Executives Trust AI Over Their Own Judgment Twice as Often as Staff
Charter's survey of 5,002 U.S. desk workers finds a third of executives trust AI over their own judgment, while 69% of Gen Zers trust work done without AI more.
By Grace Kim
3 min read

What's News
- Executives are twice as likely as non-managers to trust AI over their own judgment: ~33% vs 16.3%, per Charter's AI Pulse survey of 5,002 U.S. desk workers.
- 69% of employed Gen Zers trust work completed without AI more, and only 3% trust fully AI-produced work most, per Gallup/Walton Family Foundation/GSV Ventures.
- Executives are 3.3 times as likely as workers to use AI outputs they doubt, per Charter.
- 85% of executives are at least somewhat optimistic about AI's impact, vs 56% of employees.
- 2025 SAP research found 74% of executives trusted AI more for business advice than colleagues or friends.
Executives are twice as likely as rank-and-file employees to trust AI over their own judgment on work decisions. That figure comes from Charter's AI Pulse survey of 5,002 full-time U.S. desk workers who use AI on the job, and it flips a popular narrative on its head: the generation supposedly addicted to ChatGPT is actually the skeptical one.
About a third of managers and executives say they trust AI more than their own judgment, versus 16.3% of non-managers. Executives are also more than twice as likely as workers to trust AI over a knowledgeable colleague.
Gen Z, by contrast, keeps the technology at arm's length. In the Voices of Gen Z study from Gallup, the Walton Family Foundation, and GSV Ventures — a survey of 1,572 Americans ages 14 to 29 — 69% of employed Gen Zers say they trust work completed without AI more than AI-assisted work. Only 3% put the most faith in work produced entirely by AI.
That's not avoidance. The same survey found 51% of Gen Zers use generative AI at least weekly. They just treat it as a supporting character, not the lead.
Why does rank matter more than age?
Brian Elliott, Charter's executive-in-residence, who co-led the AI Pulse research, says where someone sits at the table matters more than the year they were born. "We surveyed over 5,000 AI users at work and found sharper divides by career stage than by age," he tells Fortune.
Part of it comes down to the job itself. "AI is great at summaries and high-level answers, which is much of what a leader needs, while workers deal with specifics where AI's gaps show," Elliott says.
The diligence numbers cut both ways. 81% of executives say they always or usually fact-check AI output before using it, versus 71% of workers. But the checking doesn't stop the doubts. "Executives say they fact-check AI more, but they're also 3.3 times as likely as workers to use outputs they doubt, almost certainly because they have less fear that making a mistake might cost them their job," Elliott says.
The biggest driver, in his view, may be pressure. "Many leaders are expected to move fast and have all the answers, and AI suits the 'seldom wrong, never in doubt' habit many already have." That combination, he says, "explains how you get a CFO who drops the CMO's campaign into ChatGPT and quizzes her on it, trusting the tool over a peer who knows the context and spent weeks on the work."
This isn't the first sign of executive faith in the technology. In 2025, SAP research shared with Fortune found that 74% of executives trusted AI more for business advice than colleagues or friends.
Takeaway: the people with the least to lose from an AI error are the ones most willing to ship the output anyway.
What's at stake when the corner office trusts the chatbot?
Misplaced trust in AI carries a bigger price at the top than at the entry level. When an executive leans on a flawed AI answer to decide who gets promoted, where the money goes, or how a team is restructured after a merger, employees absorb the consequences — and they didn't get a vote.
Optimism splits along the same lines. In Charter's survey, 85% of executives are at least somewhat optimistic about AI's impact on their organization, compared with 56% of employees. Younger workers' wariness stems from institutions they feel have failed them, from schools to employers.
Will 2027 budgets test that judgment?
Executives are finalizing next year's budgets and AI strategies now. The open question is how many of those calls will rest on a leader's judgment and how many on a chatbot's general answer.
Gen Z doesn't give AI main character energy; it treats the technology as an assistant. Leaders who do the same could make 2027 a better year for the employees who live with their decisions.
Source: fortune.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,178 articles