Money & Markets

Lloyd’s £52m pledge amid a deeper slave-trade reckoning

Lloyd’s of London pledged £52m as researchers traced slave-trade underwriting in London, Liverpool and Bristol, but historians interviewed by InsuranceERM say the archive remains incomplete.

By Daniel Okafor

5 min read

Historians uncover more questions for insurers over their role in the slave trade
Historians uncover more questions for insurers over their role in the slave tradejarmoluk / pixabay

What's News

  • Lloyd’s of London committed £52m, including £12m for Inclusive Futures and £40m for profit-making investments in the African Development Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank.
  • The £1m Connector Project, funded by the Lloyd’s Register Foundation, is uncovering insurers’ links to slavery in Liverpool.
  • Lucy Moynihan found enslavement-linked voyages in John Gladstone’s 1797 risk book.
  • Britain outlawed the transatlantic slave trade in 1807, yet Hannah Farber says British insurers continued covering foreign slave voyages.
  • InsuranceERM released its podcast on the insurance industry’s reckoning with slavery on 10 November.

By Daniel Okafor

Lloyd’s of London has committed £52m to addressing its historic role in slavery, with £12m earmarked for Inclusive Futures and £40m for investments in two development banks.

The £12m supports Inclusive Futures initiatives to help Black and ethnically diverse individuals participate and progress “from the classroom to the boardroom,” Lloyd’s said. Lloyd’s also pledged £40m towards profit-making investments in the African Development Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank, which has programmes in the Caribbean.

Six years ago, Lloyd’s said it was “deeply sorry” for the “significant role” it played in the trafficking of enslaved people and for the enormous suffering caused. Lloyd’s has since installed a commemorative plaque at its London headquarters. The UK government is considering a formal apology for Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade.

What did the archive research reveal?

An independent collaboration with Johns Hopkins University sent researchers Alexandre White and Pyar Seth into Lloyd’s archives. The resulting Underwriting Souls project documented merchant insurers underwriting slave ships across the Atlantic and, in some cases, covering enslaved people as “human cargo.”

Some of those insurers had links through predecessor businesses to major insurers operating today, according to Underwriting Souls. Historians interviewed for a podcast by the specialist news title InsuranceERM said the full extent of the insurance industry’s involvement remains far from understood.

Why is the evidence still incomplete?

White, now an assistant professor at the University of Cambridge, said surviving evidence is fragmented. Risk books, the ledgers in which individual underwriters recorded their business, are particularly rare. White said they provide only a snapshot of an underwriter’s activity, not a complete account of that business.

Asked how much more evidence may remain, White said: “There could be tons.” White added: “It’s possible we’ll find more. It’s possible much has been destroyed … or lost to time.”

White said researchers are nevertheless getting “a much clearer sense of the scale and importance of insurance to slavery.” White said work in London, Liverpool and Bristol is helping reconstruct the financial networks that supported slavery.

What is the Liverpool project uncovering?

A £1m Connector Project is producing fresh evidence about insurers’ roles in Liverpool. The Lloyd’s Register Foundation funds the initiative, and National Museums Liverpool facilitates it. The foundation is an independent charity, separate from Lloyd’s of London, but has historical links to enslavement.

The project’s first pilot study, Overwriting Underwriting, is already piecing together new evidence. Lucy Moynihan, a PhD student and research associate, has examined the 1797 risk book of John Gladstone. Gladstone was an enslaver and merchant who later became the first chair of the Liverpool Underwriters’ Association.

Moynihan said previous histories had overlooked Gladstone’s work as an underwriter in the trafficking of enslaved people. Moynihan’s research has identified voyages in the 1797 risk book linked to enslavement. Her work has also added underwriting information missing from existing datasets.

How do insurers’ networks obscure the evidence?

Malik Al Nasir, an academic, author and Connector Project manager, said Liverpool’s merchants, shipowners, bankers and underwriters were often connected through family ties and commercial interests. Al Nasir said merchants’ dual role as underwriters means evidence can also sit in private family and business collections.

Moynihan said private archives have a responsibility to “do a review of what they have” and give the public access to their records. Al Nasir’s own research has involved sourcing material from disparate repositories and eBay because of gaps in established archives.

Al Nasir’s research led him to a letter referring to insurance for the sloop Speedwell, which he says does not appear in the widely used Slave Voyages database. Al Nasir said: “If I can just find randomly from one letter one slave ship that’s not mentioned on the Slave Voyages database, then there must be many others as well.”

What remains unresolved after 1807?

Historians interviewed by InsuranceERM said more remains to be uncovered about British insurers’ activity after Britain outlawed the transatlantic slave trade in 1807. Hannah Farber, an associate professor at Columbia University in New York City, said: “British insurers are pretty openly still involved with the insurance of foreign slave voyages after 1807.”

As enforcement tightened, Farber said financiers found more covert ways to take on the risks of slave voyages without formally underwriting them. Farber said: “It’s a lot easier to stop slave ships than it is to stop slave insurance.”

Farber believes substantial work remains to connect the financial centres of London, Liverpool and New York with Brazil and Cuba, where enslavement remained legal later into the 19th century. Farber added: “There’s so much more to learn about insurance in the slave trade.”

White said the records also reduced enslaved people to financial assets within the insurance system. White explained: “African lives at this time could still provide value not just from their bodies, not just from their labour, but also in their death.”

InsuranceERM released the podcast episode, Why insurance’s reckoning with the transatlantic slave trade is far from over, on 10 November. Joshua Geer is news editor at InsuranceERM.

The open question is how much of the market’s role remains undocumented. White said more records may surface, while Farber said researchers still need to connect the financial centres of London, Liverpool and New York with Brazil and Cuba.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,546 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »