Money & Markets

Tax Insurance Cuts Fund Wind-Down Risk for as Little as 3%

Tax liability insurance costs as little as 3% for low-risk positions and binds in weeks, letting PE and credit funds wind down without holdbacks or clawbacks over six-year IRS tails.

By Nathan Brooks

3 min read

Viewpoint: The Growing Role of Tax Insurance in Asset Management
Viewpoint: The Growing Role of Tax Insurance in Asset Management777546 / pixabay

What's News

  • Tax insurance for low-risk positions costs from 3% of exposure; insurable rates rarely hit double digits.
  • IRS audit window is generally 3 years, extending to 6 years for substantial income underreporting.
  • Coverage runs 7 to 10 years, matching statutes of limitations on contingent tax liabilities.
  • Policies can be bound in a few weeks, versus slow IRS private letter rulings.
  • Cover includes additional taxes, interest, penalties and defense costs.

Tax liability insurance for a low-risk position costs as little as 3% of the exposure, and rates for insurable positions rarely reach double digits. That pricing, according to a new industry viewpoint, is turning a little-known M&A tool into a fast-track mechanism for closing down alternative investment funds.

Most practitioners know tax insurance from mergers, acquisitions, company reorganizations, or insuring alternative energy tax credits. The product is far less familiar in asset management — yet it can be deployed to vastly speed up fund closings at minimal cost.

Why fund liabilities outlive the funds

Alternative investment funds typically run on a fixed clock. They spend the first few years buying illiquid assets, then the remaining years selling them off. Hedge funds can return investor cash regularly because they hold assets that are easy to sell. Private equity, credit, infrastructure and real estate funds can't — their assets must be sold opportunistically, so full liquidity is generally off the table.

That mismatch hits managers directly in the wallet. Fund managers earn performance bonuses — carried interest — based on how quickly they return cash to investors. To hit those targets, they'll advertise an expected investment period and fund lifespan, without making assurances, and investors can balk at committing without a sense of when they'll see returns.

The standard workaround is selling remaining assets to a continuation fund, often backed by a new group of investors or a subset of the original ones. But buyers of existing funds don't want to inherit old debts and risks, and tax liabilities are the worst offenders because of how long they linger.

How long is the tail?

In the US, the Internal Revenue Service generally has three years to audit a return. Substantially underreport income and that extends to six years. Ongoing disputes can drag on longer still if the IRS asks for more time to finish an audit or courts add delays. Contingent tax liabilities can therefore run six years or more due to statutes of limitations in certain US jurisdictions — years beyond a fund's intended life.

Certain liabilities can be cleared by simply paying the tax authority. Contingent risks tied to uncertain positions the fund took are the hard part. This, the viewpoint argues, is where tax insurance becomes "an alternative asset manager's best friend."

What does this change for fund managers?

In practical terms: speed and certainty. The insurance shifts the financial risk of a tax dispute from the fund and its investors to an insurer, covering additional taxes, interest, penalties and defense costs. Managers can close funds sooner without leaving money tied up in holdbacks or worrying about future clawbacks.

Speed matters here. Unlike IRS private letter rulings, which are slow, tax insurance can be bought in just a few weeks to lock in a tax position. The cost, at 3% for low-risk positions and rarely in double digits, means uncertain positions can often be mitigated for pennies on the dollar.

The structure suits end-of-life funds specifically. A fund pays a small one-time premium for coverage over seven to 10 years, after which statutes of limitations will generally have expired. If a claim starts during that window, coverage generally applies until a final determination or settlement. Once the premium is paid and the policy is bound, the fund can wind down and return investor proceeds far more easily.

The so-what

As alternative asset managers push to maximize investor returns and accelerate wind-downs, managing long-tail contingent liabilities is becoming a priority rather than an afterthought. Tax insurance transfers those risks to highly rated insurers, lets funds distribute capital with greater confidence, and cuts the need for extended holdbacks or clawbacks. For GPs sitting on an aging fund with a six-year tax tail, it's a way to close the book — and pay out carried interest — years earlier.

Source: insurancejournal.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

News editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,524 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »