Leadership

McDonald's loses bid to throw out 450 worker discrimination claims

A London employment judge has allowed 450 McDonald's discrimination claims to proceed to a full hearing in April, reviving litigation brought by current and former restaurant staff.

By Olivia Hart

5 min read

McDonald's sex abuse: 'They were waiting for the younger girls to turn 18'
McDonald's sex abuse: 'They were waiting for the younger girls to turn 18'AI-generated

What's News

  • Judge Glennie allowed 450 McDonald's discrimination claims to proceed at the London Central Employment Tribunal, according to a BBC report published 18 July 2023
  • The 450 cases cover current and former employees and are scheduled to be heard at the Employment Tribunal in April
  • The BBC understands the claims relate to indirect discrimination rather than sexual harassment
  • Hope, now 22, worked at a West Midlands branch in 2023 and says older colleagues fixated on 16- and 17-year-old workers
  • Leigh Day represents the claimants; partner Kiran Daurka called the ruling vital for access to justice

By Olivia Hart

450 discrimination claims against McDonald's will proceed to a full hearing after Judge Glennie refused the fast-food chain's attempt to strike them out at the London Central Employment Tribunal. The ruling, reported by the BBC on 18 July 2023, clears the way for an April hearing covering hundreds of current and former McDonald's employees.

The decision is procedural rather than a verdict on the merits. No damages have been quantified, and the BBC reported that the cases relate to indirect discrimination rather than sexual harassment — a distinction the report does not unpack, and one that will determine what evidence each side runs at trial. The practical effect is a hearing date, not a judgment.

What does the tribunal ruling change?

Hundreds of current and former employees are bringing the claim, which focuses on the vulnerability of young or female workers in the workplace. It follows allegations of widespread harassment and discrimination across McDonald's restaurants in the UK, and the law firm Leigh Day is presenting the cases.

Leigh Day partner Kiran Daurka told the BBC: "We're really delighted that the judge has found that these claims can go forward to a full hearing. It's really important for access to justice that these cases are heard." Until this week, McDonald's had argued for the complaints to be thrown out; the judge declined. The claims will now be tested by evidence rather than filtered at the door.

What did the former worker describe?

Hope, now 22, worked at a McDonald's branch in the West Midlands in 2023. She told BBC News that older colleagues eyed up 16- and 17-year-old workers and talked about wanting to sleep with them once they turned 18.

Her account of her own branch included these incidents:

  • A manager came up behind her and put his hands on her shoulders; from then on she says she "moved quick" to get away from him.
  • On a night shift, two customers sexualised and objectified her, and a manager failed to intervene.
  • When she reported the customers' conduct, she says the manager told her to "just suck it up and deal with it".

"I got the hell out of there," she says of the shoulder incident. Hope described her branch as having a very sexualised, "toxic" environment.

Her stated priority was the younger teenagers. "You could tell there were other staff members waiting for their 18th birthdays. That sort of like toxic culture where it's like, 'Oh, you know, it's not illegal now.' It was that feeling from quite a few of them," she says. "And why would you? That is literally a child still." That observation points at the gap the claim targets: a policy that treats a 17-year-old and an 18-year-old as equivalent.

Why did the workers take the case to court?

Hope said she is not taking part for money, adding that the group did not know whether they would receive anything. Her stated aim was to "change the way they treat younger employees".

"It's going to change the way they treat allegations. It's going to shake up the whole internal process and make life easier for the kids who are now having their first jobs. And it's going to make it a lot safer, I think, as well. And that's something you can't put a price on, the safety of the young these days."

She also accused McDonald's of trying to "delay the inevitable" by seeking to have the claims thrown out, and said: "And the judge quite rightly looked at them and said: 'No. We're not going to do that.'" That expectation — that litigation will force procedural change — is also a claim the tribunal will test, since a policy promise is not the same as a proven outcome.

What does McDonald's say?

A McDonald's spokesperson said the company could not comment on the specifics of ongoing legal proceedings. The company issued a general statement: "Ensuring a safe, respectful and inclusive working environment across our restaurants and offices remains a fundamental priority."

In a separate statement, McDonald's said it had "embedded an extensive set of robust and far-reaching initiatives" as part of its "steadfast commitment" to staff, adding that this work continues. The spokesperson added: "Any form of harassment, discrimination or inappropriate behaviour is unacceptable and has no place in our restaurants or offices. We are confident that with the guidance and partnership of external experts, we and our franchisees have industry leading safeguarding measures in place."

The statement does not address the specific allegations, including the reported instruction to "just suck it up and deal with it", and it makes no reference to the 450 claims or to the tribunal's ruling. The claim of "industry leading safeguarding measures" is a company assertion rather than a tested finding, and the BBC's characterisation of the claims as indirect discrimination sits uneasily beside the same report's account of groping and harassment. That gap is likely to be where the two sides meet in April.

The litigation follows a BBC investigation in 2023 that heard from workers, some as young as 17, being groped and harassed. Staff had told the BBC the year before that they still faced sexual abuse and harassment.

What happens next

The claims are listed to be heard at the Employment Tribunal in April, with 450 cases consolidated into a process McDonald's failed to stop. If that hearing proceeds, the evidence will test whether the "initiatives" and "safeguarding measures" McDonald's cites have any protective effect on 16- and 17-year-old and female staff in practice. Until a tribunal rules on the merits, the company's defence is procedural confidence, and the judge has already declined to let procedure close the case.

Source: BBC Business

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,378 articles

Related articles

« Previous article