Money & Markets

Visa, Mastercard Seek Approval of $38 Billion Settlement

Visa and Mastercard asked Judge Brian Cogan for final approval of a $38 billion merchant settlement. A 0.1-point fee cut faces more than 1,000 objections and a June 2024 rejection.

By Amara Osei

4 min read

Visa and Mastercard Seek to End 21 Years of Litigation
Visa and Mastercard Seek to End 21 Years of LitigationAI-generated

What's News

  • Visa and Mastercard asked Brooklyn Judge Brian Cogan on Monday for final approval of a $38 billion settlement.
  • The proposal cuts interchange fees by 0.1 percentage point over five years and caps standard consumer cards at 1.25% for eight years.
  • The $38 billion represents estimated merchant savings through 2031, not direct compensation.
  • US interchange fees from both networks reached $118.8 billion in 2025, up from $111.2 billion the previous year, according to the Merchants Payments Coalition.
  • More than 1,000 objections include Walmart and the National Retail Federation; a judge rejected an earlier $30 billion settlement in June 2024.

By Amara Osei

Visa and Mastercard asked a Brooklyn federal judge on Monday for final approval of a $38 billion settlement with merchants, ActivTrades analyst Ion Jauregui said. Merchants have accused the networks since 2005 of imposing excessive fees and restricting competition in card payments, according to Jauregui. He called the case one of the largest US financial-sector legal disputes.

Judge Brian Cogan has not ruled on the request, Jauregui said. Cogan warned that rejecting the settlement could prolong a legal process that has already lasted 21 years.

What changes for merchants?

The settlement would reduce interchange fees by 0.1 percentage point over five years and establish a 1.25% cap for standard consumer cards over eight years, Jauregui said. Under the proposal, merchants could choose whether to accept standard, premium and commercial cards, Jauregui said. That would give merchants greater control over their costs, according to ActivTrades.

The $38 billion figure does not represent direct compensation, Jauregui said. It represents ActivTrades' estimate of merchant savings through 2031.

What does the fee cut mean for network revenue?

ActivTrades cited Merchants Payments Coalition data showing that US interchange fees from both networks reached $118.8 billion in 2025, up from $111.2 billion the previous year. Despite regulatory pressure, ActivTrades said the networks continued to post strong financial results.

Visa closed fiscal year 2026 with net revenue of $45.9 billion, up 15%, and adjusted net income of $25.3 billion, Jauregui said. Mastercard reported third-quarter revenue of $9.8 billion, up 14% year-on-year, and adjusted net income of $4.7 billion, ActivTrades said.

Interchange fees mainly go to issuing banks, Jauregui said. A reduction in those fees therefore would not imply an equivalent revenue decline for Visa or Mastercard, according to ActivTrades.

Why do merchants oppose it?

The court has received more than 1,000 objections, including objections from Walmart and the National Retail Federation, Jauregui said. The retailers consider the proposed changes insufficient, particularly because high fees would continue to apply to certain cards, according to ActivTrades.

A judge rejected an earlier $30 billion settlement in June 2024, Jauregui said. The judge concluded that it did not introduce sufficient changes to the market, he added.

What do the charts show?

Both stocks retain a long-term bullish trend, ActivTrades said. Recent declines show lost momentum after strong gains in October and November, the analysis found.

Visa traded around $416.83, down 2.25%, according to ActivTrades. The shares remained above their 50-, 100- and 200-session exponential moving averages at $392.29, $378.01 and $347.96.

Visa's RSI fell to 54.5 points, while its MACD posted a bearish crossover, Jauregui said. First significant support sits at $392, with main resistance at $441.73, according to ActivTrades.

Mastercard fell 2.52% to $645.28 and showed a similar technical structure, ActivTrades said. Its exponential moving averages stood at $603.05, $581.01 and $542.99, while its RSI declined to 55.3 points and its MACD showed signs of weakness.

For Mastercard, first support sits at $603, with significant resistance at $680.79, according to ActivTrades.

What could settle the case?

Approval would help reduce legal uncertainty that has surrounded both companies for two decades, Jauregui said. Major retailer objections could still delay a final resolution, according to ActivTrades.

ActivTrades sees the broader stock trend as positive, though technical indicators point to possible consolidation. A correction would not necessarily compromise the bullish structure if Visa held above $392 and Mastercard held above $603, Jauregui said. A break below those levels would increase the risk of broader declines, according to ActivTrades.

What caveats accompany the analysis?

ActivTrades wrote, "The information provided does not constitute investment research." The firm said the material was not prepared under legal requirements designed to promote the independence of investment research and should be treated as marketing communication. ActivTrades said it keeps no record of its prices, makes no offer or solicitation, and gives no warranty of accuracy or completeness.

ActivTrades said it provides an execution-only service, and anyone acting on the information does so at their own risk. The firm said the material does not consider any recipient's investment objectives or financial position. It added that past performance and forecasting are not reliable indicators of future performance, political risk is unpredictable, central bank actions can vary, and platform tools do not guarantee success.

Visa and Mastercard face two concrete tests: Judge Cogan's approval would help reduce two decades of legal uncertainty, while a break below $392 for Visa and $603 for Mastercard would raise the risk of broader declines, ActivTrades said.

Source: tradingview.com

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in entrepreneurship, startups and venture funding at Business Bearings.

2,248 articles

Related articles

« Previous articleNext article »