DOJ Opens Door to Merger Approvals Without Asset Sales
DOJ cleared Fox's $22 billion Roku deal on behavioral pledges alone, skipping court scrutiny — and says more mergers may pass without asset sales.
By Daniel Okafor
3 min read

What's News
- DOJ closed its Fox-Roku investigation on Nov. 6, clearing a $22 billion deal with behavioral commitments and no asset sales
- Fox pledged to carry non-Fox content for at least three years and keep providing data products on reasonable terms
- DOJ may apply the same approach to Nvidia's $13 billion acquisition of Hugging Face
- DOJ bypassed Tunney Act court review by not filing the settlement commitments in federal court
- The FTC still calls behavioral remedies 'disfavored and rare,' per official David Shaw
The US Justice Department cleared a $22 billion merger this month without demanding any asset sales, and a senior official says more deals will pass review the same way. Charlie Beller, deputy assistant attorney general for antitrust, told a New York conference on Monday that DOJ has been focused on "how behavioral commitments or remedies serve" as "a mitigating factor" for competition concerns. That approach works best, he said, in industries where asset sales are harder to arrange.
The cleared deal was Fox Corp.'s $22 billion acquisition of Roku Inc. DOJ closed its investigation on Nov. 6 after Fox committed to carry non-Fox content for at least three years and to keep providing data products on reasonable terms. No divestitures were required.
What changes under the new approach?
The shift is doctrinal. During the Biden administration, and even in Trump's first term, antitrust enforcers favored asset sales and largely rejected settlement proposals built on company pledges. Behavioral remedies — promises about how a combined company will operate — were treated as weak substitutes for structural fixes. Now DOJ treats those promises as a sufficient condition for clearing a deal in some markets.
Beller's comments also hint at how DOJ may handle its review of Nvidia Corp.'s $13 billion acquisition of AI model company Hugging Face, whose models and data anyone can freely use.
Why did the FTC push back on the same idea?
The FTC, which also reviews mergers, has not followed suit. David Shaw, the agency's No. 2 competition official, said behavioral remedies remain "disfavored and rare" at his agency. But he acknowledged regulators sometimes have reasons to accept them rather than sue.
"In some cases, blocking the deal might not be the optimum result," Shaw said at the same conference Monday. He added that successfully challenging deals in court is not always realistic.
How did DOJ skip public scrutiny of the Fox deal?
The Fox-Roku approval deviated from past practice in a second way. DOJ chose not to file the settlement commitments in federal court. That decision bypassed a public process in which a judge would have scrutinized whether the terms served the public interest, and it shielded the department from additional questions about how the deal was reached.
A Watergate-era transparency law, the Tunney Act, requires the government to explain why an antitrust settlement serves the public interest and lets the public comment. The law also forces the merging companies to disclose every contact they had with the executive branch.
What are the political consequences?
Since Trump returned to office last year, DOJ has faced accusations that it settled antitrust cases on favorable terms under pressure from other administration officials and well-connected lawyers and consultants. The cases cited include the monopolization action against Live Nation Entertainment Inc. and a merger involving Hewlett Packard Enterprise Co.
Key Democrats in Congress have already proposed amending the Tunney Act to require greater public disclosure and to strengthen the standard courts apply when reviewing settlements. Their bills answer a department that now clears $22 billion deals on promises alone, without a judge looking over its shoulder — and the Fox-Roku template may soon be tested again on Nvidia and Hugging Face.
Source: insurancejournal.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,282 articles