Economy & Policy

European pesticide makers named in 1,605 Brazil poisoning reports

European pesticide brands appeared in 1,605 Brazilian poisoning reports last year; a third involve chemicals banned on EU farms but legally manufactured for export.

By Nathan Brooks

4 min read

European-made pesticides named in 1,605 poisoning reports in Brazil last year
European-made pesticides named in 1,605 poisoning reports in Brazil last yearsbj04769 / pixabay

What's News

  • 1,605 of 2,857 product-named Brazilian poisoning reports in 2023 involved brands sold by European companies
  • 32 deaths appeared across European-linked reports; 26 were recorded as suicides
  • Reglone, containing EU-banned diquat, is still made by Syngenta in Huddersfield for export
  • Diquat cases in Brazil hit 75 last year versus 36 across 2018–2022
  • Syngenta products were cited 425 times; BASF 179 times

Pesticide brands sold by European chemical companies appeared in 1,605 poisoning reports filed in Brazil last year — and roughly a third of those cases involved chemicals banned from farm use inside the EU itself. That's the headline finding of an investigation by Unearthed and Public Eye published Tuesday, built on Brazilian health ministry data.

The legal mechanics matter here. European companies can't sell these chemicals to European farmers, but nothing stops them from manufacturing the same products for export to countries where they remain legal. Brazil is one of those countries.

What do the numbers actually show?

Brazilian law requires healthcare professionals to report every suspected pesticide poisoning to the national disease notification system. Last year, more than 6,700 medical reports involved agricultural pesticides; 2,857 named an identifiable product. Of those, 1,605 named brands sold by European companies. Within the full dataset, 1,420 cases were classified as confirmed poisonings and 1,108 as exposures.

There's an important caveat, and the investigators flag it themselves. A brand named in a report isn't proof it caused the poisoning or death. Lab confirmation is rare, so classification usually rests on a clinician's judgment.

"The insufficient training of healthcare professionals to recognise and manage these cases is a major limiting factor," said Vanda Garibotti, a public health biologist at the State Centre for Health Surveillance in Rio Grande do Sul. High staff turnover and weak institutional support, she added, mean cases rarely get laboratory confirmation.

Which products and companies are named?

  • Reglone (Syngenta): Contains diquat, banned on UK farms in 2020 and EU farms in 2019. Still made at Syngenta's Huddersfield factory for export. It appeared in 44 reports, including four deaths. Diquat cases overall hit 75 last year, versus 36 across the entire 2018–2022 period.
  • Dormex (Alzchem/BASF): Contains cyanamide, banned in the EU in 2008 over risks to farm workers. The database recorded 17 confirmed poisonings involving Dormex last year.
  • Finale (BASF): Contains glufosinate, banned in the EU in 2018 and classified there as toxic to reproduction.
  • Roundup (Bayer): Frequently cited, including 12 deaths.

Syngenta products were cited 425 times; BASF's, 179. The figures overlap, since some reports named more than one manufacturer. Across all European-linked reports, there were 32 deaths — 31 classified as confirmed poisonings, 26 of them recorded as suicides.

The human cases behind the data

Nelson Castoldi died last year after mistaking Reglone, decanted into a cola bottle to save hauling a 20-litre canister, for a soft drink. He spat it out, but the chemical destroyed his kidneys, then his lungs. He died two days later. "That poison, Reglone, should be banned in Brazil," his son Ivan said. "Not because of what happened to us, but because of its toxicity."

Sidnei Souza de Oliveira, 49, spilled Dormex on his leg when a jug handle broke. "After 15 days, my leg was black. Chunks of flesh were falling off," he said. Doctors removed dead tissue to stop the spread toward the bone. His employer's protective trousers, he said, were too thin.

How did the companies respond?

Nina Schrank of Greenpeace UK called the findings a "deadly double standard": "If a pesticide is too dangerous to use in Britain, it should be too dangerous to export."

Syngenta said almost half the cases attributed to it weren't confirmed poisonings, and accused the investigation of "selectively interpreting" evidence to support a "predetermined conclusion." It said Brazil has a "robust regulatory system" and that it trained 95,000 people there in 2025. Bayer said its products are safe when used per label instructions, questioned the data's reliability, and noted "Roundup" is often used as a generic term; its safety programs reached over 4 million people globally in 2025. BASF said it takes all incidents seriously, pointed to possible "deliberate misuse," and said its Brazil training initiatives reached more than 14,475 participants in 2025.

What does this change for practitioners? The export loophole is now quantified and named — and with a 2020 study already showing bans on highly hazardous pesticides can be a cost-effective suicide-prevention tool, the pressure on ministers in London and Brussels to close it just got harder data to ignore.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,232 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »