SanDisk's 60% Crash Looks Overdone, Say Wall Street Analysts
SanDisk dropped 22.26% on Nov 5 and trades near $886, over 60% below its June peak. Fitzgerald and Morgan Stanley call it overdone — but the chart says the downtrend isn't broken yet.
By Grace Kim
3 min read

What's News
- SanDisk fell 22.26% on Nov 5, its biggest one-day drop this year, and trades near $886 — over 60% below its June peak of ~$2,350.
- Fitzgerald values SanDisk at 2.6x 2028 expected earnings, versus 9x for Nvidia and 3x for Micron, and estimates $82 billion cumulative free cash flow through 2028.
- Morgan Stanley says the company could buy back more than half its shares and calls the midterm-driven reaction overdone since data center projects are delayed, not cancelled.
- The bearish technical view stays valid unless SanDisk posts a 4H close above $1,000; a close below $800 targets $500.
- Nvidia reports earnings Nov 17, with its spending commentary the key read-through for storage demand over the next 1-2 weeks.
By Grace Kim
SanDisk fell 22.26% in a single session on Nov 5 — its biggest one-day drop this year — and now trades near $886, more than 60% below its June peak. Wall Street says the selloff went too far. The chart, so far, disagrees.
The trigger was political, not operational. After the Nov 3 midterms, investors began pricing in delays to data center construction across the U.S. Fewer data centers means less demand for storage, and SanDisk took the hit in one brutal session.
Two major banks have now pushed back on that logic.
What Do the Analysts Actually See?
Fitzgerald puts SanDisk at 2.6 times expected 2028 earnings. For comparison, Nvidia trades at 9 times and Micron at 3 times on the same basis. Even within a chip sector that sold off together, SanDisk screens as the cheap name.
Fitzgerald also estimates $82 billion in cumulative free cash flow through 2028. That's the number Morgan Stanley leans on. The bank argues SanDisk could deploy that cash to buy back more than half of its own shares — a floor under the stock that the Nov 5 panic ignored.
Morgan Stanley called the market's reaction to the midterms overdone, on a specific reading of the facts: data center projects are being delayed, not cancelled. The demand hasn't vanished. It has slipped to the right on the calendar.
The takeaway: the banks' case is a valuation case, and it rests on profits that are still two-plus years out.
Why 'Cheap on Paper' Isn't Cheap Yet
Here's the catch, and it's a real one. The entire bull argument depends on 2028 earnings estimates, and memory prices can move those estimates a lot. In the storage business, pricing power swings fast in both directions. Cheap on paper is not yet cheap in price action.
The selloff also mixes two different things: a genuine policy shock, and a natural reset after a run to $2,350. Stocks that go vertical tend to give back more than the fundamentals alone would justify.
The next real data point arrives fast: Nvidia reports earnings on Nov 17. Its spending commentary is the clearest read-through for storage demand that exists. If Nvidia signals data center capex is holding, the delay narrative weakens; if it doesn't, the bears get fresh ammunition.
What Does the Chart Show?
The technical picture stays bearish while the fundamentals turn. SanDisk peaked near $2,350 in June, printed a lower high near $1,900 in September, and has fallen inside a descending channel ever since. The Nov 5 drop sliced down to roughly $800, right at the channel floor.
The rebound stalled at $1,000 last week — exactly where the fast EMA sits — and price has since pulled back to about $886. The 21 EMA sits at 980.23, below the 78 EMA at 1,260.35. Both are falling. Price is below both. RSI at 37.93 is weak but not oversold, meaning there's room to fall further before the technicals scream "exhausted."
The scenarios, laid out as conditions rather than recommendations:
- Base case: another rejection near $1,000, then a 4H close below $800 opens a path to $500 — the March low.
- Relief case: a 4H close above $1,000 targets $1,270, the upper channel line.
- The bearish view dies on a 4H close above $1,000. Until then, it's alive.
Key levels to watch: resistance at $1,000 (November high and fast EMA), $1,270 (slow EMA) and $1,600; support at $800 (November low, channel floor) and $500.
What Happens Next?
The timeframe here is tight — the next one to two weeks, with Nvidia's Nov 17 earnings as the deciding read-through for storage demand. The banks have made their valuation case at 2.6x 2028 earnings; the market now needs either a 4H close above $1,000 or a capex endorsement from Nvidia to believe it.
Source: tradingview.com
More from Grace Kim
Show full bio
Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,178 articles