Innovation & Tech

Only One of Africa's 39 Instant Payment Systems Is 'Mature'

AfricaNenda's fifth SIIPS report finds only Nigeria's NIP is 'mature' among 39 African instant payment systems, as bank-controlled governance and falling transaction values block upgrades.

By Olivia Hart

5 min read

The Next Wave: What Africa’s instant payment systems keep getting wrong on the way to maturity
The Next Wave: What Africa’s instant payment systems keep getting wrong on the way to maturityIqbalStock / pixabay

What's News

  • Of 39 instant payment systems in Africa as of July 2026, only Nigeria's NIP is rated 'mature'; 11 are 'progressed', 19 'basic', 8 unranked.
  • AfricaNenda, with the World Bank and UNECA, published the fifth SIIPS report on November 19, 2026.
  • Average payment value fell from $43 in 2022 to $26 in 2025; mobile money averages $9.
  • Only 3 of 36 systems graded in both years moved up a tier, all via merchant payments.
  • AfricaNenda links instant payment systems to ~7 percentage points higher active account use and ~17% higher GDP per capita after launch.

Of the 39 instant payment systems operating in Africa as of July 2026, exactly one — Nigeria's NIBSS Instant Payment — earned a "mature" rating, the top grade in the AfricaNenda Foundation's 2026 inclusivity assessment. The platform, run by the Nigeria Inter-Bank Settlement System, first reached that level in 2025 and has kept it. Eleven systems were rated "progressed", 19 "basic", and eight went unranked.

AfricaNenda, a Gates-backed non-profit that works with central banks on payments, published the findings on November 19 in Balaclava, Mauritius, in its fifth State of Inclusive Instant Payment Systems (SIIPS) report, produced with the World Bank and the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa. The authors — Deputy CEO Sabine Mensah, Director of Advocacy and Capacity Development Jacqueline Jumah, and Data Scientist Prince Ilboudo — flag persistent gaps in bank participation, pricing, governance and consumer recourse.

Progress since the previous assessment has been minimal. Of the 36 systems graded in both years, only three moved up, and all three did so by adding merchant payments. None reached "progressed".

How the four-step scale works

Unranked systems miss the basics: they either do not work on the phones most people use or do not let users pay a shop. Basic ones clear that bar. Progressed systems are open to every licensed provider, give all participants a say in governance, and involve the central bank. Mature systems add services such as credit, set recourse standards above regulatory minimums, and keep fees low without running at a loss.

The takeaway: most African rails clear the entry bar and then stop.

Who owns the rails — and who competes on them

Kenya's PesaLink illustrates the governance problem most sharply. The report describes it as "otherwise close" to progressed, with ownership structure holding it back. The network is run by Integrated Payment Services Limited (IPSL), whose sole shareholder is the Kenya Bankers Association. Non-bank participants have no representation in the KBA's decision-making, and the Central Bank of Kenya has no direct role in running the scheme.

IPSL chief executive Gituku Kirika has spent the year pushing banks toward a common tariff: free for transfers of KES 1,000 ($7.75) or less, KES 20 ($0.15) above that. Sending KES 50,000 ($388) costs KES 20 under the tariff, versus KES 108 ($0.84) on M-PESA or Airtel Money. Five of Kenya's largest banks — KCB, Co-operative Bank, NCBA, Absa and Stanbic — have adopted it. Equity Bank, Standard Chartered and I&M have not.

"We don't dictate prices to our customers," Kirika said. "We do share with them what we believe is the right approach to pricing instant payments. The banks make decisions based on their strategies and budgets." He expects every bank to switch by the end of 2027. IPSL cannot force them.

The pattern repeats elsewhere. On Mozambique's SIMOrede, e-money issuers receive board decisions without voting on them. On PesaLink, SACCOs, fintechs, telcos and microfinance banks outnumber banks on the network but hold no voting rights, Kirika said in 2025. Handing control to the central bank raises its own conflict: the regulator would run the system it supervises.

The takeaway: the cheapest way to move money between banks still depends on each bank agreeing to give up transfer revenue.

Why success is starving the systems

Between 2021 and 2025, transaction volume on African systems grew 28% a year while value grew 11%. The average payment fell from $43 in 2022 to $26 in 2025; on mobile money it is now $9. More people are using the rails for everyday spending — the mission working as designed. But each sale gets smaller while the cost of making it does not, and none of the 11 progressed systems lets anyone build credit or insurance on top, or exceeds minimum recourse standards.

The report urges operators to stop charging per transaction and sell services instead — credit tools, anonymised data, shared fraud intelligence. The report's own framing concedes the difficulty: most of these systems were built as utilities, and utilities are good at being boring and bad at selling.

What users actually want

AfricaNenda surveyed 1,403 people across 15 markets. Between a third and a half had been defrauded or hit a failed payment. Most did not retreat to cash; only those who lost money permanently cut back, and even among them only 43% did. In Nigeria, one in five people who received a refund used digital payments more than before. In South Africa, half of fraud victims cut back.

"A failed transaction may represent food a mother can no longer buy, school fees she cannot pay, or working capital she no longer has for her small business," AfricaNenda CEO Dr Robert Ochola writes. "Recourse, therefore, is not a secondary feature but an essential one." A third of people who hit a problem never report it, mostly because they do not know how; the authors want a dispute button inside the app rather than another awareness campaign.

User demands barely vary by country: instant arrival, a clear confirmation, and the recipient's name on screen before sending. A shop owner in rural Morocco asked for "a big green screen that tells me, 'The money is in your pocket now.' Not 'Processing' or 'Pending'."

The economics favor the fix. The report links instant payment systems to active account use about seven percentage points higher and GDP per capita roughly 17% higher in the years after launch. "The question now is not whether instant payment systems contribute value," Ochola writes. "It is whether Africa can develop the regulatory, technological, and institutional architecture that allows us to harness useful innovation safely and on our own terms."

Source: techcabal.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,538 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »