Economy & Policy

Hickenlooper’s AI line: race China, limit frontier models

Sen. John Hickenlooper backs a U.S. AI lead over China while seeking limits on recursive learning, stronger safeguards and grid costs for data centers.

By Grace Kim

4 min read

Newly reelected Sen. John Hickenlooper sketches Democrats’ AI line: race China, but regulate frontier models like nuclea
Newly reelected Sen. John Hickenlooper sketches Democrats’ AI line: race China, but regulate frontier models like nucleaTho-Ge / pixabay

What's News

  • Hickenlooper won a second term on Nov. 3, beating Republican state Sen. Mark Baisley 61% to 35%.
  • The Senate voted 73-25 last week to begin debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act.
  • More than 20 researchers, including Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, published a paper in September warning that automating AI research could trigger an “intelligence explosion.”
  • Hickenlooper sits on the Senate Commerce Committee, while Democrats take control of the Senate in January.
  • Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia’s CEO last week after reports of an affair with an alleged Chinese spy; the Senate Banking Committee has asked Huang and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to testify next month.

By Grace Kim

Sen. John Hickenlooper won a second term on Nov. 3, defeating Republican state Sen. Mark Baisley 61% to 35%, with Democrats set to take control of the Senate in January. The Colorado Democrat sits on the Senate Commerce Committee.

In an interview with Fortune’s Diane Brady on Monday at the Fortune 500 Innovation Forum in Detroit, where he participated by teleconference, Hickenlooper outlined an early Democratic position on frontier AI: keep the U.S. ahead of China, but limit systems that improve themselves beyond their assigned domain.

What should frontier AI rules require?

“Maybe we don’t need recursive learning, unlimited,” Hickenlooper said. He described machines “reinventing themselves sometimes outside the fence line of their domain that they’re supposed to stay in.” “That should cause real concern,” he said.

Hickenlooper supports AI labs moving quickly. “They are pushing as fast as they can. I understand that, and that’s good,” he said, citing the international rivalry. “We want to make sure that our frontier AI is the best in the world because it has the potential to dominate the globe.”

His comparison was nuclear weapons and aircraft. “We regulate nuclear weapons. We have regulations before an airplane can go into service,” he said. “We need to look at what are some of the fundamental safeguards and guardrails that we should put in place.”

In September, more than 20 researchers, including Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio, published a paper warning that automating AI research could set off an “intelligence explosion.” Alan Chan, one of its lead coauthors, said valid safety mechanisms aren’t in place.

His position is simple: support speed in the AI race, but put limits on systems that cross their own boundaries.

Why does China matter more than the Nvidia case?

Brady asked about Nvidia and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick after Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia’s CEO the previous week, following reports of an affair with an alleged Chinese spy. The Senate Banking Committee has asked Huang and Lutnick to testify next month.

Hickenlooper does not sit on that committee. He called his questions about the case “not that pressing” and said he wanted the basics first. “What is our relationship to China, and how secure do we feel in sharing our technology with them at any level?” he said. “Because I don’t feel comfortable with that.”

His priority is the China relationship, not the immediate showdown over Nvidia’s leadership.

Who pays for data centers’ power upgrades?

Hickenlooper backs the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, which he said would help curb data centers. The permitting bill would speed approvals for energy projects and require data centers to pay for the grid upgrades built to serve them.

The Senate voted 73-25 last week to begin debate on it, and President Donald Trump endorsed it. Under the bill, the cost of new power lines and substations “will be completely borne by the data center.”

Hickenlooper said data centers should first guarantee that communities will see no loud noises, hazards or nuisances.

Hickenlooper called the bill a compromise. Trump “doesn’t like wind. He doesn’t like solar,” Hickenlooper said, but the bill would put wind and solar on equal footing with natural gas. He said the measure has limitations, but its current form is “much improved” from where it started. “I wish we could go further.”

His bottom line: data centers should cover the cost of the power lines and substations built to serve them.

What do the midterms mean for Democrats?

Hickenlooper did not treat the result as a mandate. “It’s not a mandate,” he said. “I think it’s more of a to-do list, almost an audition.” He said Democrats must show they can lower costs and add jobs.

His advice on legislating was equally practical. “When you’re trying to get a deal done, you’ve got to figure out who you’re negotiating with,” he said. “You got to see what’s in it for them and find a way that you can both benefit from the final agreement.”

For Hickenlooper, victory on Nov. 3 starts a to-do list, not a mandate.

From January, Democrats will have to turn Hickenlooper’s pitch into policy: lead the AI race against China, limit self-improving frontier systems and make data centers pay for the power upgrades they require.

Source: fortune.com

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,178 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »