn’t Just for Big Companies. Here’s How Startups Can Do It With No Cash.SarlaWu / pixabay

What's News

  • Cashless equity swaps let two businesses merge with no financing, even when investors have paused new investments.
  • Small restaurants typically trade at 3x EBITDA, giving acquirers a benchmark for pricing a target.
  • In the self-storage example, ownership opens at 75/25 and moves to 50/50 through an earn-out.
  • The two self-storage businesses do $6MM and $2MM in revenue, with $1MM and $0 in profit, across 300,000 square feet each.
  • One entrepreneur in Cary, NC rolled up around 20 competing Mexican restaurants for nearly 100% market share.

Open ownership at 75/25, earn it to 50/50, and pay nothing in cash. That is the structure an Entrepreneur contributor proposed for a merger between two self-storage businesses, one generating $6MM in revenue and the other $2MM. His wider claim is blunt: startups can buy scale through mergers and acquisitions without raising capital.

What does a cashless equity swap actually buy you?

Three routes can fund an acquisition, and only the third requires no financing:

  • Cash from the buyer's own account
  • Capital raised from investors
  • Equity exchanged between the two businesses

Most startups generate little profit, so they rarely qualify for bank financing or fresh investment on demand. The equity swap sidesteps both tests. "The key thing about M&A is that it does not necessarily need to be dependent on economic or financial market conditions," the contributor wrote. "Even if third-party investors have paused new investments during a down market, nothing prevents two businesses from merging in a cashless transaction at any time."

That route converts a founder's growth problem into a valuation problem: what is each business worth, and what share of the combined company does each owner take?

What is the difference between a merger and an acquisition?

A merger combines the shareholders of two businesses into one, typically bringing management teams and operations together. An acquisition leaves the acquiring team in control of 100% of key decisions in the new company, and it integrates the acquired company's operations as the buyer sees fit. The choice decides who signs off on pricing, suppliers and hiring after closing.

Why can M&A beat organic growth?

Three advantages carry the argument, and the contributor ranked them in a single line: speed, economies of scale and removing competition.

Speed is the cleanest. A restaurant chain growing from one location to two needs more than a year to find a site and build it out. Through M&A, the second location is already built and already generating revenue on the day the deal closes.

Economies of scale come from deleting duplicate cost. A combined company does not need two executive teams, two insurance policies, two marketing agencies and two accounting firms, and the contributor expects the arithmetic to work as "1+1=3" on the bottom line.

Competition is the third. Acquiring a rival raises market share and leaves one fewer competitor to price against. One entrepreneur in Cary, NC did it at scale, acquiring and rolling up around 20 competing Mexican restaurants to capture nearly 100% market share.

How is a company valued when it has no profit?

For businesses with revenue and profit, past transactions set the price. If small restaurants in the industry trade at 3x EBITDA, it is reasonable to assume a small restaurant sells at 3x EBITDA, and a good business broker can supply the normal multiples for a company's revenue, profit and growth rate.

When a target has neither revenue nor profit, the metrics change:

  • Cash invested in the business
  • Asset value
  • The assets themselves
  • Asset counts, such as locations

Two real estate owners illustrate the last one. One owner runs 4 locations and the other runs 2. Combining them into a single business gives the 4-location owner 67% and the 2-location owner 33%.

What does the self-storage example show?

Two self-storage businesses are considering a merger. The first does $6MM in revenue and $1MM in profit across 300,000 square feet of mature buildings, open for many years. The second does $2MM in revenue and $0 in profit today across another 300,000 square feet, but it is brand new, still ramping up clients and revenues, and will reach $1MM in profit once it fully rents out its space.

The same two businesses produce three different splits depending on the metric used. On revenues, the split is 80/20. On profits, it is 100/0. On square footage, it is 50/50. The contributor's solution was to open at 75/25 and let the smaller business earn its way to 50/50 through an earn-out if it grows its client base as planned. That structure, in his words, seems "the fairest for all parties" and should get both parties to the finish line.

What can go wrong, and who should run the deal?

The contributor does not present M&A as riskless. He pointed readers to his prior article on the potential pitfalls, and advised entering the direction "eyes wide open" to prepare for hurdles that may arise later.

He also brought his own credentials. "I am a former investment banker on Wall Street, and M&A is incorporated into my DNA," he wrote. For first-timers, he said, the process can feel "scary," but it does not need to be, provided founders surround themselves with advisors who have "been there and done that" in both negotiating and integrating companies.

The mechanism is what makes the structure work: a cashless swap removes the financing condition from the deal, while an earn-out moves valuation risk onto the party whose numbers still have to improve. For a founder who cannot raise capital, that combination is now the practical route to a larger company — and, in the contributor's framing, a route to expanding valuation multiples as a bigger business.

Original: redrocketvc.blogspot.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,417 articles

Related articles

« Previous article