Study Links Questions to Less Defensiveness and Openness to Agreement
Research in Social Influence says questions can ease defensiveness, build agreement and increase follow-through, giving leaders a practical alternative to forceful arguments.
By Daniel Okafor
4 min read

What's News
- A study published in Social Influence identifies the “question-behavior effect.”
- The effect links question-asking with reduced defensiveness and greater openness to agreement.
- The research also describes the “self-prophecy effect,” under which asking about likely action increases the chance of action.
- Haden’s process example asks how to eliminate steps and achieve easier, faster work.
By Daniel Okafor
A study published in Social Influence found that asking questions instead of providing answers can overcome defensiveness and increase openness to agreement. Researchers call this mechanism the “question-behavior effect.”
What changes when a leader asks instead of tells?
Jeff Haden, who wrote the expert commentary, said: “Data, logic, and reasoning are persuasive… but asking question is an even better way to eventually gain agreement.” His recommendation changes the sequence of a management conversation, not the quality of the underlying case. Leaders can keep their evidence while inviting the other person to solve the problem with them.
The target is practical: agreement that an idea makes sense, a goal is worth pursuing or an action should be taken.
Haden separates persuasion into two broad routes. Some people win agreement through charisma and personality alone. Less charismatic people rely on logic, data and reasoning. They may still press for agreement on the strength of irrefutable logic. The question-first method gives that group another way to present the same decision without treating disagreement as a contest.
He also draws a practical boundary. People cannot change their personalities overnight, he said, but they can change how they approach a conversation. That makes the method available to managers who do not expect to become more charismatic and whose case rests on facts rather than forcefulness.
How does a question replace a statement?
Haden’s process example begins with a change already expected to save significant time. A manager could explain the change to an employee, walk through data and projections, and argue for acceptance. Instead, the manager can ask: “Do you think there’s a way we could eliminate some steps so (this) was a lot easier and faster?”
The shift is operational. A statement can hand the employee a finished conclusion. The question exposes the same objective—less time, fewer steps, easier work—and gives the employee a role in identifying the route. The manager’s analysis remains available, but it supports an inquiry rather than replacing it.
The distinction also avoids turning every question into a disguised instruction. Although Haden does not prescribe a script beyond his example, his logic is specific: identify the result the process must deliver, then ask the employee how to remove friction. The conversation becomes a joint search for steps to eliminate rather than a presentation about steps already chosen.
Can asking questions change behavior as well as agreement?
The research also links question-asking to action. Haden describes this as the “self-prophecy effect”: asking someone how likely they are to do something makes them more likely to do it. The research compares that outcome with not asking at all, placing the behavioral change in the question itself.
The two effects address separate problems. The question-behavior effect concerns receptivity: whether another person will engage with a proposed idea. The self-prophecy effect concerns conduct: whether the person acts after answering. Confusing them would blur the mechanism, because the commentary presents one as a route around defensiveness and the other as a prompt toward follow-through.
Both begin with a question, although they do not promise the same result. A leader can use the first to open discussion about a process change and the second to ask about carrying it out. The wording helps determine how the other person receives the proposal and whether it becomes action.
What should leaders take from the study?
The strongest claim is procedural. Start with the outcome, then invite the other person to examine the path. Haden’s example targets a faster, easier process with fewer steps, and the question asks the employee to help find the route. The advice specifies what to do at the point of resistance.
Questions also shape conduct, not just agreement. This makes the wording of a likelihood question part of implementation rather than a separate courtesy. It also gives managers a way to test action without adding another lecture to a conversation already built around evidence and reasoning.
One caveat is the evidence presented in the commentary. The item names the journal and two effects but discloses no sample size, effect size, study date or research-team details. Its practical value comes from a clear mechanism and a concrete workplace example, not from a quantified estimate of how much agreement improves.
For Haden, the method adjusts ordinary leadership behavior rather than replacing it. He does not argue that data loses force. He argues that a question can carry data, reasoning and a desired outcome into a conversation with less defensiveness. Leaders can test the mechanism by removing one real process step, then tracking whether commitment and follow-through strengthen.
Source: inc.com
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,546 articles