U.K. court orders confirmation of secret Apple backdoor order
U.K. tribunal orders the government to confirm a secret Apple encryption order, rejecting Home Office national-security objections. A hearing on releasable details is expected next year.
By Amara Osei
3 min read

What's News
- Thursday: The U.K. Investigatory Powers Tribunal ordered the government to confirm the secret Apple order.
- A year earlier: The U.K. government reportedly demanded worldwide access to Apple customer data.
- Apple refused the order and blocked Advanced Data Protection for U.K. users.
- The second order covered British nationals’ data in Apple’s encrypted cloud; Apple challenged it.
- Liberty International represented two individuals; a final hearing on releasable details is expected next year.
The U.K. Investigatory Powers Tribunal has ordered the government to confirm that it issued a secret order demanding Apple provide authorities with encrypted customer information. In its Thursday ruling, the independent court rejected the Home Office’s claim that disclosure would damage national security.
What does the ruling require?
The decision is a rare rebuke of the government’s effort to keep the order a state secret, requiring acknowledgment rather than immediate publication of every term. TechCrunch reported that a final hearing on which specific details can be released is anticipated next year. That hearing will determine how much of the government’s access demand enters the public record.
Who challenged the secrecy?
The U.K. Investigatory Powers Tribunal is an independent court that allows citizens to challenge government surveillance orders. Liberty International brought the legal challenge on behalf of two individuals.
Liberty said the ruling marked the first known time that the government had been compelled to confirm the existence of a secret technical order. The result compels acknowledgment of the government’s action without yet resolving what access the order sought.
What did Apple say?
Apple previously told TechCrunch that it has “never built a backdoor or master key” to any of its products or services and “never will.” An Apple spokesperson did not respond to TechCrunch’s request for comment after the ruling.
What did the government demand?
The ruling comes a year after the U.K. government reportedly demanded that Apple build a backdoor allowing U.K. authorities to access customer data anywhere in the world. Details of the so-called “technical capabilities notice” leaked to the media despite strict non-disclosure rules governing the instrument.
TechCrunch reported that the leak drew ire from White House officials and U.S. lawmakers. Those officials and lawmakers criticized the effort, arguing that the U.K. order would put Americans’ privacy at risk.
How did Apple respond?
California-based Apple refused the order. Instead of complying, the company blocked U.K. users from switching on Advanced Data Protection, its data-encryption feature for iCloud.
The Home Office later narrowed the secret demand to allow access to British nationals’ data stored in Apple’s encrypted cloud. Apple challenged that second order as well.
The revised request had a narrower subject than the reported original demand. It still targeted encrypted data, but applied only to British nationals whose information was stored in Apple’s encrypted cloud. Apple’s opposition covered both stages of the government’s request.
Why did the secrecy fight reach court?
Before Thursday’s ruling, Apple was legally barred from disclosing the order, even after details had leaked. That restriction remained in force after the leak, even as the order’s details circulated in media reports. The Home Office had also resisted disclosure on national-security grounds, a claim the tribunal rejected.
A Home Office spokesperson also did not respond to TechCrunch’s request for comment. The ministry had yet to confirm the notice’s existence. Its earlier insistence that disclosure would damage national security had already been rejected by the tribunal.
What happens next?
The ruling separates two questions that the secrecy dispute had kept joined: whether the government issued an order, and how much of it the public may see. The tribunal answered the first. TechCrunch reported that a final hearing on what specific order details can be released is anticipated next year.
That hearing will determine whether the government must publish more than confirmation of the narrowed demand. The public record currently contains the acknowledgment requirement but not the full access terms. The next-year hearing will decide whether that record extends to the substance of the U.K. government’s access demand.
Original: investigatorypowerstribunal.org.uk
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.
2,370 articles