Nvidia Fell From 8.5% to Under 6% of the S&P 500 in Six Weeks
Nvidia slid from 8.5% to under 6% of the S&P 500 in six weeks. J.P. Morgan's Michael Cembalest says it is now the cheapest major AI stock — if history's Icarus pattern spares it.
By Olivia Hart
3 min read

What's News
- Nvidia rose from 1% to 8.5% of the S&P 500 in under four years, the fastest climb to the top since 1960.
- Its index weight has fallen below 6% after roughly six weeks of decline.
- Only 2 of the 10 companies that held the S&P 500's top market-cap spot since 1960 — Microsoft and Apple — avoided a lasting fall.
- J.P. Morgan's Michael Cembalest says Nvidia is now the cheapest major AI stock and attractive long-term.
Nvidia's weight in the S&P 500 has fallen from 8.5% to below 6% in roughly six weeks, a slide that one Wall Street strategist now frames against a sixty-year pattern of boom and bust. Michael Cembalest, chairman of market and investment strategy at J.P. Morgan Asset Management, published the analysis over the weekend under the title "The Icarus Files." The name does the arguing for him.
The core numbers are stark. Nvidia's climb from 1% of the S&P 500 to 8.5% — a more than eightfold increase in relative size — took less than four years. That is the fastest ascent to the top of the index among the ten companies that have held the number-one market-cap position since 1960, according to Cembalest's note. Eight of those ten, he notes, "returned to Earth with a resounding thud." Only Microsoft and Apple escaped a lasting fall.
What does the history actually show?
The historical record cuts both ways. Since 1960, ten companies have occupied the apex of the U.S. market. All but Microsoft and Apple suffered steep, durable declines after their peaks. For Nvidia bulls, those two exceptions matter: they prove a mega-cap can lose the crown and recover, rather than fade into irrelevance. For skeptics, the odds remain two out of ten — an 80% failure rate across six decades.
Cembalest's own position sits closer to the optimists, with conditions attached. After the decline of recent weeks, Nvidia trades at the cheapest valuation among major artificial-intelligence stocks, he wrote. Even so, he frames the case as attractive on a long-term basis — a horizon that, notably, he does not define in numerical terms within the note.
The takeaway: history says most market-cap kings fall hard, but two named survivors give Nvidia a precedent worth watching rather than a verdict.
Why the valuation argument needs stress-testing
The claim that Nvidia is now the cheapest of the large AI names deserves scrutiny, because cheapness is relative to earnings, and Nvidia's earnings have themselves been a product of extraordinary demand. A stock can look inexpensive against near-term profits and still be expensive if those profits prove cyclical. Cembalest's note acknowledges the meteoric rise and the rapid fall in the same breath; it does not, at least as summarized, resolve what happens to the valuation denominator if AI capital spending slows.
What is said is concrete: the discount to peers exists today. What is not said is how durable that discount's inputs are. Investors reading "attractive on a long-term basis" should note that strategist language of this kind rarely carries a price target or a time frame in the public excerpt.
The takeaway: "cheapest AI stock" is a snapshot, not a forecast — the number depends on earnings that the same note describes as having risen at an unsustainable-seeming pace.
What happens next?
The six-week drawdown has already reset Nvidia's index weight by more than two and a half percentage points — a swing large enough that passive funds tracking the S&P 500 now hold proportionally less of the stock without selling a single share. If the Microsoft-Apple analogy holds, the current slump is a chapter, not the ending. If the other eight precedents hold, the fall has further to run. Cembalest's "Icarus Files" leaves readers with the more useful question: not whether Nvidia can fly again, but whether its wings were ever built for altitude in the first place.
Source: MarketWatch
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,205 articles