Lionsgate's $3.4 Billion Gamble: Why Hunger Games Wins by Making Less
The Hunger Games has grossed $3.4 billion, yet Lionsgate has made just two spin-offs. Sunrise on the Reaping's $60M-tracked opening shows why restraint pays.
By Nathan Brooks
5 min read

What's News
- The Hunger Games franchise has grossed over $3.4 billion across five movies.
- Sunrise on the Reaping is tracking toward a US opening north of $60 million, per Deadline, up from Songbirds and Snakes' $44.6 million debut in 2023.
- Lionsgate acquired distribution rights to Suzanne Collins' novel in 2009, before Catching Fire and Mockingjay were published.
- The franchise has produced only two movies beyond the original four-film trilogy since 2012.
- At least 71 years of Panem lore remains unadapted despite the commercial incentive.
The Hunger Games franchise has grossed over $3.4 billion across five movies, and Lionsgate's newest installment, "Sunrise on the Reaping," is tracking toward a US opening weekend likely north of $60 million, according to Deadline. That would be a multimillion-dollar step up from its predecessor, "The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes," which opened to $44.6 million in 2023. And yet the studio that owns this machine has made exactly one spin-off beyond the original four-film trilogy.
"Sunrise on the Reaping" opens Friday as the sixth installment in the cinematic universe since the first film arrived in 2012. It may also be the last — a possibility that its bittersweet ending only sharpens.
The restraint is deliberate, and it starts with one person. Lionsgate, which acquired the distribution rights to Suzanne Collins' young adult novel back in 2009 — before "Catching Fire" and "Mockingjay" were even published — has long insisted that Collins is the "creative architect" of the franchise and the gatekeeper of every onscreen possibility. Executives have publicly pledged to follow the course she charts.
Producer Nina Jacobson put it plainly at a recent press junket: "We're back where we always are: We have no idea if she's going to write another book. We hope so." She added: "We thought we were done after 'Mockingjay.' It was a trilogy; we made four movies, that was that."
What does this change for Hollywood's franchise playbook?
Plenty, if you measure it against the competition. A "Game of Thrones" feature film is on the horizon, on top of HBO's two existing prequels and four more reportedly in development. Disney has churned out six "Star Wars" films — soon to be seven — plus seven live-action TV shows since acquiring the franchise in 2012 for $4 billion. The Avengers keep returning no matter how many galaxy-level threats they defeat.
The Hunger Games breaks that pattern, and not for lack of material. Collins has written five books set in the dystopian nation of Panem, and the lore runs far deeper. Katniss Everdeen enters the story as a tribute in the 74th annual Hunger Games. "Songbirds and Snakes," published in 2020, covered the 10th Games. "Sunrise on the Reaping" tells the origin of Haymitch Abernathy, winner of the 50th. That leaves at least 71 years' worth of unexplored arenas.
Fans have spent nearly 15 years asking for a Haymitch-centered narrative, along with answers to questions like how Finnick Odair became the youngest Victor in Panem history at the 65th Games, or how Plutarch Heavensbee turned from wealthy Capitol native into an architect of its downfall. Filmmakers could rewind to Panem's "Dark Days" and the invention of the Games as punishment, or build a post-Katniss sequel off "Mockingjay's" open ending. The commercial incentive is obvious; the studio has simply declined to act on all of it.
The opposite of franchise fatigue
The new movie is directed by Francis Lawrence, who has helmed the franchise since "Catching Fire." Joseph Zada inherits the Haymitch role from Woody Harrelson, adopting his predecessor's signature drawl and mannerisms while adding a tender naivete that keeps the character fresh. McKenna Grace plays Maysilee Donner; Elle Fanning plays Effie Trinket as a charming bootlicker.
Collins outlined Haymitch's defiant victory in the Second Quarter Quell long ago, but the book revealed the full extent of his suffering — and the Capitol's propaganda, which manipulated game footage to sanitize the official narrative and turn a traumatized 16-year-old into a pariah. The film, despite its conspicuous lack of gore in a story about teenagers killing each other, carries each death scene like a fingernail digging into raw skin.
It stumbles on the familiar Hollywood trap: the Easter egg. Fanning seems contractually obliged to say "mahogany," a nod to Elizabeth Banks' improvisation. Harrelson, Josh Hutcherson, and Jennifer Lawrence reprise their roles as Haymitch, Peeta, and Katniss in a corny, predictable epilogue that undercuts Zada's dramatic climax. The winks are unnecessary but forgivable.
Scarcity as strategy
Relative scarcity has kept the franchise from feeling oversaturated, giving fans time to miss these characters. The gaps also build trust that filmmakers will handle the material with care rather than exploit it through half-baked side projects — an especially appropriate posture for a series that warns against exploitation as entertainment.
The on-screen parallel is hard to miss. As Haymitch observes in a line invented for the "Catching Fire" movie: "No one ever wins the Games. Period. There are survivors." After his victory, Haymitch spends 24 years in self-medicated agony before meeting Katniss, when the seeds of revolution finally sprout. Delayed gratification is baked into the story itself.
That framing extends to the business. The movie's running theme and informal slogan — "Nothing is inevitable" — applies as neatly to franchise strategy as it does to rebellion. "Sunrise on the Reaping" isn't a cash-grab reboot; it's a focused story about incremental change across generations, and it brings back Haymitch, Effie, and Plutarch for a reason, not for the sake of it.
If this turns out to be the final blockbuster in the series, the franchise goes out having left billions of derivable revenue unproduced — and having stayed valuable precisely because of it. For studios weighing another spin-off, the lesson from Panem is that restraint, timed to the author's own pace, can outperform extraction.
Source: feeds.businessinsider.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,611 articles