Texas Supreme Court Leaves 'Death Star' Law Intact
Texas' highest court won't hear cities' challenge to the 2023 'Death Star' law blocking local rules on payday lending and water breaks. Democrats plan a January repeal push.
By Amara Osei
3 min read

What's News
- The Texas Supreme Court declined on Friday to hear a challenge to the 2023 law blocking local ordinances that exceed state rules.
- A Travis County judge ruled the law unconstitutional in August 2023 but let it take effect; the 3rd Court of Appeals later reversed.
- Houston, San Antonio and El Paso sued, citing the Texas Constitution's provision letting cities enact their own laws.
- Ordinances on noise levels and car towing have already come off the books under the law.
- Sen. José Menéndez has filed a repeal bill ahead of the January legislative session.
The Texas Supreme Court on Friday declined to hear a challenge to the state's sweeping 2023 law that blocks cities and counties from regulating payday lending, construction worker water breaks and other areas that clash with state oversight. The decision, announced by the court itself, leaves the statute — dubbed the "Death Star bill" by its critics — fully in force across Texas.
But the legal defeat isn't the end of the fight. Democrats, who now control the Texas House and hold statewide office, have set their sights on repealing the statute when the Legislature convenes in January.
What does the law actually do?
The law, enacted in 2023, makes it illegal for localities to enact local rules that go further than what's allowed under broad swaths of state law. Critics saw it as an attempt by GOP lawmakers to bar cities and counties from adopting progressive policies.
The list of policies caught in its net is concrete. Ordinances overseeing payday lending and mandatory water breaks for construction workers fall under its reach, as do other local rules that conflict with state oversight.
The consequences have already reshaped municipal rulebooks. Local ordinances regulating noise levels and car towing fell off the books as a result of the statute.
How did the court battle unfold?
A group of cities including Houston, San Antonio and El Paso had asked the Texas Supreme Court to overturn a lower court ruling that upheld the law's constitutionality. The court's refusal to hear the case means that lower court's ruling will stand — for now.
The litigation history stretches back to 2023. A Travis County judge ruled the law unconstitutional in August 2023 but allowed it to take effect anyway. Officials in Houston, San Antonio and El Paso then sued the state, arguing the law conflicts with a portion of the Texas Constitution that enables cities to enact their own laws.
The 3rd Court of Appeals overturned the lower court's ruling, finding that the cities hadn't proven how the bill might harm them or why the state was to blame. That appellate holding is now the last word on the constitutional question.
Who wanted the law, and why?
The statute had long been sought by Gov. Greg Abbott, Republican lawmakers and business lobbying groups. Their argument: the law was needed to stop cities and counties from adopting policies that could harm business owners and the state's economic growth.
Local officials see it differently. They complained that the law is overly broad, making it nearly impossible to know exactly which ordinances and regulations might now be illegal for localities to adopt. The statute has also stopped local officials, they said, from pursuing policies they worry could draw lawsuits under the law — a chilling effect that extends well beyond the rules already struck down.
What happens in January?
The political ground has shifted since the law passed. With Democrats now in charge of the Texas House and in statewide office, lawmakers will seek to repeal the Death Star bill next year.
Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa wants to see the law repealed, she told The Texas Tribune this week. State Sen. José Menéndez, a San Antonio Democrat, has already filed a bill to do exactly that.
The path runs through the Texas Senate, where the idea will likely face stiff resistance from the Republican majority that remains in control of the chamber. What the courts declined to settle, the 2027 legislative session now will — and business owners who backed the law are watching whether three years of state-level preemption survive the Democratic takeover.
Source: gilmermirror.com
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,503 articles