Strategy

MapQuest's Contrarian Comeback Rides Gulf Naming Feuds and Flock Fear

MapQuest added 2 million users in a week by refusing Trump's Lake America renaming and mapping Flock surveillance cameras — but can a 40-person relic sustain a comeback built on defiance?

By Olivia Hart

4 min read

Annoying Trump and dodging Flock: inside MapQuest’s contrarian comeback
Annoying Trump and dodging Flock: inside MapQuest’s contrarian comebackDariuszSankowski / pixabay

What's News

  • MapQuest added over 2 million mobile users in one week after refusing the August 2025 Lake America renaming.
  • Flock's network spans 120,000 cameras across 6,000+ communities; EFF research ties under 1% of scanned vehicles to any crime.
  • MapQuest was bought by AOL for $1.1bn in 1999 and passed to Verizon ($4.4bn AOL deal, 2015) before System1 acquired it in 2019.
  • Cherokee County, Georgia approved a 10-year, $37.3m Axon surveillance contract on 3 November; DeKalb County signed a $18.9m Flock deal.
  • MapQuest still draws 35 million monthly website visitors and saw a ~10% traffic jump after the Gulf of America refusal.

MapQuest added more than 2 million mobile users in a single week after refusing to follow Donald Trump's executive order renaming Lake Ontario as Lake America. The surge, which briefly made it the top free navigation app on iOS and Android, was the clearest sign yet that a relic of the Y2K internet has found a business in defiance. Whether defiance alone sustains an app that still "hasn't updated its maps in like 15 years," as the company itself joked, is another question.

What triggered the comeback?

The first test came in January 2025, when Trump's executive order renamed the Gulf of Mexico the Gulf of America. Apple Maps and Google Maps adopted the change promptly. MapQuest did nothing. "I think the question that was posed internally was exactly that," said general manager Doug Berger, who took over during what he called the Gulf of America mishigas. "What if we didn't …?"

The company tweeted that it kept the Gulf of Mexico name "not because of politics but because we haven't updated our maps in like 15 years and don't remember how to do it." The irreverence paid off: the site, which still drew 35 million monthly visitors, saw roughly a 10% traffic jump in a month. In February 2025, it let users pick their own name for the gulf — options included Gulf of Gumbo and Gulf of Something.

When the Lake America order arrived in August, MapQuest declared: "We're not changing it." Canadians made up about half of the new users. Berger insists the position is not political. "Our stance, while it can be interpreted as political, really is about giving people familiar names," he said. That framing is convenient; the traffic numbers came from the refusal either way.

Why is it mapping surveillance cameras?

A Halloween-themed update last month added a user-requested feature: tracking surveillance cameras on the road. Flock's license-plate readers appear on the map as blinking red eyes beaming cones in the direction their lenses face.

The backdrop is real. Flock says its network has grown to 120,000 cameras across more than 6,000 communities in five years, turning passing cars into searchable records of who was where and when. Research from the Electronic Frontier Foundation shows less than 1% of vehicles scanned by automatic license-plate readers are ever connected to a crime or public safety issue. The camera data in MapQuest comes from OpenStreetMap, which also maps hardware from Motorola Solutions and Axon Enterprises.

"Flock has given people a name to put around them," said Chris Fleming, a UK-based OpenStreetMap volunteer. "Personally, I think it's important to know how prevalent these are, because if we don't know that they exist how can we debate about what level of surveillance is taking place, what is appropriate and who has access to it?"

Activist James Hayes, whom police visited at 1am without a warrant after a car chase two years ago, frames mass surveillance as a Fourth Amendment issue. "They had no arrest warrant, no anything," he said.

Where does the money come from?

MapQuest has spent 30 years changing hands. AOL paid $1.1 billion for it in 1999. Verizon absorbed AOL in a $4.4 billion deal in 2015. System1, a digital ad firm, bought it in 2019 for an undisclosed — and surely discounted — sum.

Today it is a 40-person operation in Los Angeles. Revenue comes from banner ads, premium subscriptions and licensing engagement tools — notably, not from selling user data. The nostalgia is deliberate, down to hand-drawn "questie" location markers. "Trust me, it would be very easy to create them with AI," Berger said. Ads are temporarily suspended to attract new users, which limits what the growth is worth today.

The product remains rough. It lacks full operating system integration, freezes on dashboards at times, and its ETAs tick upward as gridlock sets in. One school run lasted nearly 20 minutes longer than projected.

Can contrarianism scale?

The surveillance debate is escalating faster than MapQuest's polish. On 3 November, while voters were at the polls, Cherokee County's commissioners in Georgia voted unanimously for a 10-year, $37.3 million Axon contract covering body cameras, drones and plate readers. Last September, DeKalb County approved the nation's largest documented Flock deal — $18.9 million over 10 years — and last week rejected a civilian oversight committee.

"The datacenter thing was big this past midterm, but Flock is related to it," Hayes said. "The more datacenters, the more Flock." Berger, meanwhile, is already eyeing the next wedge issue: "synonyms for familiar places." A nine-base renaming fight under the Biden administration, later rolled back, suggests the map-naming wars will keep supplying MapQuest its lane.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,306 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »