Leadership

Nvidia Had No Succession Plan When Jensen Huang Quit, Ex-CEOs Say

Jensen Huang quit on November 12 with no heir apparent. Three ex-Fortune 500 CEOs call Nvidia's lack of a succession plan a shocking governance failure at the $5.8 trillion chipmaker.

By Daniel Okafor

4 min read

Nvidia had no succession plan when Jensen Huang quit. Former Fortune 500 CEOs call it ‘preposterous’
Nvidia had no succession plan when Jensen Huang quit. Former Fortune 500 CEOs call it ‘preposterous’Pexels / pixabay

What's News

  • Nvidia announced Jensen Huang's resignation on November 12; CFO Colette Kress became interim CEO.
  • Nvidia's valuation peaked at $5.8 trillion in early October after a rise of over $5 trillion in four years.
  • Huang held just 3.5% of Nvidia shares; Blackstone is the largest holder at 8.1%.
  • None of Nvidia's seven non-founder directors has been a Fortune 500 CEO; four have served 13-29 years.
  • Huang oversaw roughly 60 direct reports; ex-CEOs say the optimal number is 8 to 12.

Nvidia, the world's second-most-valuable company, had no succession plan in place when Jensen Huang resigned on November 12 — a failure three former Fortune 500 CEOs and a leading consultant call a basic breakdown in corporate governance. All four critics, interviewed by Fortune, serve on or advise prominent corporate boards.

The board's press release named longtime CFO Colette Kress as "interim CEO" immediately, while directors conduct a "search for a permanent Chief Executive Officer and will consider internal and external candidates." Kress spent a quarter century in Big Tech finance, including thirteen years at Microsoft, before joining Nvidia in 2013. Her resume on the Nvidia website lists no role where she ran a business or owned a P&L. That record makes a permanent promotion unlikely.

Was Kress the plan, or pure improvisation?

It remains unclear whether Nvidia maintained an emergency plan that put Kress in charge during a crisis, or improvised entirely. One retired CEO, identified here as ex-CEO 3, believes it was the latter. "It seems like a knee-jerk, panic reaction where the board's saying, 'We've got to name someone!'" the former chief said. "You've got to ask why a tech company would go with a financial person."

The critics find it staggering that a company in business 33 years and public for 27 had no groomed leader ready. Huang turns 64 in February and was already the oldest CEO by far in the Mag Seven.

They identified four red flags.

Red flag one: Success hid the problem

Huang lifted Nvidia's valuation by well over $5 trillion in four years, to a peak of $5.8 trillion in early October — the highest ever reached. That record, the critics argue, kept investors from installing safeguards against the departure of the ultimate "key man."

"No one peeled back the layers on how Nvidia was run because they were so successful," said ex-CEO 1. "No one looked behind the curtain. Their success lulled people into a false sense of security." The same observer called the situation "preposterous," adding: "When you have a celebrity CEO, that person merits a closer look, especially when you have a leader who's always putting on a show."

Red flag two: A board of old friends

Unlike Elon Musk at SpaceX, Sergey Brin and Larry Page at Alphabet, or Mark Zuckerberg at Meta, Huang held no supermajority share class. Nvidia has a single class of one-vote-one-share stock. Its largest holders are institutions: Blackstone at 8.1%, Vanguard at 6.5%, State Street at 4.2%, Fidelity at 3.9%, and Morgan Stanley, T. Rowe Price and J.P. Morgan at around 5% combined. Huang held "just" 3.5%.

Despite that dispersed ownership, Huang effectively controlled the board. Of the seven directors besides Huang, none has served as CEO of a Fortune 500 company, and four have served between 13 and 29 years.

"In any company that runs well over time, you'll find the board has lots of current or retired CEOs, and credible outside senior executives," said ex-CEO 2. "When you see a board that looks like a lot of old friends and people who've been there for decades, it flashes danger."

Ex-CEO 2 called succession the board's core duty: "It's the most important thing the board does by a mile. The ground has to be plowed for succession. The board likes to talk about M&A and all these exotic things but they pale beside succession."

Ex-CEO 3 framed the failure starkly: "Boards have all kinds of governance rules but just two major responsibilities. First, don't do a deal that kills you, and second, have the right person running the place and a backup plan to replace them. Nvidia's board failed on one of the two big items."

The consultant added: "The lesson from Nvidia is that emergencies happen more often than you think and it's a big mistake to have a structure and mindset that assumes they won't happen to you. That Nvidia has no obvious successor imposes a real cost."

Red flag three: Sixty direct reports

Huang proudly described overseeing around 60 "direct reports," touting a "flat" organization. The critics see the opposite: a structure that tested no one. "It's highly possible that none of those lieutenants had enough responsibility to have actually been tested," said ex-CEO 3. Ex-CEO 1 put the optimal count at 8 to 12. The consultant agreed: with so many reports, "none have been exposed to top roles in a deep and meaningful way. So it's hard to imagine anyone internally who is ready to take over."

What happens next?

The consultant expects Nvidia to "telescope the training" for insiders who were never prepared. Ex-CEO 3 predicts an external hire: not a veteran in his early 60s, but "someone who is, say, 50 and wants to show the world something."

Ex-CEO 2 offered a final verdict on the board's laxity: "If Nvidia hadn't been performing well, it would have been exhibit A for an activist attack." The governance gap that Huang's fall exposed now sets the agenda: whether Nvidia, an exceptional performer, can master what most of the Fortune 500 already does better — strong corporate governance.

Source: fortune.com

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,189 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »