Is Trading Really 90% Psychology? A New Course Says Only Half
A TradingView course by BigBeluga tests the '90% psychology' myth on a real BTC chart: one trader made +3.9R, another lost 3.6R, and discipline alone didn't decide it.
By Amara Osei
3 min read

What's News
- Trader A made about +3.9R buying BTC at 110,338 with a target of 117,900
- Trader B's planned 1R loss became roughly 3.6R after he removed his stop at 121,400 and sold at 112,775
- Lo, Repin and Steenbarger (2005) tracked 80 day traders over five weeks and linked intense emotional reactions to worse performance
- Trader A finished two trades at about +2.9R despite one losing trade
- Lesson 02 will examine whether great traders feel no emotions
Two Bitcoin traders read the same 4-hour uptrend and took opposite results: one finished +3.9R, the other lost 3.6R — not because their analysis differed, but because one removed his stop and sold in panic. That contrast opens a new beginner-level trading course published by BigBeluga on TradingView, titled "Trading Roadmap | Psychology Myths · Lesson 01 — 90% Psychology?"
The lesson attacks one of trading's most repeated claims head-on. "It is one of the most repeated lines in trading, and it sounds wise. It is also half true — and the wrong half can be expensive," the author writes. The number itself, BigBeluga argues, is not a measurement. There's no agreed method to split trading results into a psychology percentage and a method percentage, and the saying survives because it comforts losers without asking whether their method has an edge at all.
What does the research actually show?
Psychology does move results, and the lesson cites studies to prove it. Andrew Lo and Dmitry Repin (2002) measured skin conductance and heart activity in professional traders during live trading and found their physiological responses tracked sudden market events and volatility. Lo, Repin and Brett Steenbarger (2005) followed 80 day traders over five weeks; traders with more intense emotional reactions to gains and losses tended to show significantly worse performance.
The key point, BigBeluga writes, is that the cost shows up in decisions, not feelings. Emotions turn into decisions at four moments: before entry, when defining risk, while managing the trade, and after it closes.
How did a 1R loss become 3.6R?
The case study uses real BTC prices. Trader A bought at 110,338 with a stop at 108,400 and hit his target at 117,900 — roughly 3.9 times his risk. Trader B hesitated at the planned level after a sharp drop, watched price run to 117,900 without him, then bought the new high at 124,714 — 14,376 above the planned entry.
His stop sat at 121,400. As price fell toward it, he removed it. Price never returned; a wick reached 102,000, and he sold at 112,775. The planned loss was 1R. The actual loss was about 3.6R. When he sold, the uptrend structure hadn't even broken by a close.
BigBeluga names three decisions made under pressure: removing the stop ("hope replaced the plan"), holding without new information, and selling in panic — the same trader who couldn't accept 1R accepted 3.6R.
Why did the disciplined trader also lose?
Here's the part the myth leaves out. Trader A's next trade bought at 114,342 with a stop at 108,400 and a target at 126,200. The stop hit for a clean 1R loss, and price later fell to 103,528. Discipline didn't make the trade right — it controlled the size of being wrong. Across both trades, Trader A finished around +2.9R; Trader B finished one trade at roughly −3.6R.
The lesson leans on Daniel Kahneman's Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011): under pressure, the fast, reactive mode of thinking takes over. A written plan moves entry, stop and target decisions to a calmer moment. Even Mark Douglas, whose Trading in the Zone (2000) popularized trading psychology, defined an edge as a higher probability of one outcome over another — the edge comes first.
What's the verdict?
BigBeluga's reformulation is blunt: "Psychology does not tell you where price goes next; it decides how much of your edge survives the trip." A method without an edge loses slowly with discipline; a method with an edge leaks away without it. Psychology doesn't create an edge — it protects one.
Lesson 02 will test another popular belief: that great traders feel no emotions. The research, the author promises, points somewhere surprising.
Source: tradingview.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,267 articles