Nadella: AI agents will reshuffle who pays whom on the web
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella told the NYT DealBook Summit that AI agents will 'reshuffle' web economics, warning ad-reliant aggregators to shift to CPC or transactional models — or cede ground to rivals.
By Amara Osei
3 min read

What's News
- Satya Nadella spoke at The New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday.
- He said aggregators monetizing the 'human web' through ads will be 'reshuffled' toward CPC or transactional models.
- Amazon currently blocks AI agents from browsing its catalog or making purchases for users.
- Nadella suggested Shopify could gain an advantage over Amazon by allowing agents.
- He likened the agent shift to the earlier transition from portals like Yahoo to search engines like Google.
Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella says the rise of AI agents will reshape the economics of the internet, hitting companies whose business models depend on advertising and what he called "human web" traffic.
Speaking at The New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday, Nadella argued that the shift to an agentic web could change which companies pay others for traffic and transactions. He compared the coming disruption to an earlier transition: the move from web portals like Yahoo to search engines like Google.
"The current aggregators who have a business model which was for the human web will get, in some sense, reshuffled," Nadella said.
How does monetization change when agents replace eyeballs?
The core of Nadella's argument is a pricing shift. When software agents, not people, browse and buy, the economics of attention break down.
"And if you were monetizing ads because of the eyeballs, you now have to probably get down to essentially maybe CPC [cost-per-click] wins; maybe it's more transactional," he continued. "And so if you don't accept the agent, somebody else will."
That last line doubles as a competitive warning. In Nadella's framing, publishers and platforms don't get to opt out of the agentic web and keep their old margins. Someone else will take the agent traffic — and the transactions that come with it.
The comparison to portals is doing real work in his argument. Yahoo-era aggregators lost their grip when search engines became the front door to the web. Nadella's suggestion is that agent platforms could become the new front door, and the companies that currently collect ad revenue for routing human visitors may find themselves paying, or being paid, on very different terms.
Why is Amazon's agent blockade part of the story?
The discussion turned to Amazon and its decision to block AI agents from accessing its retail website. The block prevents agents from browsing Amazon's catalog and making purchases on behalf of their users.
Nadella suggested that companies trying to protect existing business models could lose out to rivals more willing to embrace agents. He offered a concrete scenario: if Amazon keeps blocking agents, another shopping platform — he named Shopify — could allow them and gain an advantage.
The implication for e-commerce is straightforward. An agent that can't complete a purchase on Amazon will complete it somewhere else. For a platform whose moat is catalog breadth and logistics, that's an uncomfortable trade-off between protecting current conversion data and staying reachable where buying decisions increasingly happen.
"I think this is going to be interesting," Nadella said of the changing models.
What does the scramble look like for incumbents?
Nadella's bluntest warning was aimed at executives attached to the status quo.
"It's the same thing that's happening in other categories, right? Which is, if you're in love with a particular business model, you have to kind of scramble," he said.
That's a self-aware position for the CEO of Microsoft, a company that has repeatedly rebuilt its business around platform shifts — and one now betting heavily on AI through its OpenAI partnership and its Copilot product line. Nadella isn't describing a distant hypothetical; he's describing a redistribution of payments and traffic that starts when agents become mainstream shoppers, readers and bookers.
For ad-dependent publishers and retailers, the so-what is hard to miss. The choice isn't between the old ad model and the new agent economy — it's between cutting deals with agents on transactional terms, or watching a competitor like Shopify do it first.
Original: nytimes.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,336 articles