Today's Leaders Are Becoming Tomorrow's Bad Role Models
Students are learning leadership from today's politicians, AI executives and university chiefs — and an analysis argues every category is failing the test, with two fixes proposed.
By Daniel Okafor
4 min read

What's News
- The analysis covers three domains of negative role models: politics, business and university leadership.
- Mean-spirited political rhetoric has risen over the past 10 years, the author argues.
- AI company heads are building resource-intensive data centers while ignoring economic, social and environmental costs.
- The essay defines healthy leadership through three components: vision, managing complexity, and principled communication.
- The author proposes two fixes: holding leaders accountable as role models, and teaching leadership as a counterweight.
Students in high school and college are right now forming their beliefs about how to lead, and the most prominent examples in politics, business and education give cause for concern about the future, argues a new analysis of leadership culture.
The essay's author points to role models as a core mechanism of learning. "Role models are an important part of the way we learn how a complex task should be handled," the author writes. Students may adopt the behaviors of prominent figures or react against them, but they internalize much of what they see in the people around them — and today's visible leaders, across three domains, are setting a poor standard.
What makes these role models negative?
Politics, the author argues, has supplied bad examples for a long time. For decades, politicians interviewed on television repeated talking points only vaguely related to the questions asked. Support for issues often depended more on party affiliation than on whether a position would produce a meaningful benefit. Over the past 10 years, the author adds, mean-spirited rhetoric has risen and devolved into name calling and insults rather than reasoned discussion of the issues of the day.
Business has fared no better in the last decade, according to the analysis. Prominent news stories focus on billionaires chasing additional profits while currying favor with political leaders. The heads of AI companies, the author notes, forge ahead with models that require resource-intensive data centers without letting concerns about the economic, social and environmental costs of the work influence the pace of development.
University leaders draw equally sharp criticism. Many universities have become highly politicized. Some leaders are so paralyzed by surrounding politics that they refuse to make any changes at all. Others push changes without bringing the community along and alienate students, staff and faculty in the process. The author's verdict is blunt: "None of these are examples of healthy leadership."
What does healthy leadership actually require?
Good leadership, the essay argues, involves three key components:
- Leaders must establish a vision for the future that brings people along and inspires them to engage in creating it.
- Leaders must grapple with the world's complexity and develop solutions that chart a course through competing priorities.
- Leaders must meet the moment in a principled way and communicate clearly about the factors driving the path forward.
The author draws a distinction specific to politics: campaigning can be won by emphasizing an opponent's negatives, while governing requires supporting a course of action that addresses key problems. In an era of perpetual campaigning, the author writes, it is difficult to find people who actually embrace a position and see it through.
Tradeoffs are the constant. Courses of action that are good for everyone all the time are rare, the essay notes. Great leaders recognize tradeoffs, find a reasonable compromise among them, and help the people they lead see the value of that path. They also commit to continuous improvement of outcomes even after implementing a change.
What is the path forward?
The first step, the author argues, is acknowledging the absence of great role models at present. Then two tasks follow.
First, leaders must be held accountable to be better examples. That should start with university leaders, who are all educators at heart: they must step back from the local politics of their position and remember that their actions are watched and may be emulated. Business and political leaders should be reminded that "winning is important, but how you win also matters," and encouraged to send the right message to those learning from their example.
Second, those who teach and write about leadership must provide a counterweight. Where key leadership skills are missing from current role models, the author writes, those figures should be used as examples of what not to do, and teachers should show how the short-term benefits of poor leadership produce long-term negative consequences.
The stakes will only grow. However complex the current moment seems, the author concludes, the future world will be more complicated still, shaped by climate change, globalization and artificial intelligence — and it will need leaders who unite people around a vision, a far different approach than the leaders dominating the news cycle right now.
Source: Fast Company
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Correspondent covering money, funding and market shifts around entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,189 articles