Craigslist's Newmark Banks on a Nine-Second Pause to Beat Scammers
Craigslist founder Craig Newmark's Take9 campaign tells Americans to pause nine seconds before responding. He is in talks with AARP and claims AI scam detection already exists — quietly.
By Olivia Hart
4 min read

What's News
- Craig Newmark retired from Craigslist eight years ago after about 30 years at the company.
- Take9 advises a nine-second pause before responding to any unexpected message or call.
- Take9 is in talks with AARP; Newmark has been an AARP member for almost 24 years.
- Newmark hired Bully Pulpit International to test which mass safety campaigns actually work.
- Newmark says LLM-based scam detection exists but implementers keep it proprietary to avoid tipping off scammers.
By Olivia Hart, Business Bearings
Craigslist founder Craig Newmark wants Americans to count to nine before they click, text back or wire a dollar. His campaign, Take9, bets that a nine-second pause can break the scammer's oldest weapon: manufactured urgency.
Newmark frames the threat in plain terms. "The biggest technique scammers seem to use is to try to rush people into feeling like they have to make a decision right away, and that's been very effective forever," he said. What has changed is deepfake voice cloning, which can fake a distressed relative calling for money. His countermeasures: pause, verify, and use family code words to confirm identity.
The pitch sounds almost too simple. Newmark concedes the point, sort of. "We do keep the suggestions simple because, as far as we could tell, people aren't interested in sophisticated software installations," he said. The campaign's success metric is equally blunt: "Success is really about these measures being so productive that scammers just stop trying."
Why the Craigslist founder is still fighting
Newmark retired from Craigslist eight years ago, after roughly 30 years at the classifieds site. He says he watched scammers approach users in ways that surprised him, then worked with police to understand their techniques. "I retired from Craigslist eight years ago. I continue this fight because I am personally invested," he said. He is also, by his own description, a senior himself — and an AARP member of almost 24 years.
He is not a disinterested observer. He recently got hit himself. Newmark called the company a scammer impersonated and learned it had never contacted him. The catch: the fraudsters held enough personal data to suggest the commerce site itself had been breached. He did not name the company or say whether the breach was reported.
What Take9 actually recommends
The campaign's advice stays deliberately basic:
- Count to nine before responding to any unexpected message or call.
- Use single sign-on from Google or Apple rather than new passwords everywhere.
- Adopt passkeys where offered.
- Use password managers.
- Have a relative monitor older family members' credit card transactions and challenge suspicious charges.
That last item is drawn from his own household. His wife monitors her parents' card transactions and disputes questionable charges, with what he calls "fairly successful" results. His parents-in-law cannot wire money, which closes one common fraud channel by accident.
For himself, Newmark goes further than the campaign preaches: passkeys, password managers, DNS checks, ad blocking, and a paid managed security provider that monitors his systems continuously. The gap between his personal setup and Take9's advice is notable — he trusts defenses he does not ask the public to install.
Can AI catch what keyword filters miss?
Newmark's quieter work involves technology providers. Scammers, he says, once used predictable phrasing that simple keyword matching caught. When they noticed detection, they shifted wording, and defenders needed time to catch up.
Large language models may close that gap. "What I'm hearing from people who know a lot about large language models is that these models can detect scams using much broader patterns than simple pattern matching can," he said. He claims on-device small language models could already flag scam-like language in texts and posts, and that the technology to alert customer-service teams at user-generated content sites exists.
The evidence is thin, and he offers none. The implementers are proprietary and silent. "They don't want to spill the beans quite yet, and they're right about that," Newmark said. "You don't want to talk about that publicly because the bad guys do listen and act on what they hear." That argument is convenient: it makes the claimed progress unfalsifiable.
The influence operation behind the advice
Take9 is already in talks with AARP to teach seniors basic cybersecurity and credit card checks. Newmark has hired the advertising consultancy Bully Pulpit International to study which mass campaigns actually change behavior. His benchmark took decades to work: Smokey the Bear.
He is also consulting lawyers on whether liability law could push large websites to pursue scammers, and working with government, primarily through the Aspen Institute. "Government needs to play a role. Companies need to play a role," he said, adding that he is building back-channel relationships to nudge companies toward what they already agree is right. He describes his own position frankly: "Washington is no country for old nerds."
His stated hidden agenda is workplace hygiene: habits learned at home should carry to the office, protecting jobs and, in his telling, the country. Whether a nine-second count can scale into corporate defense — or measurably dent fraud losses — is the question Take9 has yet to answer with data.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,418 articles