Economy & Policy

Dáil to Debate Seamus Healy Motion on Úisce Éireann

Seamus Healy’s November 25 motion says Úisce Éireann is “not fit for purpose” and seeks local control, public water ownership, softer water and no management bonuses.

By Grace Kim

3 min read

The Dáil Is To Debate An Extensive Motion Put Forward By South Tipp TD Seamus Healy In Respect Of Úisce Éireann On Nov 2
The Dáil Is To Debate An Extensive Motion Put Forward By South Tipp TD Seamus Healy In Respect Of Úisce Éireann On Nov 2Alexas_Fotos / pixabay

What's News

  • The Dáil will debate Seamus Healy’s motion for two hours on November 25 and vote on November 26.
  • The motion seeks recognition that Úisce Éireann is “not fit for purpose” and a return of water services to local councils.
  • Healy wants a referendum on a constitutional clause enshrining public ownership of water.
  • The motion would end management bonuses that cost €17.9 million in 2025.
  • It would require at least one public office in every county and water deemed “soft” to international standards.

By Grace Kim

The Dáil will debate Seamus Healy’s motion on Úisce Éireann for two hours on November 25, with a vote scheduled for November 26.

South Tipperary TD Seamus Healy wants lawmakers to declare the utility “not fit for purpose” and agree to return water services to local councils. His proposal also targets the company’s operating structure, management pay and the standard of water it supplies.

What does Healy’s motion seek?

Healy’s motion asks the Dáil to acknowledge that Úisce Éireann is “not fit for purpose”. It also asks the chamber to agree to return water services to local councils.

The proposal seeks changes to Úisce Éireann’s current operation as the company is being wound up. It calls for a referendum that would allow a clause in the Constitution to enshrine public ownership of water.

That constitutional demand sits alongside the motion’s immediate administrative proposals. The motion does not stop at the long-term ownership model; it sets out changes to parliamentary scrutiny, management bonuses and the company’s county footprint.

In plain terms, the motion seeks a transfer of water-service control, backed by a public-ownership referendum.

How would oversight and management change?

Healy’s motion lists three operating changes:

  • Permit TDs to submit Parliamentary Questions. Under the Dáil’s current standing orders, TDs cannot request a written reply in the way they can with the HSE.
  • End management bonus payments. Healy says the practice cost €17.9 million in 2025.
  • Require at least one Úisce Éireann public office in every county.

Taken together, the clauses would give TDs a direct written-question channel, remove a management payment practice and require a public office in each county. They would also shift the debate toward what accountability should look like as Úisce Éireann’s current operation is wound up.

The €17.9 million figure gives the management-pay proposal a measurable scale. The county-office requirement would make the company’s presence more visible, while the Parliamentary Questions clause would seek to bring its operations under tighter Dáil scrutiny.

In plain terms, Healy wants more parliamentary oversight, no management bonuses and a public office in every county.

Why does Clonmel’s water matter?

One of the motion’s most specific demands is that Úisce Éireann distribute only water deemed “soft” to international standards. The proposal would place the water-quality standard directly on the company’s operations.

Businesses and residents are concerned about a change to a “hard” water source in Clonmel. They say hard water can damage heating systems, kettles and coffee machines, among other appliances. The concern is practical: a water change could impose costs on households and local businesses that rely on those systems.

Úisce Éireann says it is obliged to provide water but not necessarily “soft” water. That position leaves a gap between the company’s stated obligation and Healy’s proposed standard for the water it distributes.

In plain terms, the debate pits a demand for soft water against Úisce Éireann’s narrower duty to supply water.

What happens on November 26?

The Government is likely to table a counter-motion. Two hours have been set aside for the November 25 debate, and the vote on Healy’s proposal is scheduled for November 26.

If the Dáil adopts Healy’s motion, it would call for the return of water services to local councils, changes to the company’s operation, a referendum on public ownership and the three administrative measures listed above. It would not, by itself, carry out each change.

The Government’s response could shape which parts of the package move forward. The final vote will set the immediate direction for Healy’s proposals and the Government’s likely counter-motion.

Source: tippmidwestradio.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,206 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »