Money & Markets

Kentucky Holds Workers' Comp Loss Costs Flat at 0% for 2027

Kentucky's DOI approved a 0.0% change in workers' comp loss costs effective Jan. 1, halting years of cuts as NCCI data shows claim frequency and national loss ratios climbing.

By Olivia Hart

3 min read

Not a Typo: Kentucky DOI Approves a 0% Change in Workers’ Comp Loss Costs
Not a Typo: Kentucky DOI Approves a 0% Change in Workers’ Comp Loss CostsAI-generated

What's News

  • Kentucky DOI approved a 0.0% change in voluntary-market workers' comp loss costs effective Jan. 1, 2027.
  • The flat rate follows a 9.7% average decrease for 2026 and similar cuts in prior years.
  • NCCI reports the 2025 combined ratio for workers' comp insurers across 38 states rose from 86% to 91%.
  • U.S. payroll increased 4.8% from 2024 to 2025 while employment rose just 0.5%; average wages gained 4.3%.
  • Policy year 2024 showed a higher loss ratio and a rise in claim frequency, breaking a pattern of declines.

Kentucky regulators have approved a 0.0% change in average workers' compensation loss costs for the voluntary market, effective Jan. 1, 2027 — the state's first halt to two decades of near-annual decreases. The Kentucky Department of Insurance confirmed the decision in a bulletin, capping a rare moment of pricing stasis in a line of insurance that has grown cheaper for employers almost every year since the mid-2000s.

The flat recommendation came from the National Council on Compensation Insurance in September, drawing on loss experience from Kentucky policy years 2022, 2023 and 2024. It follows a 9.7% average decrease for 2026 and similar cuts in preceding years, meaning Kentucky employers just saw their pricing relief stop rather than reverse into an increase.

Why did NCCI recommend holding steady?

The council's own summary flags a warning sign. Policy year 2024 produced a higher loss ratio than the prior two policy years, and NCCI says it cannot yet tell whether that deterioration is noise or a trend.

"Policy year 2024 produced a higher loss ratio than observed in the prior two policy years. It is not yet clear whether the loss ratio increase in policy year 2024 can be attributed to year-over-year volatility or the start of a longer-term trend in Kentucky," the NCCI wrote in its summary of recommendations.

The underlying signals point in different directions:

  • Claim frequency rose in 2024, breaking a long historical pattern of declines in how often workers file claims.
  • Indemnity claim severity stayed stable — payments for lost wages did not accelerate.
  • Medical severity decreased in the same year.

A rise in how often claims happen, with per-claim costs contained, is the classic early profile of a market turning. One clear takeaway: Kentucky's flat 0% outcome is a wait-and-see verdict, not a clean bill of health.

What is happening nationally?

The pressure on workers' comp economics is not unique to Kentucky. Across the 38 states where NCCI acts as rating and analytics agency, the 2025 combined ratio for workers' comp insurers rose from 86% to 91% — a five-point swing in a single year that erodes a large share of the line's underwriting margin.

A combined ratio below 100% means insurers earn an underwriting profit; at 86%, the business was exceptionally profitable. At 91%, it remains profitable but meaningfully less so. NCCI attributes the change primarily to increases in both the loss ratio and the underwriting expense ratio. That shift follows many years of declining worker injury rates across the country — a tailwind that now appears to be fading.

Payroll growth compounds the picture, because workers' comp premiums are calculated per dollar of payroll.

How much did wages and payroll move?

NCCI put hard numbers on the exposure driving premiums upward.

"From 2024 to 2025, payroll increased 4.8%, while employment rose just 0.5%," the NCCI noted.

That gap — 4.8% payroll growth against 0.5% employment growth — means the expansion came almost entirely from pay, not headcount. Average wages rose 4.3% in 2025. Employment growth was concentrated in the health care sector, according to the council.

For employers, the mechanics are straightforward: even where loss cost rates stay flat, a fatter payroll base lifts premium dollars. A Kentucky business with unchanged headcount and a 4.3% wage increase would pay roughly 4% more in workers' comp premium next year despite the 0% rate change.

The open question is whether 2024's frequency uptick repeats. NCCI's own language concedes it does not know, and its 2028 filing — informed by policy year 2025 data — will show whether Kentucky's flat line was a pause or the floor before increases begin.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,205 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »