Innovation & Tech

Sam Altman Rejects Elon Musk's Vision of Humans as AI's Pets

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman rejected Elon Musk's idea of humanity as AI's pets, telling DealBook: "I don't want to be a Labrador." Rivals now align on slowing self-improving AI.

By Olivia Hart

3 min read

Sam Altman doesn't like Elon Musk's vision of a future where humans are 'happy' pets to AI
Sam Altman doesn't like Elon Musk's vision of a future where humans are 'happy' pets to AIRoonzNL / pixabay

What's News

  • Altman said at NYT DealBook Summit on Wednesday: "I don't want to be a Labrador. I don't want my kids to be Labradors."
  • Musk told The Economist in July that "Labradors are pretty happy creatures," revisiting his decade-old pet analogy.
  • Musk, Altman and Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei endorsed Amodei's September call to slow self-improving frontier AI research.
  • In May, a jury ruled Musk waited too long to sue Altman and OpenAI over the lab's shift in direction.
  • Musk's recursive self-improvement warning came in 2015, nearly eight years before ChatGPT's release.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman has publicly rejected Elon Musk's old suggestion that advanced AI could leave humanity in the role of a house pet, declaring at The New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday: "I don't want to be a Labrador. I don't want my kids to be Labradors. I want people to have the agency over the future that we have had."

Altman's comments targeted remarks Musk made more than a decade ago. In July, The Economist asked Musk about his earlier observation that AI advancing too quickly would make humans "like a pet Labrador." Musk's reply, delivered while chuckling: "Labradors are pretty happy creatures, that's my experience."

What did Musk actually say about self-improving AI?

The Labrador line traces back to a deeper technical argument. In 2015, Musk and astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson discussed what happens if AI reaches recursive self-improvement — the stage where AI advances itself with minimal or no human guidance. Some in the field have warned that at that point AI could rapidly surpass human intelligence and escape any means of control.

"That's all she wrote," Musk said, repeating Tyson's words. He described worrying that a recursively self-improving AI "could reprogram itself to be smarter and iterate very quickly and do that 24 hours a day on millions of computers."

That exchange happened almost eight years before ChatGPT's release. It is less theoretical now. Musk himself, in his telling, is the supposed pet owner here — yet he has also voiced alarm about the outcome. "I don't love the idea of being a house cat," he said in 2016. His proposed fix then: hook human brains directly into computers.

Who now agrees on slowing AI down?

Notably, the rivals have converged on at least one position. Musk, Altman, and Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei all endorsed Amodei's September call to slow frontier AI research that pushes models toward self-improvement — and to use the resulting time to find more effective ways of keeping models under human control.

Altman has repeated his position in recent weeks: the industry must not accept any scenario in which humans cede control to AI. He has also said he is not convinced his competitors share that commitment — a claim that is easy to make and, so far, backed by no named evidence.

Speaking alongside OpenAI President Greg Brockman at DealBook, Altman said: "We both believe very deeply that people need to stay in control of the future. And there's increasing talk about, well, there is either going to be or there should be this sort of gradual handover to AI. And we both agree that that's a terrible idea."

The word "both" does a lot of work in that quote. It covers Altman and Brockman, not the industry at large.

How old is this feud?

The Labrador exchange is tame by the standards of the Altman-Musk relationship. Their feud dates back years, rooted in Musk's anger over OpenAI's shift in direction. Musk cofounded the AI lab and was an early financial backer before breaking with it. In May, a jury ruled that Musk waited too long to sue Altman and OpenAI over the matter, closing off that legal avenue.

What Altman did not address on stage is the harder question: how a commitment to "staying in control" gets enforced in practice. Endorsing a pause on self-improving AI research is one thing; verifying that every frontier lab honors it is another. The endorsement of Amodei's September call suggests the industry's leading figures at least agree the window for answering that question is narrowing.

Source: feeds.businessinsider.com

Share this article:

More from Olivia Hart

Olivia Hart

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,378 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »