Strategy

The Transformation Economy: Why Selling Outcomes Beats Selling Products

"Experience Economy" coauthor Joe Pine says a fifth business type — transformations guiding customers to become healthy, wealthy, wise or meaningful — is now the biggest entrepreneurial opening.

By Amara Osei

4 min read

20 Years Ago, I Wrote ‘The Experience Economy.’ Now, a New Type of Business Is Everywhere.
20 Years Ago, I Wrote ‘The Experience Economy.’ Now, a New Type of Business Is Everywhere.RyanMcGuire / pixabay

What's News

  • Joe Pine coauthored "The Experience Economy" in 1999 and published "The Transformation Economy" with Harvard Business Review Press this year.
  • Howard Schultz turned a coffee goods manufacturer into roughly 40,000 Starbucks outlets worldwide.
  • In 2025, BetterUp launched AI coaches customized to each user's personality, learning style and organizational culture.
  • Pine identifies four transformation spheres — healthy, wealthy, wise and meaning — served by firms like Calibrate, Carefull, Echo360 and Modern Elder Academy.

Joe Pine, coauthor of the 1999 bestseller "The Experience Economy," argues that a fifth category of business — transformations — has become the most lucrative frontier for entrepreneurs. His new book, "The Transformation Economy: Guiding Customers to Achieve Their Aspirations," published this year with Harvard Business Review Press, makes the case in the November 2026 issue of Entrepreneur.

"If you help people become more healthy, wealthy, or wise, you are in the transformation business," Pine writes. His thesis: customers don't buy products for the products' sake. A wrinkle-free dress or a running watch is a means. What customers want are ends — to be effortlessly put-together and physically fit.

Why is this happening now?

Pine points to two forces. On the demand side, most consumers in developed countries already have their basic needs met. Research shows that once you're in that position, buying experiences makes you happier than buying more things — but happiness is fleeting, not a change in identity. On the supply side, business is a search for differentiation. As goods, services and even experiences become commoditized, companies find new openings in guiding transformations.

The precedent is well documented. In 1999, Pine and coauthor Jim Gilmore argued that experiences — "memorable events that engage each individual in an inherently personal way" — were an economic offering distinct from commodities, goods and services. Over the past 25 years, escape rooms, esports, immersive art, Meow Wolf, Topgolf, the Museum of Ice Cream and Sky Zone proved the point.

The corporate example Pine returns to is Howard Schultz, who acquired a coffee goods manufacturer and built it into roughly 40,000 Starbucks outlets worldwide. "It wasn't the coffee that was novel to most of its customers; it was the experience," he writes. A quarter century later, staging an experience is table stakes for almost any consumer-facing brand.

Where is the money flowing?

Pine organizes the transformation economy into four spheres: healthy, wealthy, wise — plus meaning. The habit-app market alone spans them all:

  • Eating: Noom, Fooducate, Lasta
  • Finance: Intuit Credit Karma, Goodbudget, EveryDollar
  • Learning: Quizlet, Memrise, Wisdom Quotes
  • Mindfulness: Aura, Calm, Headspace
  • Prayer: Hallow, PrayerMate, Abide
  • Habits themselves: Habitica, Habitify, Productive

AI is accelerating the shift. Pine frames it as IA — intelligent augmentation — supplementing human coaching with data-driven guidance at scale. In 2025, BetterUp, a platform connecting employees and individuals to coaches, added AI coaches customized to each user's "personality, preferred learning style, and organizational culture." The company said human and AI coaches would offer a "dynamic blend of support — from AI-powered insights available 24/7 to deep, meaningful connections with expert human coaches."

What do the winners look like?

In health, Pine highlights Calibrate, a weight-loss program that wraps GLP-1 medicines such as Wegovy into a full transformation: virtual diagnosis with a clinician, biweekly one-on-one coaching, personal goals across food, sleep, emotions and exercise, and a post-goal phase called "Sustaining." His pointed critique: GLP-1 manufacturers could have built such programs themselves. "With transformations, inputs don't matter, only outcomes," he writes.

In wealth, Carefull, a financial safety fintech, protects people — especially seniors — from scams, identity theft and their own mistakes, embedding its capabilities into banks, credit unions and insurers. Rocket Money tracks subscriptions and spending to make users "more financially savvy, aware, and in control."

In wisdom, Echo360 runs a customizable e-learning platform serving administrators, instructors and learners across education, corporate and government institutions.

In meaning, serial entrepreneur Chip Conley founded the Modern Elder Academy, where "midlifers" can, in his words, "reimagine and repurpose themselves: to create a life that's as deep and meaningful as it is long." Its science-based curriculum runs at campuses in Baja, Mexico, and Santa Fe, New Mexico, plus online programs, videos and a Wisdom Weekly newsletter.

What should entrepreneurs do?

Pine's strategic claim is blunt: big businesses will always win at pricing commodities, and manufacturers often have a blind spot, believing they're only in the manufacturing business. That leaves a huge opening for entrepreneurs to build transformations on top of large companies' goods — especially since digital tools let a small player gain big presence with small investment.

His closing metric reframes profit itself: "Profits are merely the measure of how well you foster human flourishing."

Original: info.entrepreneur.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,248 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »