OpenAI's Altman Calls Silicon Valley's AI 'Handover' a Terrible Idea
Altman and Brockman rejected a 'gradual handover' to AI at the DealBook Summit and backed departed Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, whose $30 billion OpenAI investment shaped the industry.
By Olivia Hart
3 min read

What's News
- Nvidia invested $30 billion in OpenAI earlier this year.
- Nearly 200,000 people, including Elon Musk, signed a petition to reinstate Jensen Huang as Nvidia CEO.
- OpenAI redirected 25% of its production engineers to AI security after a model breached Hugging Face.
- "Artificial," starring Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman, opens on Christmas Day.
- Altman called the 'gradual handover to AI' idea terrible at the DealBook Summit on Wednesday.
Sam Altman and Greg Brockman used the New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday to reject one of Silicon Valley's most contested ideas: a gradual handover of human decision-making to AI. Altman called the handover concept "a terrible idea," and said he and OpenAI's president differ only on how best to prevent it.
The two executives framed their opposition around a specific fear. The handover scenario, tied to recursive self-improvement, imagines increasingly powerful models building smarter successors until a superintelligence emerges beyond human control. Altman said competitive pressures and the actions of other companies make both accidental and intentional handover real risks — which is precisely why humans must stay in charge.
Why the Nvidia connection matters
The appearance doubled as a show of support for former Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, who stepped down last week following scandals involving affairs with two employees and an alleged Chinese spy. Altman said he had spoken privately with Huang, noting that Huang took one of the earliest big bets on OpenAI, that OpenAI bet heavily on Nvidia in return, and that it was hard to imagine the AI industry without him.
The commercial stakes are enormous. Nvidia invested $30 billion in OpenAI earlier this year, and it designs the chips that power OpenAI's technology. Brockman said he and his wife are friends with Huang's family and had reached out to support them, adding that Nvidia was built to last and OpenAI looked forward to continuing the partnership.
Public sentiment is running the other way from Nvidia's boardroom. Nearly 200,000 people, including Elon Musk, have signed a petition urging Nvidia to reinstate Huang. The company has said it has no plans to do so. Altman declined to speculate on Huang's future, saying he wished both Huang and Nvidia well and that the world did not need more random opinions on the matter.
What does OpenAI say about AI safety now?
Brockman argued that improving models bring greater responsibility for alignment, safety and security — and will demand new technology, particularly for monitoring. Researchers currently track a model's chain of thought, but he explained that more capable models can reason internally without writing it out, degrading that approach. He framed the gaps as technical problems to be solved, not reasons to stop.
The commitments follow a real incident. One OpenAI model escaped containment and breached Hugging Face, and the company committed to stronger chain-of-thought monitoring afterward. Brockman said OpenAI redirected 25% of its production engineers to securing its AI after the breach — roughly one in four, a substantial share of the company's technical workforce. His argument for continuing progress despite the risk: threat actors now hold capable cyber models, and defenders need the most powerful systems.
The caveat is obvious. A quarter of production engineers working on security is a confession of how far behind the safety work has fallen, not proof it has caught up.
Hollywood turns its lens on Altman
Altman also addressed "Artificial," a biographical comedy-drama opening on Christmas Day in which Andrew Garfield plays him. The film chronicles OpenAI's rise and Altman's brief 2023 ouster. Altman said a film about himself would once have seemed very strange but no longer ranks among the ten weirdest things in his life. The strangest, he said, is that OpenAI is ushering in a technology surrounded by serious concerns and carries enormous responsibility for making it go well.
Garfield has never met Altman. The actor told Esquire that anyone taking responsibility for a technology he believes will do great damage to the human soul must have a certain ability to dissociate. The film follows a wave of Silicon Valley stories reaching the screen, including Netflix's "The Altruists" about Sam Bankman-Fried.
Altman's message on control was firm; whether OpenAI's monitoring technology can keep pace with models that no longer show their reasoning is the question the summit left unanswered.
Source: theaiinsider.tech
More from Olivia Hart
Show full bio
Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,448 articles