Kalshi Loses Appeal: Maryland Can Police Its Sports Betting Markets
A 2-1 Fourth Circuit ruling lets Maryland regulators pursue Kalshi over unlicensed sports bets, deepening a circuit split that could push the $40 billion prediction market to the Supreme Court.
By Nathan Brooks
3 min read

What's News
- The 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 on Tuesday that Maryland can pursue enforcement actions against Kalshi.
- Kalshi was valued at $40 billion in a recent funding round.
- Two other appeals courts have ruled against Kalshi; a third said New Jersey cannot regulate it.
- Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented, calling Kalshi's contracts "swaps" under exclusive CFTC oversight.
- New Jersey has already taken its fight over Kalshi's prediction market to the US Supreme Court.
A US appeals court ruled Tuesday that Kalshi cannot block Maryland gaming regulators from pursuing enforcement actions over unlicensed sports bets placed on its prediction market platform. The 2-1 decision from the Richmond, Virginia-based 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals hands states a fresh win in the fight over who polices event-contract trading.
The stakes are enormous for Kalshi, which a recent funding round valued at $40 billion. Maryland's Lottery and Gaming Control Commission sent the company a cease-and-desist letter last year demanding it stop offering unlicensed sports wagering. Kalshi sued, lost its injunction request at the lower court, and appealed — and now has lost again.
What does the ruling actually change?
For now, Maryland regulators can keep pursuing Kalshi for letting users bet on sports outcomes without a license. That matters because states argue prediction market operators are violating gaming laws, including restrictions blocking anyone under 21 from wagering.
The decision also deepens a split among federal appeals courts. Two other appeals courts have ruled against the New York-based company. A third concluded New Jersey could not regulate it. That kind of circuit split raises the odds the US Supreme Court will have to settle the question — and New Jersey has already taken its fight over Kalshi's prediction market to the high court.
The legal fault line: federal vs. state power
Kalshi's core argument is simple: the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission has exclusive jurisdiction over the sports-related event contracts traded on its platform. Under President Donald Trump's administration, the CFTC has agreed, sharing the industry's position that event contracts fall solely under federal oversight. The CFTC has even sued New York to block state oversight of prediction markets.
The majority on the 4th Circuit panel didn't buy it. US Circuit Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker, writing separately, concluded that under their interpretations of the Commodity Exchange Act, those contracts may still be subject to state gaming laws. They reached that conclusion on different grounds.
"Congress knows how to displace traditional state police powers when it chooses to do so," Gregory wrote.
US Circuit Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented. In her view, Kalshi's sports-related event contracts qualify as "swaps" — a category of derivatives that falls exclusively under CFTC oversight.
Both sides claim momentum
Kalshi framed the loss as proof of legal confusion rather than defeat. Tuesday's decision "demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets," the company said in a statement.
Maryland's regulators read it very differently. Jeremy Baker, acting director of the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Commission, said the ruling "affirmed the state's ability to regulate what is clearly sports wagering."
Why the Supreme Court may settle this
Kalshi and its competitors let users trade on outcomes of events ranging from sports to elections. States contend those firms are operating without required licenses and flouting gaming statutes written long before event contracts existed.
With three circuits now split on whether state gaming regulators hold any authority over these platforms, the legal ground under the $40 billion company is uneven by design — the same product may be legal in one state and subject to enforcement in the next. Practitioners should watch the Supreme Court's docket: if the justices take the New Jersey case or a follow-on from this split, a single ruling could determine whether prediction markets answer to Washington or to 50 state gaming commissions.
Source: insurancejournal.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,460 articles