Economy & Policy

Scotland's £1.5bn 'Kilt' Bond Plan Faces Cost and Credibility Questions

Scotland aims to raise £1.5bn by 2031 from its first 'kilt' bonds, but economists tell Holyrood they'll cost 0.3 points above gilts plus £2m per bond in admin fees.

By Grace Kim

3 min read

Gilts v kilts: What is happening with Scottish government bonds?
Gilts v kilts: What is happening with Scottish government bonds?wenzlerdesign / pixabay

What's News

  • Scotland targets £1.5bn from its first-ever 'kilt' bonds by 2031, issuance expected this financial year
  • Estimated interest rates would sit 0.3 percentage points above gilts, plus £2m per bond in administrative costs
  • Scotland's capital borrowing cap is £450m a year, roughly £491m inflation-adjusted this year, within a £3.3bn total limit
  • The government received a credit rating identical to the UK's in November 2024
  • Prof David McMillan warned bonds would lose credibility with investors if limited to five years

Scotland wants to raise £1.5bn by 2031 from its first-ever government bonds — but economists told Holyrood's finance committee this week that the plan will cost more than the borrowing routes London already provides.

The bonds, nicknamed "kilts" as a play on UK government "gilts", would let Scottish ministers borrow directly from investors, who receive regular interest payments and repayment at the end of an agreed term. The government expects issuance within this financial year, subject to market conditions.

The money is earmarked for long-term capital projects — building hospitals, maintaining roads — not day-to-day spending.

How did the 'kilts' plan start?

Former First Minister Humza Yousaf commissioned initial work in 2023, after the Scottish government's Investor Panel recommended making bonds available as a way to raise Scotland's profile and attract investment.

In November last year, the government announced it had received a credit rating identical to the UK's score. The rating rested on what the government described as "prudent fiscal management" and Scotland's economic stability — though ministers were warned the score could change if Scotland moved towards independence.

Market volatility driven by the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East has prompted questions about the timing. David McMillan, professor in finance and accounting at the University of Stirling, told MSPs the government should not wait for ideal conditions.

"You can't wait for a perfect time because there's going to be no perfect time," McMillan said.

How much can Scotland actually borrow?

The £1.5bn target is a fraction of the Scottish government's near £70bn budget. About four-fifths of that budget goes on resource spending — NHS funding, benefits payments and salaries — and Scotland cannot borrow for resource spending except to correct forecasting errors.

Capital spending is different. Scotland can borrow up to £450m a year at 2023-24 levels, capped at £3bn in total, with both limits uprated for inflation. Adjusted, that works out at roughly £491m of borrowing headroom this financial year and a total ceiling of about £3.3bn.

The bond programme therefore sits inside a tight envelope, not alongside open-ended borrowing.

What would the bonds cost?

Economists have noted that kilts would be a more expensive route than the UK government's National Loans Fund. Estimates put interest rates on Scottish bonds at 0.3 percentage points above gilts, plus an additional £2m per bond in administrative costs.

The Scottish government has not released costings, citing market sensitivities. It has insisted the bonds would represent value for money relative to borrowing through the UK scheme.

Ministers argue two benefits: the bonds would market Scotland to global investors, and they would build useful capability if Scotland became independent.

What did the experts tell MSPs?

Dr Ben Cormier, a senior lecturer at the University of Strathclyde's department of government and public policy, told the finance committee the bonds could cost marginally more than the UK scheme but would "bring flexibility to public finances and debt management".

McMillan backed the plans "in principle" — with one caveat. He warned the bonds would lose "credibility" with investors if limited to five years.

Cormier flagged the political risk plainly: independence was the one thing "that could materially change the nature of risk associated with Scottish bonds".

Conservative MSP Liam Kerr said the bonds could be more expensive than borrowing through the National Loans Fund and raised concerns about a lack of transparency in the programme.

McMillan agreed on disclosure. "You've got to have a clear, full and frank conversation with the public," he said.

With issuance expected this financial year and no published costings yet, the government's value-for-money claim is the number markets — and taxpayers — will press hardest.

Original: spice-spotlight.scot

Share this article:

More from Grace Kim

Grace Kim

Show full bio

Market editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,387 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »