Economy & Policy

Former Minister Warns Royal Mail Faces Collapse Without Urgent Reform

Former business secretary Peter Kyle warns Royal Mail could collapse under full-time employment costs unless ministers level the playing field with parcel rivals.

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

Government must act now or lose Royal Mail, former minister warns
Government must act now or lose Royal Mail, former minister warnsThe Metropolitan Museum of Art / The Met · CC0

What's News

  • Royal Mail was fined £21m in October 2025 for missing 2024/25 delivery targets
  • 98% of Royal Mail's 130,000 workers are permanent employees with pensions and sick pay
  • Kyle says Royal Mail 'will just collapse' without government action on the parcel market
  • Ofcom's annual monitoring report, due December, will precede any reform decision
  • Ofcom cut the first class next-day target to 90% and scrapped second class Saturday deliveries

Royal Mail was fined £21 million in October 2025 for missing delivery targets, and a former business secretary now warns the company could collapse entirely without urgent government intervention. Peter Kyle, who served in the role until July, said a "crunch point" had been reached. The claim is stark; the evidence behind it is a familiar mix of competition, legal obligation and shrinking letter volumes.

What did Peter Kyle actually say?

Kyle said the government must "level the playing field" for Royal Mail or risk the business becoming unviable. His core concern: rival parcel delivery firms are undercutting Royal Mail because they do not employ staff under the same conditions.

"If we leave it another few years then Royal Mail will just become unviable and it will just collapse under the weight of having full-time employees," he said. That is a strong claim, and Kyle's own framing suggests the government has yet to test it — he started preparing officials at the Department for Business and Trade (DBT) to examine the parcel market shortly before Jonathan Reynolds replaced him in July.

His proposed review would have mapped where costs sit in the delivery market and where profit is made, to see whether successful companies upheld "the values of business in Britain today." Notably, it would not have touched Royal Mail's universal service obligations or its staff terms and conditions. The takeaway: Kyle wanted to scrutinise competitors, not loosen Royal Mail's own duties.

How big is the employment gap?

According to Royal Mail, 98% of its 130,000 workers are permanent employees with pensions, sick pay and holiday pay. That is roughly 127,400 people on full statutory terms.

Some competitors use self-employed delivery drivers instead. Some offer an opt-in service giving couriers limited additional benefits — a structure Royal Mail argues shifts the cost base against it. The arithmetic is simple: permanent employment costs more per worker than self-employment, and Royal Mail carries those costs across nearly all of its headcount.

What must Royal Mail do that rivals do not?

Royal Mail is legally obliged to offer a "one price goes anywhere" service across the UK and to deliver first class letters six days a week to every address. No competitor faces the same mandate.

Regulator Ofcom has already eased some of this burden. It agreed last year to scrap second class Saturday deliveries and to cut the first class next-day delivery target to 90%. Even so, Royal Mail is still missing its targets for first and second class post, despite recent performance improvements.

What is the government doing now?

A government spokesperson said it will consider whether further parcel market reforms are needed after Ofcom publishes its annual monitoring report in December. That means no decision before winter — a timeline that sits uneasily with Kyle's warning that waiting "a few years" would doom the company.

The current business secretary, Jonathan Reynolds, met Royal Mail and the Communication Workers Union (CWU) last week, according to the spokesperson, "to seek timely progress on improving their quality of service and to reiterate our commitment to the company's success."

DBT has also launched a consultation on what it calls "bogus" self-employment — "a practice whereby some businesses mislabel staff as self-employed to avoid statutory obligations." Royal Mail welcomed it. A company spokesperson claimed parts of the delivery industry were "driving a race to the bottom" on employment standards and said Royal Mail would "continue to push for a level playing field, with strong and enforceable standards across the industry." A consultation, of course, is not a rule; nothing yet binds the competitors Kyle names only in general terms.

Who else is piling on?

Shadow business minister Bradley Thomas put the blame squarely on management. "Customers are being asked time and time again to pay increased prices, yet the service they're receiving is not improving," he said.

"Be in no doubt, this is not the fault of the hardworking postmen and women, it's the fault of Royal Mail's management," Thomas said, adding: "Nationalisation isn't the solution to this problem. Instead, we need ministers and Ofcom to bear down on Royal Mail's management to ensure they deliver on the improvements they've promised their customers."

The CWU is pushing in the opposite direction, with General Secretary Dave Ward calling for a "new model of ownership." Many MPs report high volumes of constituent complaints about missed and delayed deliveries.

The December Ofcom report now looks like the hinge: it will determine whether the government treats Royal Mail's troubles as a market failure or a management one.

Original: gov.uk

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,221 articles

Related articles

« Previous article