Economy & Policy

Researchers accuse tobacco firms of silencing critics through employers

Researchers say tobacco firms used employer complaints, information requests and legal pressure to silence critics. A Tobacco Control report calls for stronger protections.

By Olivia Hart

5 min read

‘The abuse I copped was phenomenal’: researchers accuse tobacco companies of intimidation tactics to silence critics
‘The abuse I copped was phenomenal’: researchers accuse tobacco companies of intimidation tactics to silence criticsAI-generated

What's News

  • Thursday’s Tobacco Control report characterizes employer complaints against researchers as a systemic challenge.
  • A tobacco company demanded Pisinger’s firing from a hospital in 2013.
  • Maddox cited 66 deaths a day in Australia and 37% of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander deaths.
  • Bast counted about 15 industry representatives at an event launching youth nicotine-use data.

By Olivia Hart

A report published Thursday in the international journal Tobacco Control calls employer complaints against tobacco-control researchers “not isolated incidents but part of a systemic challenge.” It examines online discreditation, information requests and legal threats.

Led by Emily Banks, an Australian physician and epidemiologist, the paper says tobacco companies use threats and employer complaints against advocates, researchers and policymakers. It calls this “a deliberate strategy to silence critics, distort evidence, and weaken regulation.”

Banks said investigators cannot establish tobacco-industry involvement in every case, yet tobacco-control work exposes researchers to intimidation tactics. The paper asks governments and employers to treat intimidation as an occupational health and safety issue.

How did Philip Morris challenge a researcher?

Prof Charlotta Pisinger, a medical doctor and public health researcher, received an employer complaint after interviews questioning heated tobacco, vapes and whether Philip Morris International cared about improving health. The Danish subsidiary of PMI accused her of breaching the University of Southern Denmark’s research communication standards.

PMI’s complaint said: “Pisinger claims that PMI lies and deceives. We assume that Pisinger’s statements are to be understood polemically and not as an expression of a factual legal matter.” It also accused her of failing to clarify whether her comments reflected scientific expertise or personal opinion, overstating conclusions and omitting context.

Pisinger said: “In countries where proper tobacco legislation is still not in place, they [the tobacco industry] still charge ahead and do everything they can to promote cigarettes.”

A corporate-affairs manager for PMI in Denmark said the company “respects the right of academics to express their views, including views critical of our company.” The manager said: “Equally, we believe that claims presented as scientific fact should be open to scrutiny and challenge.”

PMI also said: “Our complaint … does not seek to restrict [Pisinger’s] freedom to speak or participate in public debate.” Pisinger’s account and PMI’s response show how a complaint can turn disputed claims into a test of an employer’s research standards.

What tactics do researchers face?

The report identifies public and online discreditation, freedom of information requests and legal threats. It says critics have been labelled “zealots” and “extremists” while their work was misrepresented. The paper offers strategies to anticipate, withstand and learn from pushback.

Banks said she has felt intimidated after online abuse or when people contacted her boss “and that person’s boss up the line to question the way I’m working.” She added: “Of course people have the right to seek information, but our paper finds that freedom of information requests can be weaponised for industry intimidation.”

The paper also accuses tobacco companies of using front groups, third parties and deliberately obscured affiliations. It says legitimate actions can burden, discredit or deter critics. Banks’s caveat leaves disputed attribution possible, but administrative and legal tools can still serve as pressure.

What did Australia’s vaping inquiry reveal?

Raglan Maddox, an associate professor at the Australian National University and a paper co-author, received “the most abuse I have ever received in one day” after speaking publicly during a vaping inquiry. He said children’s health was a human right and discussed nicotine addiction.

He said: “I spoke about children grappling with nicotine addiction and not being able to sleep without having a vape under their pillow and the types of things we need to support them through nicotine addiction.” The report notes that many major vape brands are owned or supported by tobacco companies.

Maddox said: “The abuse I copped for 24 hours after that was phenomenal. Why would [the abusers] be questioning the way I look, my character, instead of an industry that continues to fuel 66 deaths a day in Australia, and 37% of all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander deaths?”

Maddox’s figures translate to roughly one death every 22 minutes in Australia and more than one in three deaths among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. At Australia’s parliamentary inquiry into illicit tobacco, public-health experts testified publicly, while industry figures could give evidence anonymously behind closed doors.

“While they stood in the same hallways as us, the public accountability … is very different,” Maddox said. “They’re protected from that scrutiny, and health practitioners don’t have that same privilege.”

The paper says attacks can escalate to physical violence where advocates lack institutional or government backing. It alleges some researchers have faced death threats, though such cases remain rare. Maddox’s account shows how public participation can trigger concentrated retaliation.

What does an intimidation complaint cost?

Pisinger says a tobacco company demanded that she be fired from the hospital where she worked in 2013. She said each employer complaint forces her to explain her work and provide documentation. “It is time-consuming and unpleasant until it is resolved,” she said.

Lotus Sofie Bast of Denmark’s National Institute of Public Health, who was not involved in the study, said she and her legal department spend “hours” answering industry freedom of information requests. Industry representatives also attended student PhD defenses, took notes and wore sunglasses indoors.

Bast said industry representatives fought to attend an event launching youth nicotine-use data. She counted about 15 in the room. “There was kind of an odd feeling in the room, and comments from other participants were rather sparse,” she said. She fears younger researchers may be deterred from tobacco-control work.

Who must change the response?

The World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control requires governments to protect health policies from tobacco-industry influence. Researchers including Pisinger and Bast also adhere to that principle. The paper calls on employers to support staff through complaints and governments to enforce rules barring interference more strictly.

Recommendations include a risk-management plan, stronger digital security, and documentation and reporting of every threat. The paper says: “For those in tobacco control, the legacy will not be the attacks they endured, but the collective progress they helped secure.”

If governments and employers implement those measures, the practical test will be whether future complaints support researchers rather than transfer pressure to their workplaces.

Source: theguardian.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,378 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »