DOJ Has No Espionage Evidence Against OpenAI Engineer, Defense Says
Lawyers for Abdulrahman Alfozan say DOJ prosecutors admitted no espionage evidence exists, backing a new bid to free the ex-OpenAI engineer before trial.
By Nathan Brooks
3 min read

What's News
- Prosecutors told the defense in two November meetings that no evidence supports espionage charges, Rizk says.
- Alfozan was indicted in October on a single Wiretap Act count tied to a device found in OpenAI's San Francisco office.
- A judge ordered detention, citing Saudi Arabia's bond offer and the flight of Alfozan's wife and son.
- FBI lost access to Alfozan's seized cellphone after a power failure; he offered to unlock it voluntarily.
- Defense also seeks to lift court restrictions on Alfozan's AI use while preparing for trial.
Justice Department prosecutors have found no evidence to support espionage charges against Abdulrahman Alfozan, the Saudi national accused of planting a listening device in OpenAI's San Francisco office, according to his attorney.
"Government counsel acknowledged that if there were supporting evidence, new charges would have been brought when Mr. Alfozan was indicted," David Rizk, Alfozan's lawyer, said in a court filing ahead of his client's Tuesday court appearance.
"Instead, Mr. Alfozan was indicted solely on the Wiretap Act count that was the subject of the Complaint."
How did the case get here?
Federal prosecutors in San Francisco arrested Alfozan in October, accusing him of planting a listening device in a conference room at OpenAI's office, where he worked as an engineer. The criminal complaint charged him with interception of oral communications.
Prosecutors took the case to a grand jury later in October. The indictment came back on a single wiretap count — no espionage, no theft of trade secrets.
Rizk says he met with prosecutors twice this month and was told both times that no evidence had emerged to justify additional charges. A spokesperson for the US Attorney's office in San Francisco didn't immediately respond to a request for comment.
What does this change for Alfozan's detention?
The filing is Rizk's latest push to get his client out of jail, and it zeroes in on the gap between the government's rhetoric and its charges. Alfozan has pleaded not guilty, but a federal judge ordered him held pending trial, citing a high flight risk. The judge pointed to two factors: the Saudi government's offer to pay his bond, and the fact that his wife and son had already flown to Saudi Arabia.
Rizk is now asking US District Judge Vince Chhabria, who is overseeing the case, to order the Justice Department to hand over additional information so the defense can formally request release.
According to Rizk, the discovery material produced so far shows no sign that prosecutors ever investigated ties between Alfozan and the Saudi government — the very concern that helped keep him detained.
There's also a practical wrinkle working in the defense's favor. Alfozan's cellphone was seized by the Justice Department, and prosecutors said earlier this month they lost access to it because of a power failure at an FBI facility. Rizk says his client voluntarily offered to unlock the phone.
What did the original complaint allege?
Photos included in the criminal complaint show a USB device plugged into the back of a conference room TV, wrapped in toilet paper. The complaint also contained what prosecutors described as a photo of Alfozan checking on the device a week after another OpenAI employee found it hidden there.
That's the evidence base for the sole surviving charge — one count under the Wiretap Act.
A second fight over AI access
Rizk isn't only seeking release. He also asked the judge to modify a previous order restricting Alfozan's use of AI while he prepares his defense.
"The U.S. Attorney's Office should not be in the business of policing defense counsel's discovery practices," Rizk wrote.
That sets up a side battle over whether an AI-savvy engineer can use the very tools of his trade to defend himself.
What happens next
Tuesday's appearance before Judge Chhabria will test whether the absence of espionage evidence — confirmed, per the defense, in two meetings with prosecutors this month — is enough to loosen the government's grip. If the single wiretap count stands as the full case, the detention rationale built on Saudi ties looks increasingly exposed.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,352 articles